• Get access

Requests & Ideas - page 200

Mladen Rakic
163390
Mladen Rakic  
rayphua:
Hi Mladen, I'm revisiting my earlier request where I asked if SuperTrend and MACD could be combined. You had mentioned that they work on different sets of values.

I would like to know if Blau's TVI and Supertrend can be combined into one indicator. I attached the iMacdAtr indicator pic again for your perusal as well as Blau's TVI2.

If again this is not possible, can you perhaps advise what is possible then and how the above was done. Thanks Mladen.

rayphua

Super trend is an indicator that works on main chart (not going to go into details now how the 2 versions found are actually calculated). William Blau's TVI is an indicator that is an indicator shown in a sub-window.

MACD and atr from your picture are giving comparable results and values (and that is why they could be combined - that you can check by simply placing atr and macd on the same chart and comparing values you see).

______________________

As a simple test : place super trend and Blau Ergodic at one same chart and compare the values

RWP
537
RWP  
mladen:
CrustallumKvs Here you go Here is a comparison the the "on chart" version

PS: just to remind that filter type 4 is the additional "no-name" digital filter

regards

Mladen

Hi Mladen,

Could you kindly create two indicators from the digital filter created as quoted?

1. A candle indicator that is color coded based on the filtered histogram

2. A Macd version with zeroline of the digital filter.

Thanks for the help!!!

Mladen Rakic
163390
Mladen Rakic  
rayphua:
Hi Mladen,

Could you kindly create two indicators from the digital filter created as quoted?

1. A candle indicator that is color coded based on the filtered histogram

2. A Macd version with zeroline of the digital filter.

Thanks for the help!!!

Here is the bars version of that indicator (satl - filter type 1 - used for both filter types)

Hermo
383
Hermo  

Hello everybody again!

I'm looking for a renko strategy in online. I mean...I've tried a lot of indicators, but all with offline. I'm aware that someone has a special communication (or something like that..) to get this.

I'm wondering also what it's the difference between online and offline:

1. The real data it's the same?

2. At same time?

3. I can send buy/sell orders to a market?

4. To try the strategy in tester, it's like the online strategy?

I'm pretty sure that this topic it's also requested in other thread. Can anyone send me the link (I tried to search but it was impossible to get all answers!).

Thank you in advance!

Mladen Rakic
163390
Mladen Rakic  
Hermo:
Hello everybody again!

I'm looking for a renko strategy in online. I mean...I've tried a lot of indicators, but all with offline. I'm aware that someone has a special communication (or something like that..) to get this.

I'm wondering also what it's the difference between online and offline:

1. The real data it's the same?

2. At same time?

3. I can send buy/sell orders to a market?

4. To try the strategy in tester, it's like the online strategy?

I'm pretty sure that this topic it's also requested in other thread. Can anyone send me the link (I tried to search but it was impossible to get all answers!).

Thank you in advance!

Hermo,

Some answers :

Offline charts depend 100% on the software that generated it (in this case I suppose you think about custom offline charts, not the standard time frames opened as offline charts) so always bear in mind that the primary is how the code that generates the offline chart works

1. If by "real data" you mean real prices they should be the same

2. Yes

3.
1. Manually : Yes, the only thing you will not see are trading levels on such charts

2. from EA : it depends on the code generating offline chart if an EA will work on that chart or not

4. No, you can not use offline custom periods in strategy tester (metatrader allows only standard time frames to be tested)

Hermo
383
Hermo  
mladen:
Hermo,

Some answers :

Offline charts depend 100% on the software that generated it (in this case I suppose you think about custom offline charts, not the standard time frames opened as offline charts) so always bear in mind that the primary is how the code that generates the offline chart works

1. If by "real data" you mean real prices they should be the same

2. Yes

3.
1. Manually : Yes, the only thing you will not see are trading levels on such charts

2. from EA : it depends on the code generating offline chart if an EA will work on that chart or not

4. No, you can not use offline custom periods in strategy tester (metatrader allows only standard time frames to be tested)

Hello mladen,

thank you for the quick reply!

I appreciate it a lot!

Some other questions: you said to me about "so always bear in mind that the primary is how the code that generates the offline chart works". Does it means that you need a "master code" and "slave code", where master strategy (online chart) is the guide to slave strategy (offline chart)?

Where or how can I see it? Do you have an example? With Renko or Range data...

Other question: so...how can I test a renko strategy? or range strategy?

Thank you in avance!

Mladen Rakic
163390
Mladen Rakic  
Hermo:
Hello mladen,

thank you for the quick reply!

I appreciate it a lot!

Some other questions: you said to me about "so always bear in mind that the primary is how the code that generates the offline chart works". Does it means that you need a "master code" and "slave code", where master strategy (online chart) is the guide to slave strategy (offline chart)?

Where or how can I see it? Do you have an example? With Renko or Range data...

Other question: so...how can I test a renko strategy? or range strategy?

Thank you in avance!

Hermo

As of how a code that generates offline data works (and should work in order to allow EAs to work on offline charts generated) see this indicator : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/179807/page130 . You attach it to any "live" chart and open an offline chat which then can be used as any normal "live" chart

As of testing : as I said it is not possible to back-test custom offline time frames (data) in metatarder (even less in metatrader 5 since there offline chart do not exist any more)

Hermo
383
Hermo  
mladen:
Hermo

As of how a code that generates offline data works (and should work in order to allow EAs to work on offline charts generated) see this indicator : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/179807/page130 . You attach it to any "live" chart and open an offline chat which then can be used as any normal "live" chart

As of testing : as I said it is not possible to back-test custom offline time frames (data) in metatarder (even less in metatrader 5 since there offline chart do not exist any more)

Thank you mladen!

I'll try it!

RWP
537
RWP  

Hi Mladen,

Is there a possibility to reflect (1) on the chart, and (2) in the form of a histo tape in a seperate window, when Blau TVI with two different settings meet the criteria? Please advice.

Thanks!

Files:
Mladen Rakic
163390
Mladen Rakic  
rayphua:
Hi Mladen,

Is there a possibility to reflect (1) on the chart, and (2) in the form of a histo tape in a seperate window, when Blau TVI with two different settings meet the criteria? Please advice.

Thanks!

rayphua

What does "reflect (1) on the chart" mean? Do you mean colored bars according to Blau ergodic tvi values?