Who has already tried the Signals subscription to get on the tail of ATC 2012 participants? - page 77

New comment
 
nickcorp:

I made a request at servicedesk for the same situation - still not fixed... Application #592014 | 2012.11.15 03:01

similar suspicion of incorrect balance display in servicedesk.
 

Full log of yesterday's day in the trailer. Small real.

Signed up withManov. I had about $150 at the time, and my ISP account balance was about $15000.

Everything seemed fine for a while. Then suddenly on Friday at 21:01 in Kiev something strange happened:

CL      0       Trades  19:29:14        '137754': deal #1055520 sell 0.01 AUDUSD at 1.0468 done (based on order #1228905)
JR      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has balance 15 336.95 USD, leverage 1:100; subscriber has balance 151.21 USD, leverage 1:500
QQ      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': percentage for volume conversion selected according to the ratio of balances and leverages, new value 1%
PP      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.20 AUDUSD 1.04195]
HD      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [buy 0.10 EURAUD 1.24084]
CG      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.10 EURCHF 1.20853]
IQ      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.20 EURGBP 0.80549]
GR      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [buy 0.10 EURJPY 101.852]
JF      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.40 EURUSD 1.2894675]
RM      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [buy 0.30 GBPCHF 1.49317]
EN      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 2.10 GBPJPY 128.585667]
QH      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.20 GBPUSD 1.59924]
DM      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [buy 0.10 USDCAD 0.99104]
RO      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [sell 0.10 USDCHF 0.94083]
RD      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': signal provider has position [buy 0.10 USDJPY 79.538]
OE      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': mismatch of position volume, trying to fix [sell 0.02 AUDUSD 1.04225]
NS      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': instant buy 0.01 AUDUSD at 1.0463 (deviation: 8)
GJ      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': accepted instant buy 0.01 AUDUSD at 1.0463 (deviation: 8)
QH      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': order #1229625 buy 0.01 / 0.01 AUDUSD at 1.0463 done
OS      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': position [sell 0.02 AUDUSD 1.04225] corrected successfully
KN      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': mismatch of position volume, trying to fix [sell 0.02 EURGBP 0.8078]
JK      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': deal #1055936 buy 0.01 AUDUSD at 1.0463 done (based on order #1229625)
DF      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': instant buy 0.01 EURGBP at 0.8092 (deviation: 6)
EN      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': accepted instant buy 0.01 EURGBP at 0.8092 (deviation: 6)
PE      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': order #1229626 buy 0.01 / 0.01 EURGBP at 0.8092 done
OE      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': position [sell 0.02 EURGBP 0.8078] corrected successfully
LQ      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': mismatch of position volume, trying to fix [sell 0.03 EURUSD 1.29295]
DN      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': deal #1055937 buy 0.01 EURGBP at 0.8092 done (based on order #1229626)
MH      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': instant buy 0.02 EURUSD at 1.2975 (deviation: 4)
PD      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': accepted instant buy 0.02 EURUSD at 1.2975 (deviation: 4)
EO      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': order #1229627 buy 0.02 / 0.02 EURUSD at 1.2975 done
RH      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': position [sell 0.03 EURUSD 1.29295] corrected successfully
EK      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': mismatch of position volume, trying to fix [buy 0.02 GBPCHF 1.489875]
CP      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': deal #1055938 buy 0.02 EURUSD at 1.2975 done (based on order #1229627)
JP      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': instant sell 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.4880 (deviation: 16)
OG      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': accepted instant sell 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.4880 (deviation: 16)
KD      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': order #1229628 sell 0.01 / 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.4880 done
MO      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': position [buy 0.02 GBPCHF 1.489875] corrected successfully
FI      0       Signal  21:01:45        '137754': mismatch of position volume, trying to fix [sell 0.02 GBPUSD 1.5987]
IK      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': instant buy 0.01 GBPUSD at 1.6038 (deviation: 6)
MN      0       Trades  21:01:45        '137754': deal #1055939 sell 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.4880 done (based on order #1229628)
IN      0       Trades  21:01:46        '137754': accepted instant buy 0.01 GBPUSD at 1.6038 (deviation: 6)
ID      0       Trades  21:01:46        '137754': order #1229629 buy 0.01 / 0.01 GBPUSD at 1.6038 done
EE      0       Signal  21:01:46        '137754': position [sell 0.02 GBPUSD 1.5987] corrected successfully
RP      0       Signal  21:01:46        '137754': synchronization finished successfully
MJ      0       Trades  21:01:46        '137754': deal #1055940 buy 0.01 GBPUSD at 1.6038 done (based on order #1229629)
LD      0       Signal  21:01:46        '137754': ping to signal server 78 ms, to trade server 79 ms
RP      0       Network 21:57:52        '137754': scanning network for access points
CF      0       Network 21:57:57        '137754': scanning network finished

