MQL5 Algo Trading community — forex forum for traders and developers

What if you trade at the wrong time? So, I was trying to pass my first prop-firm challenge. My trading system was actually pretty decent giving me 64% winrate with RR 1/3. But I lost my challenge. I didn't know why because my live broker account gave me +9.13% of profit monthly . Most of my trades
Dear Members, I am investigating a reproducible tick-data discrepancy in MetaTrader 5 using read-only native MQL5 and Python tests. Environment Broker server: FOREX.comGlobal-Demo 531 Account type: Demo Symbol: EURUSD Test date: November 9, 2026 Platform: MetaTrader 5 for Windows Native methods
I've been testing simple "fade the stretch" ideas on XAUUSD M15 and I'm stuck on something. Hoping someone here can help me understand it. I tried entries when price is far from the daily VWAP, at Bollinger 2.5σ, and on RSI(2) extremes, with TP 1 ATR and SL 2 ATR. Win rate is around 60–63%, but
Nobody has ever had a bad backtest. How much forward testing is required before you would trust an EA? I have a method that I believe was derived from very sound statistical principles but no-one believes backtests (perhaps rightfully so). How much forward testing to establish credibility? Thanks
  signals question  (6)
I only see like 5 signals in the signal tab on metatrader
I’m running low on disk space and found two MetaTrader 5 folders taking up a lot of room: C:\ProgramData\MetaQuotes\ML is about 4.22 GB C:\Users\<me>\AppData\Roaming\MetaQuotes is about 3.3 GB What is the ProgramData\MetaQuotes\ML folder used for, and is it safe to delete? I don’t use any Python or
Hi everyone, I'm curious about how most developers and algo traders here structure their testing workflow in the MT5 Strategy Tester. When optimizing an EA—especially on volatile symbols like XAUUSD—running full optimization with "Every tick based on real ticks" can be very slow. On the other hand
Hi, I see a new version indicator on MQL5, but the Update button isn't appearing in MetaTrader 4. I have already restarted both MT4 and my computer, and the issue persists. Could you please help me resolve this? Thank you. MQL5 Meta4
  GOLD, Gold and XAUUSD  (1560   1 2 3 4 5 ... 155 156)
Hi! Is it worth buying gold at 1130
  Contrast  (5)
Hello, I reinstalled MT5 on my mobile, but now is the contrast of the candles much lower and the settings are doing exactly the same thing... how do I get them right again? First screenshot is the new one and not good and second one is good
Hello MetaQuotes team, I need an authoritative, source/runtime-specific clarification for private, non-commercial scientific validation in the forksAi-personal project. Exact environment: Server=MetaQuotes-Demo Company=MetaQuotes Ltd. Symbol=EURUSD Terminal build=6204 MetaTrader5 Python
  Messaging System  (4)
Hello, I keep getting a " WebSocket connection to 'msg1.mql5.com' failed " error when I try to view my messages. I just want to ascertain if this is a me problem or if everyone is getting it? Thanks, Rob
  MT5 and MT4 EA's  (2)
I Want to know: Am i allowed to have two of the Same EA's on my sellers page: 1X for MT5 and one for 1X MT4 as they are different languages
Hello, I am the seller of product 202121. I need help obtaining enough information to reproduce an automatic Market validation result locally. Version 1.30 passed automatic validation. Version 1.41 completed the four tests listed below, but failed with one reported error. The report dated 18
Use detailed Nasdaq data to enhance your trading strategies through more accurate decision-making and efficient risk management. This is a unique opportunity for those looking to improve their results. Unlike traditional minute or hourly bars, the subscription offers access to tick data, providing
[Deleted]
  Automated Vs Manual Trader  (27   1 2 3)
On my opinion, “Automated Trading Systems” does notpay attention to the Ratios. However, by automating your system there are zerochances of falling in love for a deal, which is good since no one is lookingfor love here! In the other hand, very few traders can actually automatesomething different....
