Why have subscriptions been banned on the grounds of "too high a yield" ?

[Vladimir Gomonov]

I gave hrenfx two demo accounts of $1000 each yesterday and monitored them in "Signals". One has not started yet, but the second one has already traded $54,000 for half a day. He's strong, though. The signal is here: https://www.mql5.com/ru/signals/14780 The subscription was open and free, but it was closed by MetaQuotes for some reason, with the resolution "Subscription not allowed. Suspicious growth value. High risk to subscribers." :) Funny. Where is the risk if the equity curve is almost straight? ;-)

Otherwise, users will not see the best signals - they are too profitable.

[Artyom Trishkin]

MetaDriver:

Suggestion: Allow subscriptions in such cases with a risk warning. Otherwise, the best signals won't be available to users - too profitable.

Maybe that's the point... that's why we don't see them...

[TheXpert]

MetaDriver:

You can't make too much money -- the tailrace will go bankrupt.

[Renat Fatkhullin]

There's such off the charts slippage in copying this pipsqueak that we' d have to be suicidal to allow people to publicly get the balance line exactly the opposite direction. The slippages on entry and exit are knowingly and grossly greater than the profits of the demo pipsqueak.

We have gathered enough statistics and have started to methodically improve the quality of the service, protecting non-professional users. We will see it in the next terminal versions.

ps: you seem to be no novices, but you write as if you do not understand that the account of the copier will go to zero for 10-15 minutes of subscribing to such an outrageous scheme

[михаил потапыч]

papaklass:
You should not have mentioned that the account is managed by hrenfx. You know the attitude of the management here towards him.

What does that have to do with it?

[Vladimir Gomonov]

Renat:

There's such off the charts slippage in copying this pipsqueak that we' d have to be suicidal to allow people to publicly get the balance line exactly the opposite direction. The slippages on entry and exit are knowingly and grossly greater than the profits of the demo pipsqueak.

We have gathered enough statistics and have started to methodically improve the quality of the service, protecting non-professional users. We will see it in the next terminal versions.

ps: you seem to be no novices, but you write as if you do not understand that the account of the copier will go to zero for 10-15 minutes of subscribing to such an outrageous scheme

In that sense the risks are really big. I would not have signed a real account for this signal but I wanted to sign up another demo account with the same broker for the purpose of stress testing the service itself - whether it will cope with speeds or not. Market execution slippage in this case is due to speed limitations and not liquidity - lots there (so far) are small.After all, you can actively "not recommend" subscription, but to forbid it is too much. Imha - too much concern for users. Why should you forbid signing demo accounts for real accounts - that's OK.

[Vladimir Gomonov]

papaklass:
You should not have mentioned that the account is managed by hrenfx. You know the attitude of the management here to him.

Well, Renat kind of rebuked hrenfx once for the lack of his signals. now there are signals. only one cannot sign... :(

[Vladimir Gomonov]

And by the way.

A password-protected archive with the source code of the trading robot (in mql4) has been published. The password will be added when the robot "reaches good results in the account" (the wording is in the comments to the archive). The archive can be found at the page linked in the signal description.

// In the meanwhile, there are already 67 275.36 USD in the account.

Also new information from manager - trade on the account will be conducted not more than one lot.

[Renat Fatkhullin]

MetaDriver:
Well Renat sort of on the contrary once rebuked hrenfx for the lack of his signals. now there are signals. only you can't sign... :(

What kind of person (his long history under the nicknames getch, hrenfx we know well), such are the signals. He publicly lies about his scalper performance and people believe him. Apparently, Buffett is no match for him.

The signal is under the automatic protection filter.

[TheXpert]

Renat:

He is publicly lying about his scalper performance.

Can you argue your position?

Renat:

(his long history under the nicknames getch, hrenfx is well known to us)

Yeah, so well known that people are scouring the internet for his comments and codes.

[Alexandr Bryzgalov]

MetaDriver:

And by the way.

I have published a password-protected archive with the source code of the trading robot (in mql4). The password will be added as soon as the robot "reaches good results in the account" (see comments to the archive). The archive can be found at the page mentioned in the signal description.

// In the meantime, the account already has 67 275.36 USD.

I bought a real account at the same broker with the same amount ..., so, all the same but real.

but this is just a beauty from the series: the ideal program should work in ideal conditions )