(the beginning of the weirdness highlighted in red).

In general, something decided (either terminal or Signal-server) that positions do not coincide and closed a lot of damn positions.

Note, the last deal at the Provider was copied without any problems (which was at 19:29). After that there were no deals at the Provider.

The result is $20$ minus. It is not much, but it is unpleasant.

I hope the bug is fixed in the new build. If it is not, please let me know why I have not used the signals yet.

Files:
20121123.log  29 kb
 
notused:

Full log of yesterday's day in the trailer. Small real.

Signed up withManov. I had about $150 at the time, and my ISP account balance was about $15000.

Everything seemed fine for a while. Then suddenly on Friday at 21:01 in Kiev something strange happened:

(the beginning of the weirdness highlighted in red).

In general, something decided (either terminal or Signal-server) that positions do not coincide and closed a lot of damn positions.

Note, the last deal at the Provider was copied without any problems (which was at 19:29). After that there were no deals at the Provider.

The result is $20$ minus. It is not much, but it is unpleasant.

I hope the bug is fixed in the new build. If it is not, please let me know why I have not used the signals yet.

Also attach the history of your trades. You may use it in Service Desk.
 
antt:
Also attach the transaction history. Can be in the servicedesk.
#608919
 

this service and signals, two days ago i subscribed to a profitable provider who gives absolute lpribyl, i had profit for a day and then closed positions on my account when i had no such trades on the account of the signal seller( this is either a bug or specifically designed to drain the deposit

i can show you a screenshot, but i don't think anyone is interested in it

 
ygrek:

this service and signals, two days ago i subscribed to a profitable provider who gives absolute lpribyl, i had profit for a day and then closed positions on my account when i had no such trades on the account of the signal seller( this is either a bug or specifically designed to drain the deposit

i can show you a screenshot, but i don't think anyone is interested in it

i think it may be due to the fact that i have open accounts with different brokers!
 
Rugyi_cool:
may be because accounts are opened with different brokers!

What do you mean different brokers? What do you mean one signal in one account, another account in another terminal has a different signal, there may be several demo accounts and several terminals from different brokers...

you may have different accounts and different brokers.

Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Состояние окружения / Информация о счете
Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Состояние окружения / Информация о счете
  • www.mql5.com
Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Состояние окружения / Информация о счете - Документация по MQL5
 
ygrek:

What do you mean different brokers? What do you mean one signal in one account, another account in another terminal has a different signal, there may be several demo accounts and several terminals from different brokers...

You may have different account numbers and brokers and how they may influence each other.

For the correct work of signals, it is desirable for the buyer of signals to open an account with the same broker that the signal provider opened, since different brokers may have different symbols or even a set of instruments may be different!
 
Rugyi_cool:
For the signals to work correctly, it is advisable for the buyer of the signals to open an account with the same broker that the signals provider opened!
 
ygrek:
I do not want to open an account with a broker who supplies signals, I'm going to work with a russian forex bank through a bank, moreover, why would such a service be implemented in the Mql5 system? Moreover, the rules do not mention anything about bans or bugs, and the broker is one of the accepted brokers for working with signals.
1...7071727374757677787980818283
New comment
Reason: