• Get access

Requests & Ideas - page 59

paapi
32
paapi  

Hi Mladen..,

I am speechless.., thanks a lot for this new indi from you.

Mladen Rakic
163288
Mladen Rakic  

paapi

I think that with the price drawn as it is in this separate window version, it will be much clearer how does it monitor the chosen price and bands and how does it check for breakouts

regards

Mladen

paapi:
Hi Mladen.., I am speechless.., thanks a lot for this new indi from you.
paapi
32
paapi  

Hi Mladen.

There was an alert showing EUR/CHF at 15:14:53 Donchian Channel Price broke lower band and there was an alert showing gbp/jpy broke the upper band when neither had happened actually .., this is an issue with the chart window indicator.., can you please look what might be the cause and post the one which has got the option of alert on every break of the band by a candle.., i mean if 1, 2, 3, 4, 5...... candles keep on breaking it., i would like to be alerted.

regards,

paapi.

Flytox
256
Flytox  
mladen:
paapi

I think that with the price drawn as it is in this separate window version, it will be much clearer how does it monitor the chosen price and bands and how does it check for breakouts

regards

Mladen

Hi Mr Mladen

is it possible, when you have time, to do the same with your cfb channel.

Thx

Mladen Rakic
163288
Mladen Rakic  

paapi

Please read the post (the beginning of this post : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/179807/page39 ) where I explained what can (could) happen and what to do

regards

Mladen

paapi:
Hi Mladen.

There was an alert showing EUR/CHF at 15:14:53 Donchian Channel Price broke lower band and there was an alert showing gbp/jpy broke the upper band when neither had happened actually .., this is an issue with the chart window indicator.., can you please look what might be the cause and post the one which has got the option of alert on every break of the band by a candle.., i mean if 1, 2, 3, 4, 5...... candles keep on breaking it., i would like to be alerted.

regards,

paapi.
paapi
32
paapi  

Hi Mladen..,

Sorry to be dragging this out and checking your patience (i know u've got a lot of this ), but the truth is i'd read the post u'd made and only after that i made the last post. I am not using MTF, but as i was reading your new post.., i got an alert, for eur/chf, gbp/chf, and gbp/jpy to have broken the lower band, but only gbp/jpy was correct, the other two were not, the gbp/chf had broken the middle band and eur/chf was just above the lower band .

PS: With great trepidation, i'm writing this, I would be more than happy to have a new one where it alerts on all breaking of the bands unlike the earlier ones where it only alerted on first instance and ignored the rest or the 2nd version where it alerted on the 2nd instance provided the price came down/up the band and again pierced.

regards,

paapi

Mladen Rakic
163288
Mladen Rakic  

paapi

I am testing it over and over and it works correctly (even the version with the change proposed to alert on every bar that breaks the upper or lower band) There is no alert on middle line brake (break out alerts check only the upper and lower bands, they completely ignore the middle line)

Here is a "history" of alerts with the change in code I sent you on a 1 minute EURUSD chart (no mtf, current bar) and as you can see there were no alerts when the price retraced into the channel nor the alert was repeated - it alerted at the exact moment (which is seen from the exact time of the alert in the list of alerts) when the price broke the band
regards

Mladen

paapi:
Hi Mladen..,

Sorry to be dragging this out and checking your patience (i know u've got a lot of this ), but the truth is i'd read the post u'd made and only after that i made the last post. I am not using MTF, but as i was reading your new post.., i got an alert, for eur/chf, gbp/chf, and gbp/jpy to have broken the lower band, but only gbp/jpy was correct, the other two were not, the gbp/chf had broken the middle band and eur/chf was just above the lower band .

PS: With great trepidation, i'm writing this, I would be more than happy to have a new one where it alerts on all breaking of the bands unlike the earlier ones where it only alerted on first instance and ignored the rest or the 2nd version where it alerted on the 2nd instance provided the price came down/up the band and again pierced.

regards,

paapi
Files:
paapi
32
paapi  

Hi Mladen..,

That is great.., send me the changed version (by you to alert on every break).., maybe it is my mistake in coding i don't know.., but whatever comes from your hands will be a perfect one.

regards,

paapi.

Mladen Rakic
163288
Mladen Rakic  

This is the version I tested

regards

Mladen

paapi:
Hi Mladen..,

That is great.., send me the changed version (by you to alert on every break).., maybe it is my mistake in coding i don't know.., but whatever comes from your hands will be a perfect one.

regards,

paapi.
paapi
32
paapi  

Hi Mladen..,

Thanks a lot.., i would have never attempted changing it if i'd known that it would give u so much headache..., but the one sent by you works perfectly. I had changed the code in the original donchian, which missed one line of code, which is present in the 2nd version, and i think that was the problem.., sorry.., but you cannot expect us humans to be a God like you

regards,

Paapi