Best PF Year vs Best Return Year in 8 EA Backtests: Same Year in 5; GOLD KING's PF 13.56 Year Returned the Least
19 November 2026, 01:00
0
7
Is the year with the highest profit factor also the year that made the most money? For the backtests of 8 EAs we list on the Market, we took each full calendar year and compared the year with the highest profit factor with the year with the highest return. Result: the same year in 5 of 8. In the other 3 they were different years, and GOLD KING v6 was the opposite case: its highest profit factor, 13.56 in 2021, came in its lowest-return full year (+36.2%), and its best-return year, 2025 (+164.5%), had its lowest full-year profit factor, 4.80. We also checked the year with the highest win rate: it was the best-return year in 4 of 8. Everything here is backtest. No forward result is used. Figures are as of 2026-11-19.
How it is counted
- Source: the deal list of each published MT5 test report, grouped by the year a trade was closed (commission and swap included). Floating profit and loss of open positions is not included.
- Only full calendar years are used. 2026 is shorter than a year in every test that reaches it, so it is left out.
- Return is the net closed profit of the year divided by the closed balance at the start of that year. Years are compared by return, not by money, because the tests compound.
- Year balance drawdown is the largest fall of the closed balance from a peak to a trough inside that year, with the start-of-year balance as the first peak. It is smaller than an equity drawdown and is shown only for the year in the same row.
- Profit factor and maximum relative equity drawdown in the last two columns are for the whole test, from the same report and setting. The drawdown is the figure we publish for each EA.
The table: highest profit factor year vs best return year
Ranks are among the full years of the same test (1 = highest).
EA | Backtest period | History quality | Full years | Highest-PF year: PF / return / return rank / year balance DD | Best-return year: return / PF / PF rank / year balance DD | Same year? | Profit factor (whole test) | Max relative equity drawdown (whole test)
GOLD KING v6 | 2019.01.01–2026.06.01 | 5% real ticks | 7 | 2021: 13.56 / +36.2% / 7 of 7 / 1.0% | 2025: +164.5% / 4.80 / 7 of 7 / 7.5% | No | 4.66 | 91.3%
BITCOIN COMET | 2018.01.01–2025.12.31 | 98% | 8 | 2018: 2.65 / +111.3% / 4 of 8 / 16.6% | 2021: +351.7% / 2.32 / 2 of 8 / 13.4% | No | 1.72 | 31.2%
GOLD TRIPWIRE | 2020.01.01–2026.10.14 | 11% real ticks | 6 | 2022: 3.00 / +41.0% / 2 of 6 / 1.7% | 2020: +722.8% / 2.54 / 3 of 6 / 9.2% | No | 1.83 | 19.0%
MEGAMAX DONCHIAN | 2017.01.01–2026.06.01 | 100% | 9 | 2021: 3.33 / +471.2% / 1 of 9 / 7.8% | same year | Yes | 1.55 | 58.6%
ATLAS | 2019.01.01–2026.06.28 | 100% | 7 | 2022: 1.84 / +203.8% / 1 of 7 / 19.2% | same year | Yes | 1.48 | 26.3%
GOLD VIPER | 2019.01.01–2026.09.01 | 8% real ticks | 7 | 2020: 2.48 / +194.0% / 1 of 7 / 10.3% | same year | Yes | 1.64 | 30.3%
ETHEREUM EA | 2019.01.01–2026.06.28 | 100% real ticks | 7 | 2024: 5.25 / +105.8% / 1 of 7 / 7.3% | same year | Yes | 2.83 | 17.1%
DONCHIAN ENGINE (free) | 2017.01.01–2026.06.01 | 100% real ticks | 9 | 2021: 3.19 / +37.3% / 1 of 9 / 2.6% | same year | Yes | 1.50 | 10.8%
GOLD KING v6: the cleanest year made the least
In GOLD KING v6 the two rankings run in opposite directions at both ends. 2021 had the highest profit factor of its 7 full years (13.56), 215 trades and a year balance drawdown of 1.0%, and it returned +36.2%, the lowest of the 7. 2025 returned +164.5%, the highest, with 655 trades, a profit factor of 4.80, the lowest of the 7, and a year balance drawdown of 7.5%. All 7 full years were positive. Over the whole test the maximum relative equity drawdown is 91.3%, far deeper than any year balance drawdown in the table.
The other two that split
- BITCOIN COMET: the highest profit factor came in 2018 (2.65, +111.3%, 4th of 8 by return). The best return came in 2021 (+351.7%) with the second-highest profit factor, 2.32.
- GOLD TRIPWIRE: the highest profit factor came in 2022 (3.00, +41.0%). The best return came in 2020 (+722.8%, profit factor 2.54, 3rd of 6). That test started from a balance of 1,000, so 2020 is a return on a small first-year balance.
Second check: highest win-rate year
EA | Highest win-rate year | Win rate | Return that year | Return rank | Year balance DD
GOLD KING v6 | 2019 | 91.0% | +51.8% | 5 of 7 | 2.0%
BITCOIN COMET | 2018 | 45.1% | +111.3% | 4 of 8 | 16.6%
GOLD TRIPWIRE | 2020 | 69.0% | +722.8% | 1 of 6 | 9.2%
MEGAMAX DONCHIAN | 2021 | 48.3% | +471.2% | 1 of 9 | 7.8%
ATLAS | 2022 | 35.9% | +203.8% | 1 of 7 | 19.2%
GOLD VIPER | 2025 | 59.4% | +63.9% | 6 of 7 | 16.7%
ETHEREUM EA | 2025 | 53.6% | +71.9% | 2 of 7 | 3.8%
DONCHIAN ENGINE (free) | 2021 | 48.3% | +37.3% | 1 of 9 | 2.6%
The highest win-rate year was also the best-return year in 4 of 8. GOLD VIPER's highest win rate, 59.4% in 2025, came in a year that ranked 6th of 7 by return, with a year balance drawdown of 16.7%.
Limits
- TRINITY and AIFW are left out because the original report files are not available. GOLD NEURON is left out because the deal list does not add up to the net profit in its report.
- Each test has 6 to 9 full years. With that few years, "same year in 5 of 8" is a count, not a rule.
- The tests differ in symbol, timeframe, period, tick model, risk setting and deposit. GOLD KING v6, GOLD VIPER and GOLD TRIPWIRE ran on 5% to 11% real ticks. The row order is not a ranking.
- These are EAs we chose to keep listed, so this is a survivor set. All of it is historical simulation, not a live record, and no year here says what a future year will do.
For buyers
- When a seller shows one year with a high profit factor, ask for that year's return and how it ranks among the other full years.
- Ask for the profit factor of the best-return year too. A high return can come with a lower profit factor and a deeper year drawdown.
- Put any single good year next to the maximum relative equity drawdown of the whole test.
The two EAs discussed most in this article: GOLD KING https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/180879 · GOLD VIPER https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/182297
Our published backtests state period, balance and settings, and our forward accounts are labelled as demo accounts wherever we show them. The full list: fxea365.com/ea/ranking


