Discussion of article "General information on Trading Signals for MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5" - page 7

[Deleted]  
Renat:
You need to register as a seller so that the organisers know the sellers. No one gives data to buyers.

And no one says that it is not necessary to register, etc. The question is in your (I do not know who exactly wrote the text of the article) phrase, I quote again:

This information may be required in case of any disagreement between the subscriber and the supplier.

what cases are we talking about? and as a consequence - how can personal information about the supplier help to solve these cases?

simple questions like this

SUS: maybe this phrase was written by someone for a red word, just say so - I will not break my brain about it and pester you with questions.

 
alexx_v:

... what cases are we talking about? ...

Well, here's an example: someone will raise a fuss, start saying "again he under another nickname his slivators puts", and here MK - "it's different people, etc.".

Well, and with the Market: will register some peppers 2 or 3 nikami and will start buying goods from himself. Yes, at a loss, but the rating will raise - "here I buy from me, take it, you will not regret it" and stamp reviews "everything is cool...". Under the second nickname the same thing.

I think this information is needed MK for screening "dead souls".

These are my thoughts on this topic.

 
ForexMoneyMaker:

I have two questions for the developers:

1. Will the buyer's signals be recognised if he and the supplier are serviced by different brokers with different names but identical financial instruments? For example, if the supplier has EURUSD and the buyer has EURUSD=, or if the supplier has XAUUSD and the buyer has GOLD?

2. If the signals were provided by the provider for FREE during a month, and then at the end of this month the provider decided to put these signals for sale, will they be automatically put out immediately or do they need to be checked again by the organisers within a month?

Thanks in advance for the answer!

Hello, developers of the signals service!

I would still like to hear your answers to the questions first-hand. You developed the service, so you assumed how such situations would be resolved. Please comment!

Additionally, there are a couple more questions:

3. Is a signal provider protected from reselling his signals by a buyer to other buyers through the Signals Service?

4. Is the signal provider protected from FREE distribution of signals by a buyer, who is followed by a group of buyers, united with him in the signal purchase shareholders, through a demo account? (i.e., for example, 100 people discounted and one of them bought signals for this amount and immediately distributes them for free to all the others who are involved in this case)?

Торговые сигналы
Торговые сигналы
  • www.mql5.com
Торговые Сигналы для MetaTrader: копирование сделок, мониторинг счета, автоматическое исполнение сигналов и социальный трейдинг
 

1. automatic symbol mapping works within suffixes. That is EURUSD <=> EURUSDxxx, priority is given to a full name match, and if there is more than 1 mapping option, it is disabled due to uncertainty of what to choose. There are no other mapping methods and are not planned for security reasons.

2. yes, one month is mandatory.

3. yes. it is protected. it is technically impossible to resell signals, there is a good protection system. attempts to cheat will result in eternal ban for the whole account.

4. yes, point 3.

Read discussions of the signals service on this site - all these issues have been discussed. You can search for the topics.

Торговые сигналы
Торговые сигналы
  • www.mql5.com
Торговые Сигналы для MetaTrader: копирование сделок, мониторинг счета, автоматическое исполнение сигналов и социальный трейдинг
 
Renat, tell me, do such signals have the right to exist? Isn't the following text a violation of the very essence of the "Signals" service?

ECN Secret Method

Please don't subscribe, because you will not make profit


https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/3096


It seems to me that this is a referral lure from a brokerage company, and has nothing to do with normal signals for making money (the author himself says: don't subscribe, but open an account there and there, put 250 USD on it, and then I will send you(?) a trading system).

In fact, the brokerage company is advertised, not a signal that you can subscribe to and profit from.


UPD: the feedback to the signal is also entertaining.

 
Deleted. The penalties for spamming are serious - eternal block.
 

What about these signals https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/1994#!tab=history

Gain: 26,287,747. 77%

Initial deposit: -0.36 USD Why the minus is not clear at all.

And if you look at the average history, where did this result come from?

217879732012.10.31 16:26Balance0.00
217228762012.10.30 16:27Balance0.00
216629792012.10.29 16:26Balance0.00
216050712012.10.28 16:27Balance0.00
215716662012.10.28 15:08Balance-0.01
214661232012.10.25 21:28Buy0.01EURUSD1.294481.296582012.10.28 15:081.296592.11
215626882012.10.27 16:27Balance0.00
215626892012.10.27 16:27Balance-0.01
215206962012.10.26 16:26Balance0.00
215206972012.10.26 16:26Balance-0.01
214789372012.10.26 08:36Buy0.01EURUSD1.289681.290782012.10.26 08:391.290791.11
214791212012.10.26 08:39Balance0.00
214780912012.10.26 08:11Balance0.00
214775782012.10.26 07:41Buy0.01EURUSD1.289471.290572012.10.26 08:111.290581.11
214738352012.10.26 05:10Balance0.00
214693942012.10.26 01:15Buy0.01EURUSD1.293511.294612012.10.26 05:101.294611.10
214552582012.10.25 16:26Balance0.00
213900222012.10.24 16:26Balance0.00
213443992012.10.24 08:18Balance0.67Balance
212781702012.10.23 08:32Buy0.01AUDUSD1.026661.033332012.10.24 08:171.033356.69
 
Zeleniy:

What about these signals https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/1994#!tab=history

Gain: 26,287,747. 77%

Initial deposit: -0.36 USD Why the minus is not clear at all.

And if you look at the average history, where did such a result come from?

We will filter out such figures next week. These are not trading accounts.
 

Awesome signal: https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/3186

Initial deposit: 2 000.00 USD

Profit: 1 352 249.33 USD


Launched: 2013.01.13 16:48:53

Updated: 2013.01.13 16:48:55


In 2 seconds the deposit grew from 2000 to 1.3 million USD?

Graph and numerical designation of the growth - no comments at all.


And the account is real, on FECH-Server, which is famous for such signals with fantastic results, free subscription (!!!) and leverage 1:1000.

I tend to think that this is a clever advert of FECH, and behind the real account there is no real client, and there are employees of the company, who make deposits in the server part of MT5. They didn't spam openly (like these guys), but they decided to attract in a veiled way.

 
i_logic:

...

I tend to think that this is a cunning advert of FECH company, and behind the real account there is no real client, and there are employees of the company, who make deposits in the server part of MT5. They did not spam openly (like these people), but they decided to attract in a veiled way.

It is even hard to imagine what these people were thinking when they decided to attract someone in this way.