All is OK with the indicators, but all is working as it should - Technical Indicators

SSL 2014.12.18 07:14 #9751

SSL:
Hi mladen,

Greetings!

I have been noticing an issue with the indicator alerts for quite sometime now... ... ...

Best Regards,

Mony

Hi mladen, mrtools,

please help address the issue.... Thank you

https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/180648/page650

Mladen Rakic 2014.12.18 08:53 #9752

SSL:
Hi mladen,

Greetings!

I have been noticing an issue with the indicator alerts for quite sometime now...

The indicators are missing to generate the alerts on the signals consistently... the signals come correctly, but the alerts on the signals are very inconsistent...(both, using current bar/closed bar)...! many a times there will be no alert even though a signal is generated...and especially when trading on reversals, the missing alerts leads to issues when trading live... meaning, the missing alerts are not doing what they are meant to on every signal/on a consistent basis...

I have extensively noticed this issue specially on the offline charts (range bars, renko-range bars, seconds charts)... and this issue is even more severe on faster moving markets/volatile times...

I have been testing & noticing this issue from previous build & current one/recent upgrade for a month now... the issue persists on as many instruments tested live/demo...

And to my surprise, EAs based on these indicators built using iCustom calls are also displaying the same issues...

To confirm this issue, I had put the indicator and the EA simultaneously, and whenever there is indicator signal & alert-the EA is taking trade instantly... and whenever there is indicator signal but NO Alert-the EA also is not taking trade...

and this issue is happening consistently with EA...

When using EAs based on these indis, this issue has to lead to many orphaned/unattended trades & losses and confusion on reversals and manual interventions...

Could this issue be fixed... so that there would be no missed alerts & trades on signals (manual trading)

And as for EAs based on these indis, I have no clue as to why this is a co-related issue...

please help fix this indicators with your experience & wisdom

Thanks a lot!

I have attached the indis that I tested...

Best Regards,

Mony

All is OK with those indicators. If you wish to have alerts on a current (still opened) bar set the alertsOnCurrent to true. If you wish to have alerts on an already closed bar, set it to false. Other than that, all is working as it should (set at least one of the alert type to tru to have an alert - for example in super trend volty like all are set to false, and if you leave the parameters like that, there will be no alerts even if the alertsOn is set to true. Set the parameters correctly and all will work OK)

Signal to Indi Something interesting, old thread Coding help

Albert Idrisov 2014.12.18 11:04 #9753

Уважаемые программисты, пожалуйста, добавьте звук и руки, когда изменение цвета баров Gyazo - b9f305eb8945fd38ff27a7213adfb79f.png, и просто воспользоваться этой возможностью, пожалуйста, см. мой постwpr_candles.mq4 wpr_candles.mq4

https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/180648/page650

thnx very match

Files:

wpr_candles.mq4 3 kb