Hello traders, I have been working on algorithmic strategies for XAUUSD (M15 timeframe), and one of the biggest challenges I face is controlling drawdown while maintaining solid profitability. In your experience: - What risk management techniques work best for gold? - Do you prefer fixed lot or
  Clarifying XAUUSD spread  (15   1 2)
Please somebody help me with this. I know that this is a simple and basic ,maybe even stupid question to ask ,but it still give me a headache. Anyway , here it is: What is a tipical(average,expected whatever you want to call it) spread on XAUUSD preferably on ECN type accounts. Of course ,i know it
I've been thinking about market regimes lately and I'm starting to question how we normally build EAs. Most strategies are basically built around the assumption that the market behaviour we see in the backtest will continue to exist in the future. But we all know that isn't always the case. A trend
We run a small MT5 stack with a 1 % daily loss cap. It had been in place for months and we trusted it. Replaying our own history, a day where every stop gaps at its instrument’s 99th percentile reaches 13.84 % of equity . Not 1 %. The cause is simple once you see it: the limit counts the stop, not
Modifying A Good Trading Strategy Prematurely. Strategies will often go through a losing period but the issue comes down to knowing when a change has occurred. Many traders will try to tweak indicators, add filters or change entry rules after a few losing trades. This can cause overfitting of your
Hi everyone, I’m working on an automated interpretation of a trendline trading approach in MQL5 and would appreciate technical feedback on how to validate its behavior in the MT5 Strategy Tester . The strategy inspiration comes from Tori Trades’ video, “Once you master this strategy, trading becomes
I run an LLM-driven intraday scalper on MT5 (demo). Over 60 closed trades it lost $212, and commission alone was 40% of that loss. Before asking "how do I make it profitable", I spent two weeks trying to establish whether it has any directional edge at all. It does not — and I want a sanity check
  Trading System by Xard777  (3901   1 2 3 4 5 ... 390 391)
Here is a suggestion for a possible trading system... System one is MT4-Xard777.rar and System two is XARD-BOX.rar Enjoy... All the best Xard777
I was testing a daily loss lock in the Strategy Tester (100,000 account, 5% daily limit = 5,000, lock set at 90% of the limit). With "1 minute OHLC" the lock fired late: the day closed at 105% of the limit. With "Every tick based on real ticks" it locked at 90.0% (−4,501), exactly as designed. The
Hi all, Recently i tried to optimize a strategy, i choose the fast genetic optimization since the number of passes where high. I used the system resources and also the MQL5 cloud network at the same time. Local optimization is working fine, but the cloud optimization is failing. In the Journal the
Has anyone actually used an EA for passing their prop firm challenge and maintaining their prop firm accounts over a long period of time? If so, do you have proof? Trade history on myfxbook, for example? Thanks
Hello! In the Marketplace at mql5.com you can download a demo version that only works in the strategy tester . Many clients do not consider the Strategy Tester as a valid proof and have doubts about the robot's efficiency. Can I place a link to the trading robot demo version in the product
  VPS server  (89   1 2 3 4 5 ... 8 9)
What kind of vps do you use? Maybe some cheap and reliable advice for 5-10 terminals
  The Only Pivot  (2695   1 2 3 4 5 ... 269 270)
Shinigami ask me to put my latest indicators and templates.. so if you are new for reading this thread, please use this indy and template because this is what i use now after download this zip file, just go to page number....... (i forgot, sorry ) the rule is using h1 1. if 2 SMMA WEIGHTED CLOSE...
Hi, I have recently started learning MQL5 language and all the tutorials are only focused on Forex market. I have been trading Futures contracts(manually) with <Deleted>. So, my question is If i keep learning Mql5 language, will I be able to develop EA for Futures market(with <Deleted>)? Thank you
I'm trying to figure out if I can have a list of all my trades for the same utensils separate rather than one bulk position in the tool box/terminal box. Is this even possible? Thanks
What is your Preffered Syle of trading? Swing Day Or Scalping? What EA would you prefer for developers to make you assuming All of the work and are profitable
  Welcome to the new section!  (15   1 2)
Inspired by comments and reviews received from MQL5.community members, we have added a new forum section called "Trading stocks, futures, options and other exchange instruments". Share your ideas and trading experience with the website visitors. Reach out to MetaTrader 5 developers if you have...
Hi, Can someone please let me know how to use Metatrader5 to trade in stocks in NSE and/or BSE stock markets in India? Thanks, Amitabh
Hello, Can any one please suggest me the best indicator for binary options trading? Thanks...
