Same 1% risk, different lot every time: live numbers and the hidden spread cost
"Risk 1% per trade" sounds like one number, but the lot that delivers it changes every time the stop changes. I recorded a live session on a MetaTrader 5 demo account (EURUSD, balance about 9,680 USD) and wrote down the lot for each stop distance. The numbers also show something that is easy to miss: how much of that 1% the spread takes before the trade even moves.
The formula
Lot = money at risk / (stop distance in points x value of one point for one lot), rounded down to the broker's lot step.
On EURUSD with 5 digits, one point (0.00001) is worth 1 USD per standard lot. With 1% of the balance at risk (about 96.5 USD in this session):
| Stop distance | Money at risk (1%) | Lot | Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| 36 points | 96.84 USD | 2.69 | 96.84 / 36 = 2.69 |
| 43 points | 96.75 USD | 2.25 | 96.75 / 43 = 2.25 |
| 48 points | 96.48 USD | 2.01 | 96.48 / 48 = 2.01 |
| 50 points | 96.50 USD | 1.93 | 96.50 / 50 = 1.93 |
The stop moved by 14 points and the lot went from 2.69 to 1.93: 39% more lots for the shorter stop, with the same money at risk. Using a fixed lot instead would have risked anything between 0.7% and 1.4% for these four stops.
Why round down
The exact value for a 50-point stop is 1.9300; for 47 points it is 2.0600 when the risk is 96.82 USD. When the result falls between two lot steps, rounding to the nearest step can push the risk above what you chose. Rounding down keeps it at or below your limit.
The spread takes a bigger share with short stops
In the same session the spread was 11 points (late evening, server time). With a 47-point stop and 2.06 lots:
- Money at risk: 96.82 USD (1.00%).
- Spread cost at entry: 2.06 lots x 11 points x 1 USD = 22.66 USD.
- The trade starts 22.66 USD down, which is 23% of the planned risk.
The share depends only on the ratio between spread and stop: 11 / 47 = 23%. With a 150-point stop the same spread would be about 7% of the risk. Short stops at hours with wide spreads are expensive even when the lot is correct.
Practical takeaways
- Size the lot from the stop, not the other way around: place the stop where the trade idea is wrong, then calculate the lot.
- Look at the spread as a share of the stop before entering. Above 10 to 15% it is a real cost.
- Check the instrument's point value: gold, indices and crypto have very different values per point than EURUSD.
Limitations
One account, one symbol, one session. Point values, lot steps and spreads differ between brokers and symbols.
Do it in one drag
The numbers above come from Chakana Risk Manager: you drag the stop line and the panel recalculates the lot, the money at risk and the spread cost before you click BUY or SELL. It also places pending orders at a draggable entry line, closes part of the trade at TP1 and has a daily loss shield. Video of this session: Risk Manager live demo. The free Lot Size Calculator does the lot calculation on its own.
- Chakana Risk Manager: MetaTrader 5 · MetaTrader 4
- Chakana Lot Size Calculator (free): MetaTrader 5 · MetaTrader 4
Trading involves risk of loss. This post explains a calculation; it is not trading advice.


