MiniBull Logical — Multi-Timeframe Trend Scanner & MA Reversal Dashboard | Non-Repainting
MiniBull Logical v21 — Symbol & Timeframe Guide
══════════════════════════════════════════════════
Strategy: MN1/W1 Trend + D1 False Breakout + Multi-TF MA Reversal
Backtest Period: 2024.07.01 – 2026.02.03
Settings: $10,000 Deposit | 1:10 Leverage | Lot 0.1/0.01 | 100ms Delays
Modelling: Every tick based on real ticks
Total: 20 Symbols | 222 Files | 26,784 Trades | 10/20 Profitable
BT→FWD Validation: 56/110 chart TFs confirmed, 22 overfit detected
Crisis Resilient: $2,755 across 11 events (best: Liberation Day Tariffs $2,830)
⚠️ ALL TESTS WERE CONDUCTED WITH EMA(20). SMA and KAMA have NOT been fully tested.
MiniBull Logical Indicator (v22)
MiniBull Logical is a multi-timeframe signal indicator for MT5 based on three confluent conditions: monthly and weekly trend direction, D1 false breakout detection, and multi-timeframe moving average reversal confirmation.
How it works: The indicator compares current price against the previous MN1 and W1 closing prices to determine the dominant trend. It then monitors whether price has broken outside the previous D1 high/low range and reversed back inside. A signal is only generated when a moving average reversal (SMA, EMA, or KAMA) is confirmed on at least one of seven timeframes: M15, M30, H1, H4, H8, H12, D1.
Features:
- Three MA types: SMA, EMA, Kaufman Adaptive MA (KAMA)
- Proximity warning when price approaches W1 or MN1 close levels
- On-chart BUY/SELL signal labels
- Built-in alert and push notification support
- HTF data availability check with Experts log diagnostic
- Strategy Tester support with CSV signal export and multi-stage performance evaluation
- Clean dark-themed panel with full market context
Recommended: NAS100, M15 chart. Default parameters optimized for NAS100 M15 (2024–2026).
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
⚙️ INPUT PARAMETERS (Backtest Settings)
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
Parameter │ Value
──────────────────────────────┼───────────────────────────────
=== MA Settings === │
MA Type (SMA/EMA/KAMA) │ Exponential Moving Average (EMA) ← TESTED
MA Period │ 20
KAMA Fast Period │ 2 (not fully tested)
KAMA Slow Period │ 30 (not fully tested)
MA Touch Zone (ATR mult.) │ 0.5
=== Trend Proximity === │
Proximity Warning (ATR mult.) │ 1.5
=== Backtest Only === │
Eval Period 1 (bars) │ 5
Eval Period 2 (bars) │ 10
Eval Period 3 (bars) │ 20
=== Panel === │
Panel X position │ 10
Panel Y position │ 165
=== Alerts === │
Alert on signal │ true
Push notification on signal │ true
Note: MA Type supports SMA, EMA, and KAMA. Only EMA(20) has been backtested.
SMA(20) and KAMA(20,2,30) may produce different results and should be tested
separately before live trading.
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
✅ RECOMMENDED — USE THESE SYMBOL + TF COMBOS
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
(Tested with: EMA(20) | MA Touch Zone: 0.5×ATR | Proximity: 1.5×ATR)
NAS100 (+$2,373) — Grade B
Use: M5, M15*, M30, H1, H4 (all FWD confirmed)
Best: M15 → 57% WR, +$711
Note: Strong across all timeframes. Top performer.
BTCUSD (+$1,231) — Grade C
Use: M30, H1*, H4, H8 (all FWD confirmed)
Best: H1 → 61% WR, +$705, A grade
Note: Excellent on H1. Avoid M1/M5.
FRA40 (+$376) — Grade C-
Use: M30, H1, H4, H8* (all FWD confirmed)
Best: H8 → 58% WR, +$210, A grade
Note: Higher TFs only. M15 and below all negative.
US500 (+$353) — Grade C
Use: M30, H1* (FWD confirmed)
Best: H1 → 56% WR, +$134, B grade
Note: H4/H8 positive but OVF. Stick to M30/H1.
XAUUSD (+$343) — Grade B
Use: M1, M5, M15*, M30, H8 (all FWD confirmed)
Best: M15 → 57% WR, +$470, B grade
⚠️ Avoid H1 ($-372) and H4 (38% WR, $-289)!
AUDUSD (+$192) — Grade B
Use: M15, M30, H1*, H4 (all FWD confirmed)
Best: H1 → 56% WR, +$56, B grade
Note: Most consistent symbol. All TFs profitable + confirmed.
USDCAD (+$88) — Grade C
Use: M30*, H1 (FWD confirmed)
Best: M30 → 54% WR, +$72, B grade
Note: Avoid M15 (OVF) and H4 (negative).
ORCL.US (+$33) — Grade C-
Use: H1, H4* (FWD confirmed)
Best: H4 → 88% WR, +$17, A+ grade
Note: Very high WR on H4 but low trade count.
NFLX.US (+$8) — Grade B
Use: M15* (only FWD confirmed TF)
Best: M15 → 50% WR, +$3
Note: M30/H1 look good but are OVF. Use M15 only.
AAPL.US (-$3) — Grade D
Use: M30* (FWD confirmed)
Best: M30 → 59% WR, +$1, A grade
Note: A grade on M30 but very low PnL. Use with caution.