  Simple trade automation?  (19   1 2)
I used to use metatrader4 when I was messing with Forex, but I have funds that I'd like to use out of my stock porfolio to trade one particuarl stock which goes up and down $1-2/day pretty much all the time. I'd like to set metatrader up to say, sell at a certain price, then buy at $2.00 lower, then
Dear all, I am trying to import historical data (M1) to MT5 from my Tradestation account. I have export the data in csv format and below there are some rows as example: "Date","Time","Open","High","Low","Close","TotalVolume" 1/2/2008,03:01:00,3841.00,3842.25,3840.25,3841.75,184
  Nasdaq  (6)
Does anyone here trade Nasdaq? What leverage do you get from your broker
  BTC  (11   1 2)
Does anyone here trade BTC
Hi All How do I add the NSE Indian Market- Stocks and Futures into the MT5 market watch. Thanks a ton for your help. Regards Praveen
  MT5 and NSE  (5)
what is the procedure to add symbol from NSE to MT5 marketwatch and start trading NSE option trading and back test
  Who are the resistance?  (19   1 2)
If BTC/USD has support at $68,000 and resistance at $70,000, what type of group or person would keep dumping at $70,000 when they make very little profit from a buy at $69,000
For the past weeks I've been developing an EA based on SMC, multitimeframe liqquidity-sweep: Stats are good IMO, DD < 10%, good sharpe ratio, etc... But I question myself about this being more stable? Such as diversifying. My main problem is choosing a variety of pairs, i.e: EUR/USD GPB/USD USD/JPY
I want to demo Options board on MT5 but cant find ANY one who offers it? Where can i try the MT5 options board? Who is currently demo/ real trading with MT5 options platform? its ridiculous i cant find ANY information on how to actually do it/ who offers it. Its almost as if it doesnt exist/ noone
Many prop-style rules measure the daily loss limit from midnight on the broker's server clock and include floating P/L (equity), not only closed trades. Below is the approach we use in an EA to get the day's starting balance and the running result for the day, closed plus open, without storing
Could you clarify the official process exit-code meaning for MetaEditor64.exe version 5.0.0.6308? I ran a single-file compile using /compile:"BTC_Scalper_Auth5_ReadOnly.mq5" /log:"metaeditor_compile.log" . The log reports code generated , 0 errors , and 0 warnings , and a fresh EX5 was created
Hello everyone, I’m investigating an initialization failure during automatic Market validation of my MT5 Expert Advisor, The 500 Calabash EA, version 1.65 . test on EURUSD,H1 (hedging) tester stopped because OnInit returns non-zero code 1 disconnected there are no trading operations The validation
If this topic is not allowed please delete it. I am only asking purely for educational reasons. Not for intent. It was the case that since 2016 there was not solid proof that MT5 ex5 cannot be converted to MQL5 . In fact there were so many scam services offering that. This is what I would also say
Feature Request: Introduce Full Expert Advisor (EA) Support in MetaTrader 5 for Android To: MetaQuotes Development Team Dear MetaQuotes Team, I am writing to propose an important improvement to the MetaTrader 5 Android application. I would like MetaQuotes to introduce native Expert Advisor (EA)
Hello. In a newly installed terminal, WebRequest() returns 1009 and GetLastError() returns 5203 for one domain. Another terminal on the same VPS reaches the same domain without any problem. I tested with a simple GET script on a live chart, and the results are below. Terminal A (build 6295 , newly
Hello, We are preparing two local MT5 Strategy Tester runs on build 6230 using “Every tick based on real ticks” (Model 4). Both use RoboForex Demo ECN hedging, EURUSD and USDCHF, and the historical period from 17 August 2020 through 13 August 2021. The planned difference is the fixed execution
