AI comparison: Gold Beaver vs Quantum Titan vs Hedgehog

AI comparison: Gold Beaver vs Quantum Titan vs Hedgehog

19 November 2026, 16:29
Arnold Bobrinskii
0
16

Back-tests only, not live results.

In short

  • The next Gold Beaver update adds three new scalper presets: Titan Scalper, Hoggy Scalper and Combo Scalper.
  • Titan Scalper trades in the same style as the Quantum Titan EA, and Hoggy Scalper in the same style as the Hedgehog EA. Our AI research assistant tested them next to the original EAs: same tester, same gold data, same period.
  • They take the same trades: 92% (Titan) and 96% (Hedgehog) of the original trades, at the same time and price. Profit at 0.01 lot: 102% and 107% of the originals.
  • Combo Scalper runs Titan Scalper, Hoggy Scalper and our UBS Scalp C Plus together in one preset. At the same risk it grew far more than any of the originals - but almost all of that came in 2026, and scalpers are sensitive to slippage (section 6).

Words used in this post

  • Same risk: every EA gets the lot size that makes its biggest drop exactly 15% over the same period (1 January 2025 - 7 November 2026). Then growth can be compared fairly.
  • Drawdown: how far the account falls from its last high.
  • Slippage: when an order is filled at a worse price than the EA asked for. On fast gold moves this happens often.

1. How the AI comparison was done

  • Same MT5 Strategy Tester, same broker data for gold (XAUUSD), every price change replayed, 1 January 2025 - 7 November 2026.
  • The original EAs ran with their default settings. The Gold Beaver presets ran with 0.01 lot on every order.
  • For every original trade the AI looked for a Gold Beaver trade on the same side, opened within 60 seconds, at a price within $0.30. It also compared the exits, the daily results and the full equity curves.

2. Titan Scalper vs the original Quantum Titan

Both look at yesterday's high and low and at older daily levels, and enter just before price reaches them. Trades last about 1-2 minutes, every trade has a stop-loss.

Original Quantum TitanGold Beaver Titan Scalper
Trades515510
Winning trades81%80%
Profit factor2.372.48
Profit at 0.01 lot$878$894

Key point: the two lines lie almost on top of each other.

3. Hoggy Scalper vs the original Hedgehog

Hedgehog places stop orders around recent highs and lows of the hour chart and follows the breakout with a tight trailing stop. Half of the trades last under 30 seconds.

Original HedgehogGold Beaver Hoggy Scalper
Trades1,6541,717
Winning trades68%71%
Profit factor2.332.34
Profit at 0.01 lot$1,501$1,602

Key point: again the curves follow each other closely; Hoggy Scalper ended a little higher.

4. How close is close?

Titan Scalper vs Quantum TitanHoggy Scalper vs Hedgehog
Same trades (2025)88%97%
Same trades (2026)95%94%
Same exit, of the same orders96%85%
Daily results match95%97%
Equity curves match100%100%
Our profit compared with the original102%107%

Key point: not every single trade is identical, but day by day the results move together, and over the whole period the equity curves are practically the same.

5. Combo Scalper: all in one preset

Combo Scalper runs three scalpers together on one chart: Titan Scalper, Hoggy Scalper and our UBS Scalp C Plus. Each keeps its own orders, so nothing is removed or merged. (We tested removing trades that two scalpers take together - it made the result worse, because those shared trades are the best ones.)

Starting with $10,000, all at the same 15% max drawdown, 1 January 2025 - 7 November 2026:

Ended with20252026 (to 7 Nov)Green monthsWorst monthLongest time below a previous high
Original Quantum Titan$148,800+126%+558%91%-2.3%61 days
Original Hedgehog$155,200+71%+810%83%-5.3%71 days
Original Titan + Hedgehog together$467,000+148%+1,787%96%-0.6%56 days
Gold Beaver Titan Scalper$139,600+111%+561%91%-3.7%61 days
Gold Beaver Hoggy Scalper$243,800+117%+1,025%91%-6.5%104 days
Gold Beaver Combo Scalper$3,694,700+238%+10,835%91%-4.0%39 days

Key point: Combo Scalper grew the most in both years and had the shortest time below a previous high. 2026 was an extreme year for gold, so the 2026 numbers are far above what a normal year can give.

6. Slippage - the big test for any scalper

These scalpers hold trades for seconds or minutes, so every cent of a worse fill counts. Here is the same lot as above, but every fill $0.10 worse:

Ended with ($0.10 worse fills)Max drawdown
Original Quantum Titan$107,20015.9%
Original Hedgehog$83,10019.7%
Original Titan + Hedgehog together$226,70015.3%
Gold Beaver Titan Scalper$102,40015.9%
Gold Beaver Hoggy Scalper$119,60021.7%
Gold Beaver Combo Scalper$1,001,70021.2%

If we lower the lot so the drawdown is back at 15%, Combo Scalper ends with about $260,300, Titan Scalper about $89,500 and Hoggy Scalper about $55,000.

Key point: slippage takes a large part of the profit from every scalper, the originals included. A broker with fast, exact fills matters more than the preset choice.

Gold Beaver on the MQL5 Market: https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/177869