* = Optimal TF
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
⚠️ CAUTION — LIMITED USE
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
UK100 (-$36) — Grade D
Use only: M30, H4, H8* (FWD confirmed)
Best: H8 → 52% WR, +$190
⚠️ SELL direction loses $-173. Overall in loss.
GBPUSD (-$220) — Grade D
Use only: H8 (+$41) — but NOT FWD confirmed
⚠️ All other TFs negative. SELL direction: $-300.
EURUSD (-$122) — Grade D
Use only: H4 (+$6, FWD confirmed) — marginal
⚠️ SL/TP issue. Both directions in loss.
US30 (-$431) — Grade D
No reliable TF. M15/M30/H1 show profit but are OVF.
⚠️ SELL direction massive loss: $-1,964.
AMZN.US (+$3) — Grade C
Too few trades (36). No reliable TF.
⚠️ Not enough data to trust.
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
🔴 AVOID — DO NOT USE THESE SYMBOL + TF COMBOS
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
Symbol │ Avoid TFs │ Reason
────────────┼─────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────
NAS100 │ M1 │ 49% WR, $-19, D grade
BTCUSD │ M1, M5 │ M1: 45% WR $-336 | M5: 49% WR $-197
FRA40 │ M1, M5, M15 │ All below 44% WR, negative PnL, OVF
XAUUSD │ H1, H4 │ H1: $-372 | H4: 38% WR $-289, F grade
USDCAD │ M15, H4 │ M15: OVF | H4: 48% WR, D grade
GBPUSD │ M5, M15, M30, H1, H4 │ All negative. Only H8 positive but OVF
USDJPY │ ALL │ All TFs negative, all OVF
EURUSD │ M15, M30, H1 │ All negative even with FWD
US30 │ M5, H4 │ M5: $-241 OVF | H4: 38% WR $-921 F
UK100 │ M1, M5, H1 │ M1: $-163 | M5: $-96 | H1: 42% WR
AAPL.US │ M15, H1 │ 45%/44% WR, both OVF
ORCL.US │ M15, M30 │ Low PnL, weak grade
NFLX.US │ M30, H1, H4 │ OVF — no FWD confirmation
AMZN.US │ H1, H4 │ Too few trades, OVF
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
❌ DISABLE COMPLETELY
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
JPN225 (-$2,937) — WR: 45% | PF: 0.2 | SELL lost $-2,957. No TF profitable.
EUSTX50 (-$787) — WR: 36% | PF: 0.1 | Both directions in loss.
ETHUSD (-$73) — WR: 40% | PF: 0.2 | All TFs negative or zero.
SpotBrent (-$58) — WR: 42% | PF: 0.4 | Only H4/H8 marginally positive.
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
📋 QUICK REFERENCE
═══════════════════════════════════════════════
Symbol │ Status │ Optimal │ WR │ PnL │ FWD │ Use TFs
──────────┼────────┼─────────┼─────┼────────┼─────┼──────────────────
NAS100 │ ✅ USE │ M15 │ 57% │ +$711 │ ✅ │ M5,M15,M30,H1,H4
BTCUSD │ ✅ USE │ H1 │ 61% │ +$705 │ ✅ │ M30,H1,H4,H8
XAUUSD │ ✅ USE │ M15 │ 57% │ +$470 │ ✅ │ M1,M5,M15,M30,H8
FRA40 │ ✅ USE │ H8 │ 58% │ +$210 │ ✅ │ M30,H1,H4,H8
UK100 │ ⚠️ CAU │ H8 │ 52% │ +$190 │ ✅ │ M30,H4,H8
US500 │ ✅ USE │ H1 │ 56% │ +$134 │ ✅ │ M30,H1
USDCAD │ ✅ USE │ M30 │ 54% │ +$72 │ ✅ │ M30,H1
AUDUSD │ ✅ USE │ H1 │ 56% │ +$56 │ ✅ │ M15,M30,H1,H4
ORCL.US │ ✅ USE │ H4 │ 88% │ +$17 │ ✅ │ H1,H4
NFLX.US │ ✅ USE │ M15 │ 50% │ +$3 │ ✅ │ M15
AAPL.US │ ⚠️ CAU │ M30 │ 59% │ +$1 │ ✅ │ M30
GBPUSD │ ⚠️ CAU │ H8 │ 52% │ +$41 │ ❌ │ H8 only (OVF)
EURUSD │ ⚠️ CAU │ H4 │ 48% │ +$6 │ ✅ │ H4 only
USDJPY │ ❌ OFF │ — │ — │ -$338 │ — │ DISABLE
JPN225 │ ❌ OFF │ — │ — │ -$2937 │ — │ DISABLE
EUSTX50 │ ❌ OFF │ — │ — │ -$787 │ — │ DISABLE
ETHUSD │ ❌ OFF │ — │ — │ -$73 │ — │ DISABLE
SpotBrent │ ❌ OFF │ — │ — │ -$58 │ — │ DISABLE
US30 │ ⚠️ CAU │ — │ — │ -$431 │ — │ No reliable TF
AMZN.US │ ⚠️ CAU │ — │ — │ +$3 │ — │ Too few trades
Strong ConfTF: D1 | Weak ConfTFs (disable): H1, H12, H8, M15, M30
All results based on EMA(20). SMA/KAMA not fully tested.
Past performance does not guarantee future results.