One Month Made Over Half the Year's Profit in 18 of 53 Profitable Years Across 8 EA Backtests; BITCOIN COMET in 7 of 8
20 November 2026, 00:00
0
9
How much of a profitable year comes from its single best month? For the backtests of 8 EAs we list on the Market, we took every full calendar year that closed with a profit and divided the net profit of its best month by the net profit of the whole year. Result: in 18 of 53 profitable full years, one month made more than half of the year's profit. BITCOIN COMET did this in 7 of its 8 full years. GOLD KING v6 and GOLD TRIPWIRE never did: their highest share in any year was 33.2% and 46.6%. In 5 years the best month made more than the whole year, because the other months added up to a loss. Everything here is backtest. No forward result is used. Figures are as of 2026-11-20.
How it is counted
- Source: the deal list of each published MT5 test report, grouped by the month a trade was closed (commission and swap included). Floating profit and loss of open positions is not included.
- Only full calendar years are used. 2026 is shorter than a year in every test that reaches it, so it is left out.
- Best-month share = net profit of the best month of the year / net profit of the year. Only years that closed with a profit are used (53 of 60 full years). The 7 losing full years are left out because a share of a loss has no meaning.
- Return is the net closed profit of the year divided by the closed balance at the start of that year.
- Year balance drawdown is the largest fall of the closed balance from a peak to a trough inside that year, with the start-of-year balance as the first peak. It is smaller than an equity drawdown. It is the only drawdown used in this article.
The table: best-month share of the year's profit
EA | Backtest period | History quality | Profitable / full years | Median best-month share | Lowest–highest share | Years over 50% | Median full-year return | Deepest year balance DD
ETHEREUM TREND | 2019.01.01–2026.06.28 | 100% real ticks | 5 / 7 | 103.5% | 29.8%–153.6% | 3 | +6.9% | 10.7%
BITCOIN COMET | 2018.01.01–2025.12.31 | 98% | 8 / 8 | 66.7% | 37.9%–91.1% | 7 | +77.6% | 16.6%
MEGAMAX DONCHIAN | 2017.01.01–2026.06.01 | 100% | 6 / 9 | 47.6% | 22.4%–58.0% | 2 | +18.9% | 52.2%
DONCHIAN ENGINE (free) | 2017.01.01–2026.06.01 | 100% real ticks | 7 / 9 | 46.7% | 27.9%–1173.9% | 3 | +9.9% | 9.2%
GOLD VIPER | 2019.01.01–2026.09.01 | 8% real ticks | 7 / 7 | 42.6% | 31.5%–95.9% | 2 | +116.3% | 19.6%
ATLAS | 2019.01.01–2026.06.28 | 100% | 7 / 7 | 38.4% | 27.3%–122.9% | 1 | +107.4% | 19.2%
GOLD TRIPWIRE | 2020.01.01–2026.10.14 | 11% real ticks | 6 / 6 | 27.8% | 22.2%–46.6% | 0 | +34.3% | 9.2%
GOLD KING v6 | 2019.01.01–2026.06.01 | 5% real ticks | 7 / 7 | 20.8% | 14.2%–33.2% | 0 | +60.2% | 7.5%
Median full-year return and deepest year balance drawdown are taken over all full years of the test, losing years included.
BITCOIN COMET: one month above half in 7 of 8 years
BITCOIN COMET closed all 8 full years with a profit, from +16.4% to +351.7%. In 7 of them the best month made more than half of the year's profit. The highest was 2022 at 91.1% (best month 2022-07), a year that returned +18.3%. The only year under half was 2023 at 37.9%, which returned +16.4%. The deepest year balance drawdown was 16.6%, in 2018. The test trades about 8 times a month (median of active months), so a year depends on a small number of trades.
When the best month made more than the whole year
EA | Year | Best month | Best-month share | Return that year | Year balance DD
ETHEREUM TREND | 2021 | 2021-01 | 103.5% | +14.7% | 10.7%
ETHEREUM TREND | 2022 | 2022-01 | 136.2% | +6.9% | 8.3%
ETHEREUM TREND | 2023 | 2023-01 | 153.6% | +6.8% | 9.4%
ATLAS | 2020 | 2020-02 | 122.9% | +10.6% | 11.6%
DONCHIAN ENGINE (free) | 2018 | 2018-07 | 1173.9% | +0.4% | 5.3%
In these 5 years, the other months of the year added up to a loss, and the year still closed positive. All 5 returned +14.7% or less. For ETHEREUM TREND the best month was January in each of 2021, 2022 and 2023. The 1173.9% for DONCHIAN ENGINE is large only because the year's net profit was small (+0.4%).
The highest-share year and the return
- In 4 of 8 tests, the year with the highest best-month share was also the lowest-return profitable year: GOLD VIPER 2022 (95.9%, +22.6%), ATLAS 2020 (122.9%, +10.6%), ETHEREUM TREND 2023 (153.6%, +6.8%) and DONCHIAN ENGINE 2018 (1173.9%, +0.4%).
- GOLD TRIPWIRE was the opposite case: its highest share, 46.6% in 2020 (best month 2020-03), came in its best-return year, +722.8%, with a year balance drawdown of 9.2%. That test started from a balance of 1,000, so 2020 is a return on a small first-year balance.
- GOLD KING v6 kept every best month under a third of the year (14.2% to 33.2%). Its median full-year return was +60.2% and its deepest year balance drawdown 7.5%.
Limits
- TRINITY and AIFW are left out because the original report files are not available. GOLD NEURON is left out because the deal list does not add up to the net profit in its report.
- Each test has 6 to 9 full years. "18 of 53" is a count, not a rule.
- The tests differ in symbol, timeframe, period, tick model, risk setting and deposit. GOLD KING v6, GOLD VIPER and GOLD TRIPWIRE ran on 5% to 11% real ticks. The row order is not a ranking.
- These are EAs we chose to keep listed, so this is a survivor set. All of it is historical simulation, not a live record, and no year here says what a future year will do.
For buyers
- When a seller shows a yearly return, ask how much of it came from the best month of that year.
- If one month makes more than half of most years, missing that month (a late start, a switch-off, a terminal offline) changes the year more than the yearly figure suggests.
- Put each year's return next to that year's drawdown, not only next to the whole-test figure.
The two EAs discussed most in this article: BITCOIN COMET https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/181831 · ETHEREUM TREND https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/182358
Our published backtests state period, balance and settings, and our forward accounts are labelled as demo accounts wherever we show them. The full list: fxea365.com/ea/ranking


