You take profit on half a reversal trade and move the remaining stop to entry. The trade feels protected, but how much has the complete idea actually earned? For a trader using two positions, the useful unit is the whole setup. This article develops a payoff review you can apply before approving a ReversalLogic signal, then checks what the runner must contribute for the exit plan to justify its losses.
Define one risk budget for the complete setup
The ReversalLogic method description combines an exhaustion count, a closed Heikin-Ashi confirmation and higher-timeframe agreement. It divides an entry into two positions. The first target is near TDST, a level derived from the setup, or at the specified risk ratio, whichever is closer. After the first position closes, the second stop moves to entry and a later Heikin-Ashi colour change controls its exit.
That sequence creates several possible outcomes. To compare them, define 1R as the combined cash loss originally planned for both positions at their initial stops. Keep that denominator fixed throughout the trade. Moving a stop later changes remaining exposure, while the original risk unit remains available for evaluating the decision.
Suppose a hypothetical USD account assigns USD 100 to one setup, split equally into USD 50 per position. Both positions have a 30-pip initial stop distance. For EUR/USD, one pip is 0.0001 dollars per euro. The example assumes equal position sizes, ideal fills, and excludes spread, commission, financing and slippage. Actual sizing must respect the broker's contract and lot increments.
Translate the first exit into total-setup R
Imagine the nearby first target offers 18 pips from entry, or 0.6 times the 30-pip stop distance. Closing half the exposure there earns 0.5 multiplied by 0.6, which is 0.30R for the complete setup, or USD 30. If the second position subsequently exits exactly at entry, the combined gross result is still 0.30R.
Now consider a different hypothetical path. The first target fills, and the runner eventually exits 54 pips beyond entry. That is 1.8 times its initial stop distance. Its contribution is 0.5 multiplied by 1.8, or 0.90R. Adding the first exit gives 1.20R, or USD 120. The 54-pip exit is an invented outcome for this calculation. ReversalLogic's colour-change exit produces a variable result.
Hypothetical example. Ideal fills assumed. Results before trading costs. If both positions hit their original stops before the first target fills, the gross result is minus 1R. Those three paths form a useful starting ledger. Recording the first ticket as a winner and the runner as a separate break-even trade can hide the relationship between the size of the full loss and the much smaller protected outcome.
Ask how much the runner contributes
Consider a deliberately simplified distribution. Of the setups that reach the first target, suppose 60% subsequently exit the runner at entry and 40% achieve the hypothetical 54-pip runner exit. The mean gross result among those successful setups is 0.60 multiplied by 0.30R plus 0.40 multiplied by 1.20R, giving 0.66R. These invented frequencies are assumptions to test against a recorded sample.
If 65% of all setups reach that first target and the remaining 35% lose 1R, the mean result is 0.65 multiplied by 0.66R minus 0.35 multiplied by 1R, or 0.079R before costs. Subtracting an assumed average total cost of 0.04R per setup leaves 0.039R. Small changes in either the first-target frequency or the runner distribution can consume that margin.
For comparison, if every first-target success subsequently exits the runner at entry, the same 65% success rate gives 0.65 multiplied by 0.30R minus 0.35R, or minus 0.155R before costs. A high frequency of taking partial profit can coexist with a negative complete-setup average. Measure the entire distribution, including runner exits between entry and 54 pips, instead of forcing live results into these three simplified bins.
Check the transition after the partial close
A stop at the entry price can still leave a negative net result on that position after charges. Confirm that the first close actually occurred, the second stop modification was accepted, and the correct position remains open. MetaTrader describes broker stop-level restrictions and stop modification in its trade-execution documentation. Save the accepted stop price and execution timestamps in your review.
When replaying history, inspect any bar that contains both the first target and the original stop. Its high and low alone cannot establish the order in which those levels traded. A runner protected only after a target fill needs that sequence to be established. Label unresolved cases and compare alternative sequences before judging the exit plan.
Use the Navigator to record a decision
Before approval, save the signal time, initial stop distance, first-target distance, combined planned risk and higher-timeframe observation. After completion, add both fill records, costs, the stop-change timestamp, maximum adverse excursion and the runner's final contribution in setup R. Group results by the first-target distance so you can see whether nearby targets leave too much dependence on occasional long runners.
The Forex Top Team Trading Toolkit provides the ReversalLogic Navigator for chart planning and the semi-automatic Assist EA for approved execution. Its value in this process is making the proposed levels and management sequence explicit. Apply the worksheet to a recorded sample before drawing conclusions about your account's results. The earlier profit-factor review shows how to inspect sample size and outlier dependence when you summarize that ledger.


