Indicators with alerts/signal - page 1208

William Snyder
9492
William Snyder  
ValeoFX:
Would you please explain to me why the signal gets thrown back by 2 candles on the Dex_ADX & alerts nmc.mq4?

ADX does not and Regression channels don't so why is this the case here?

Would appreciate a reply.

Thanks in advance.

There is an dex adx here: https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/183798/page82 where the adx dots (using plusdi minusdi cross) doesn't repaint.

kramachandran59
54
kramachandran59  

hi mladen and mrtools,

I would like you to add an alert to this Inside bar indicator when you find some time because you are always busy with many requests from laymen like me. A pop up and sound alert please.

Thanks and Regards

Hercs
2957
Hercs  
mladen:
Because it repaints

And it was not written by me (maybe the question should be posted to "akadex" who wrote it why did he make it like that) otherwise it would not repaint.

And guys, once again, I really, really do not have time to check each and every code peace or coding errors and correct them. I am not and coding police. When I notice them (the errors), I correct them or warn about it. Otherwise I just leave the code as is and do what somebody requested counting on a fact that the user already checked it

_______________________

You of all people should know that : remember the times when I was making a clean version of XO on your request, and you insisted that I leave the option to allow it repaint? And how many disputes we had because I did not want to do so. So, I find your question rather odd at the least when you know very well my opinion about repainting

all the best

Thank you for replying Mladen.

I am puzzled that you tell me "I wanted the XO to repaint" as I am totally against any repainting indicator, but maybe I learned from you during that time. I will check our correspondence in the XO Thread and rectify my ignorance if it will be possible.

Continued success to you.

Hercs
2957
Hercs  
mrtools:
There is an dex adx here: https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/183798/page82 where the adx dots (using plusdi minusdi cross) doesn't repaint.

Deeply appreciated MrTools.

Continued success to you.

Mladen Rakic
154381
Mladen Rakic  
ValeoFX:
Thank you for replying Mladen.

I am puzzled that you tell me "I wanted the XO to repaint" as I am totally against any repainting indicator, but maybe I learned from you during that time. I will check our correspondence in the XO Thread and rectify my ignorance if it will be possible.

Continued success to you.

One of the posts : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/175779And you shall find in your xo thread a xo version that has an option to repaint or not (the option called "JustLastBar - that was the compromise that I have accepted on your insisting even though I was trying to explain that it is a classical case of repainting, and then it was you that posted that indicator, not me (since the whole thing went through emails) and you posted it here : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/176163/page20)

_________________

PS: check your emails, because the correspondence about that whole thing was using emails, not forum posts

PPS: I hope that this will refresh your memory as of how and why that indicator had that option

all the best

Mladen Rakic
154381
Mladen Rakic  
kramachandran59:
hi mladen and mrtools,

I would like you to add an alert to this Inside bar indicator when you find some time because you are always busy with many requests from laymen like me. A pop up and sound alert please.

Thanks and Regards

kramachandran59

That indicator repaints

Better not to use it in signaling/alerting mode

Hercs
2957
Hercs  
mladen:
One of the posts : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/175779And you shall find in your xo thread a xo version that has an option to repaint or not (the option called "JustLastBar - that was the compromise that I have accepted on your insisting even though I was trying to explain that it is a classical case of repainting, and then it was you that posted that indicator, not me (since the whole thing went through emails) and you posted it here : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/176163/page20)

_________________

PS: check your emails, because the correspondence about that whole thing was using emails, not forum posts

PPS: I hope that this will refresh your memory as of how and why that indicator had that option

all the best

OY Mladen, I did not question your memory. All I meant was that I do not remember it in the same detail as you do. You obviously saw it as an insult for which I offer a belated apology as it was unintentional firstly and secondly as I am not a coder, my enthusiasm for what I thought was an excellent indicator.

Maybe it is time that I tell you that I just turned 73 and in all my life I have never been grilled as much as what you have grilled me. That I am computer literate is an achievement for me as I started late in life to get to understand computers - you grew up with computers and that is the difference. You are an exceptional coder and nobody doubts that (read my accolades to you all over the show), but you have this manner of not accepting anything but the very best from everybody, because you understand what you are doing.

I am a mere mortal trying to make a success of my third vocation - the first two I was exceptionally successful at. Like you, I am also trying to make this last career a huge success and whether you want to believe it or not, I am very successful but not to my complete satisfaction just yet. On top of that I have this streak of trying to live up to being a "perfectionist" and there is no such thing in Forex. Therefore I have had to change to "strive for excellence, not perfection" in order to curb my frustration which the former brought with it.

So I trust that you will try and understand where I am coming from and that you will allow a little more "lee-way" when dealing with me in future, if at all.

Continued success to you nevertheless.

Hercs
2957
Hercs  

Mladen,

Thank you for the first link in which I wrote on the 15th of February 2008 :

Let me start by telling you that through the magic worked by Mladen, we now have a stable MTF_XO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I am deeply indebted to him...

and one Post later......................Mladen, once again my sincerest thanks.

Have I ever been anything but not deeply appreciative of your work? If I have then please show me where and when as I have no recollection of that. Just last week I recommended your work to someone.

Thank you for the heads-up. I will go through my Threads this weekend.

Best wishes.

Mladen Rakic
154381
Mladen Rakic  
ValeoFX:
Mladen,

Thank you for the first link in which I wrote on the 15th of February 2008 :

Let me start by telling you that through the magic worked by Mladen, we now have a stable MTF_XO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I am deeply indebted to him...

and one Post later......................Mladen, once again my sincerest thanks.

Have I ever been anything but not deeply appreciative of your work? If I have then please show me where and when as I have no recollection of that. Just last week I recommended your work to someone.

Thank you for the heads-up. I will go through my Threads this weekend.

Best wishes.

ValeoFX

Let us leave this thread for what it is dedicated to : indicators with alerts/signals

I hardly believe that users are interested in our private stuff (private stuff should always be solved privately - did not delete posts, but let this thread be kept free of "private stuff")

all the best

Mladen Rakic
154381
Mladen Rakic  

Upgraded stochastic (multi time frame version with alerts and arrows - made more user friendly and shorter - more efficient code) : stochastic_mtfalertsarrows_2.mq4