Hi everyone, there were a few threads here lately about backtest vs live. Most ask why the two differ. I'd like to ask something a bit different: how do you notice it early enough? What I do with my EAs is pretty simple. I run the backtest over the same weeks as the live trades, on my broker's
Running 2 EAs on MT5 via VPS. Recently had one go quiet for about 3 days — no crash, no errors in Experts or Journal, smiley face still there, terminal connected. It just stopped taking trades. I only found out because I manually check the accounts every few days. Could easily have been longer
The given errors are: 'iMA' - wrong parameters count ThreeMA_Strategy_EA.mq5 76 22 'iMA' - wrong parameters count ThreeMA_Strategy_EA.mq5 77 22 'iMA' - wrong parameters count ThreeMA_Strategy_EA.mq5 79 22 'iMA' - wrong parameters count ThreeMA_Strategy_EA.mq5 81 23 'iMA' - wrong parameters count
Hi, I am totally new in MT5 Python API and I hope, my question is quite trivial - I couldn't find anything: How to install a MT5 listener so the Python script gets notified, once a trade was closed by a S/L or limit order? Is there a sample somewhere? Which functions to use? Thx
my code below iStart2Lots should equate to 0.10 -- however when trade opens, the lot is 0.09. why oh why? please explain, and how to ensure the result is correct -- 0.10? input double iStartLots = 0.25 ; // 1st Trade Lot double iStart2Lots = . 4 *iStartLots; //0.10; // 2nd Trade Lot what
  trend indicator  (2)
Hello, i have easy trend indicator. ( attached picture ) It only write sell/buy signal does not make auto trading. Is there a way to make it auto ?Best
Let's look at the results of the tests on one and a few characters. The tests will be conducted in All ticks mode. You can use your own multisymbol EA schemes to reproduce the problem and share your results. Let us denote the problem. For example, if you test one symbol, the test time takes 1
  NFP news filter  (4)
Why didn't my EA get triggered during the NFP news release, even though it doesn't use a news filter? Can anyone help me understand why this happened
  Pivot indicators  (761   1 2 3 4 5 ... 76 77)
Everything about pivot indicators you may find in this thread. Besides there are some usefull links as well: - how to trade with pivot (manuals) is here . - some trading system based on pivot https://www.forex-tsd.com/forum/trading-systems/1158-pivot-system - pivots, camarilla, high/low etc.... is
  Everything about RSI  (1470   1 2 3 4 5 ... 146 147)
RSI indicator We are continuing discussion about the indicators. We have the following thread: Parabolic SAR indicator Momentum indicator Stochastic Oscillator Divergence Indicator Now we are talking about RSI. "Technical Analysis from A to Z": Overview The Relative Strength Index ("RSI") is a
Equidistant ChannelStandard Deviations ChannelLinear Regression ChannelAndrew's Pitchfork (let it be too)Another channel. Will write about it in the commentsNoneI do not have an opinion on the topicI just want to see the answer
[Deleted]
  SuperTrend  (263   1 2 3 4 5 ... 26 27)
I've developed a new SuperTrend indicator. It works the same as the ProRealTime version where you can set the 'Nbr Periods' and 'Multiplier' values. Bear in mind that because of differences between brokers that in places it may change direction earlier or later than the ProRealTime version if you...
  Current spread and swap monitor  (43   1 2 3 4 5)
been asked for this a couple of times by pm,so here it is
  Parabolic SAR indicator  (299   1 2 3 4 5 ... 29 30)
I am continuing posting information about indicators. So, we have information about Stochastic indicator https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/177239 We have the thread about Momentum indicator https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/176430 Now something about Parabolic SAR. OverviewThe Parabolic Time/Price System,...
Why the version of MT5 backtest speed such slow, I pend it over night(~8 Hours), only 1 pass finished but I have brought a new cpu, the usage of CPU keep only 11%
My intention of the code below is to display 3 periods of moving average lines for the range of bars specified by chart window width. Although first period of line is drawn properly, succeeding 2 period lines fail to draw due to CopyBuffer error (4806 : Requested data not found). I cannot figure out
Repainting indicators look perfect in history and useless in live trading. Here is a check anyone can run without any tools. 1. Screenshot the last 20 signals today. 2. Wait for 3 new bars - do not reload the chart. 3. Screenshot again and compare. If an arrow moved, disappeared, or appeared late
Hi! I'ld like to be able to draw some rectangles that are gonna mark support and resistances zones that may take lots of bars to be crossed, thus being relevant for a lot of time. In my tool, I do that by extending the final points of the rectangle to a whole new year in the future: The problem is
  Oscillators  (50   1 2 3 4 5)
Does anyone have a large collection of oscillators (works best in a trading range) that he/she put together? Maybe we could start a thread where all oscillators are gathered. And let's go a little beyound RSI and Stochastic
Why is it that MT5 has a white flicker when you change timeframes while MT4 operates smoothly? Is it because the charts in MT5 are not preserved and are rebuilt every timeframe switch? How does this affect the objects in the charts? Is there a way, or can you make a way to make the chart engine the
Most of the repainting complaints I see in this section come down to one assumption, not to the detection logic or the buffer handling. MetaTrader hands OnCalculate its price arrays oldest to newest. Not series, not reversed, not newest first. Index 0 is the oldest bar currently loaded, and index
Hi, i'm trying to create an indicator with claude ai help, and it's almost works well, this code is intended to draw a plot arrow into the particular candle as a signal based on stochastic level the only issue i face is the signal only appear on previous candle that already formed, meanwhile for the
  Kalman Filter  (5)
I'm looking for someone that feels the have developed a good working Kalman Filter Model to use in the fx market
Check out the new article: Developing a Multi-Currency Expert Advisor (Part 32): Secrets of the Optimization Project Creation Step (II) . The article discusses the parameters of the second stage of the automatic optimization pipeline for a multi-currency Expert Advisor. We analyze the criteria for
Trade Journal Exporter - closed trades to CSV, one row per position, with MFE/MAE, R multiple and session : Exports your closed trade history to a CSV file with one row per position (not per deal), ready for Excel, Python or any journal. Each row has ticket, symbol, magic number, comment, side
Rollover Cost Table - swap mode from the symbol, triple-swap day from the broker : An MQL5 indicator that draws a table on the chart with one row per open position and shows what one more night of holding it costs, in the deposit currency where the symbol's swap mode allows it. The swap mode and the
Trailing Stop Manager - ATR, Chandelier, swing, SAR, MA, break-even with costs : Trails the stop loss of open positions with one of seven methods plus a break-even that includes the commission. Moves a stop only on a real improvement, never back, respects stop and freeze levels, limits requests
EventTracer : An Expert Advisor for MetaTrader 5 that prints one line each time one of its event handlers runs, on a chart, in the Strategy Tester and during an optimization. It never trades. Author: Rico Hehl
Volume Profile with Naked POC - day, week, month or year profiles built from M1 bars : Volume profiles per day, week, month or year with POC, value area high and low (classic two-rows method), naked POC lines that stay until price trades through them, and a developing POC. Built from M1 bars. 8
Check out the new article: Offline Reinforcement Learning in MQL5: Conservative Q-Learning from Historical Trade Logs Without Live Exploration . Build and deploy a conservative, offline‑trained policy entirely in MQL5. Logged trades become a fixed dataset for a two‑layer Q‑network trained with
Gold Session Liquidity Free MT4 - XAUUSD Sessions, Sweeps and Risk Planner : Free MT4 XAUUSD analysis indicator: completed Asian range, closed-bar liquidity sweeps, swing structure breaks, London/New York session context, H1 EMA trend and manual lot-risk planner. No automatic orders or guaranteed
Gold Session Liquidity Free MT5 - XAUUSD Sessions, Sweeps and Risk Planner : Free XAUUSD MT5 indicator with Asian session High/Low, closed-bar liquidity sweeps, swing structure breaks, EMA trend context and a manual lot-size risk planner. No automatic trading or guaranteed profit. Author: Sondang
Murrey Math Line X MT5 : Murrey Math Line X MetaTrader indicator — a pivot line indicator that will definitely help every trader who knows how to trade with support, resistance, and pivot lines. It displays 8 primary lines (with 5 more additional ones) on the main chart, helping you to find the best
Check out the new article: Neural Networks in Trading: Bidirectional Adaptive Temporal Correlation (Conclusion) . The BAT framework transforms a chaotic stream of market data into accurate forecasts and well-informed trading decisions. Backtesting shows steady capital growth with controlled risks
Check out the new article: Native SFTP Client in MQL5: Uploading Trade Reports over SSH Without External Tools . Send MetaTrader 5 trade reports to an SFTP server without WinSCP or external scripts. A pure-MQL5 SSH/SFTP client uses host-key pinning, safe packet handling and a temporary “.part” swap
Check out the new article: How Far Away Is the Stop-Out? A Stop-Out Threshold Finder and Pre-Trade Guard in MQL5 . CStopOutGuard shows how far a symbol's price can move before the modeled margin level reaches stop-out, and how much closer a planned order would bring that threshold. Positions are
Check out the new article: Price Action Analysis Toolkit Development (Part 65): Building an MQL5 System to Monitor and Analyze Manually Drawn Fibonacci Levels . The Fibonacci retracement tool is an essential component of price action analysis, providing critical levels for potential market
New article An Expert Advisor Made to Order. Manual for a Trader has been published: Not all traders are programmers. And not all of the programmers are really good ones. So, what should be done, if you need to automate your system by do not have time and desire to study MQL4? Author: Andrey...
The MetaTrader 4 platform update will be released on Friday , March 1, 2024. This version provides error fixes and platform stability improvements. The update will be available through the Live Update system
I have 4 MT4 terminals, with 15 charts per terminal. I've been updating my trading system lately. One of the measures I took was to reduce the number of indicators on each chart, thinking that this would make my system snappier. To this end, I coded one indicator to have multiple buffers and display
Hello everyone, I'm having an issue with MT4 MetaEditor when trying to compile an EA using MQL5 Cloud Protector. The MQL5 Community login window keeps asking for my password in an endless loop, even though I'm entering the correct credentials. The same account and password work perfectly in MT5
  Expert Advisor  (7)
Hello I'm looking for the proper way to call a .ex4 indicator with no source code in my Expert advisor. I'm having issues with the inputs and line index
  Metatrader 5 app  (4)
Hallo, I am from the Netherlands and trying to create a new account in my MetaTrader 5 app. Not a Demo account but a live trading account. I don’t see an option anywhere in the app to create a live trading account. Nothing. Could anyone please tell me how I can open a live trading account, or
Hello, How can I switch the virtual hosting signals (VPS) from one live account to another live account for the MetaTrader 4 software without deleting my data subscription? Since I have a 6-month contract, I do not want to lose the money I have already paid and therefore would like to use the
Hi everyone i have a problem i bought a new vps and i cant login my mql5 account on the mt5 i have logged in my trading account but mql5 account login is giving error login failed and in journal it says mql5.community authorization failed i have tried everything Microsoft WebView 2 reinstalled mt 5
  Off-topic posts  (1882   1 2 3 4 5 ... 188 189)
Comments that do not relate to the " Ask for help ", have been moved into this topic
  Android  (1)
How do i create a different line in my Moving Average in my Android phone
Hi All, I am trying to set up an outlook email under TOOLS>OPTIONS>EMAIL but am having issues I keep getting the error " Mail: login to smtp-mail.outlook.com:587 failed", I have also tried using smtp.office365.com:587 instead of smtp-mail.outlook.com:587 but it still comes back with the same error
  Spread Indicator  (29   1 2 3)
Hi traders, several times traders from forums ask if there is an indicator simply showing the current pair's spread. I already programmed such an indicator for my own use and decided to contribute it to the community. Feel free to comment! By the way, it's also posted @ codebase.mql4.com Indicator...
  Interesting and Humour  (49803   1 2 3 4 5 ... 4980 4981)
Members of the forum, don't forget to follow the rules
Programmatically placed arrow objects work but interfere in readying the chart. The common function below, in hopes to disabled it, can't handle dismissing it. ObjectSetString ( 0 ,sName, OBJPROP_TOOLTIP , "" ); In the object you drawn manually for example, this is what you see,. I have indeed seen
Hello, I need help retrieving missing EURUSD M1 history for an MT4 Strategy Tester backtest. My setup: Broker: OANDA U.S. Platform: MT4 running in Windows 11 through Parallels on a Mac. Required history: September 1–October 23, 2026, including September for indicator initialization. In my October
Hello, Do you listen any music while you trade? I have tried with many different kinds, but I think classical music is the most appropriate to remain discipline focus and calm . Any replies are appreciated. Let's start