Trend indicators for EAs.

[Aleksey Ivanov]

Gentlemen! There are thousands of indicators on the Internet that are used for trend identification.

My question to active EA developers who studied this problem in practice: "In your opinion, what indicators are really promising to be used in EAs for reliable detection of trend beginning?

In my opinion, it would be desirable for Expert Advisors to discuss (in terms of advantages and disadvantages) indicators with scales, for example, trend strength varies from -1 to 1 .

[Mickey Moose]

you won't believe it - muvings

[Aleksey Ivanov]

Mickey Moose:
you won't believe it - a muving.

That's understandable, but the muving has no scale.

[Yousufkhodja Sultonov]

Mickey Moose:
you won't believe it - a muving.

Differential mouving.

[Yousufkhodja Sultonov]

Aleksey Ivanov:
That's understandable, but the muving has no scale.

Then, Double differential muving.

[Petros Shatakhtsyan]

Aleksey Ivanov:

Gentlemen! There are thousands of indicators on the Internet that are used for trend identification.

My question to active EA developers who studied this problem in practice: "In your opinion, what indicators are really promising to be used in EAs for reliable detection of trend beginning?

In my opinion, it is desirable to discuss (in terms of advantages and disadvantages) indicators with scales, say, the strength of the trend varies from -1 to 1 .

In real time to determine not only the beginning of the trend, but also the end, it is absolutely impossible.

Don't believe it if someone knows how to do it.

[Aleksey Ivanov]

Petros Shatakhtsyan:

In real time to determine not only the beginning of a trend but also the end, it is absolutely impossible.

Don't believe it if someone knows how to do it.

I just want to catch the beginning, and then I'll hang a trawl.

[Georgiy Merts]

Petros Shatakhtsyan:

In real time to determine not only the beginning of a trend but also the end, it is absolutely impossible.

Don't believe it if someone knows how to do it.

Indeed, it is a strange request - to confidently determine the trend. Yes, if someone could confidently identify it - they would have taken all the money in the world long ago.

[Yousufkhodja Sultonov]

Petros Shatakhtsyan:

In real time to determine not only the beginning of a trend but also the end, it is absolutely impossible.

Don't believe it if someone knows how to do it.

You are cruelly mistaken, with such a categorical attitude.

[Aleksey Ivanov]

Georgiy Merts:

A strange request indeed - confidently identifying a trend. Yes, if someone could confidently define it - they would have taken all the money in the world a long time ago.

We are talking about a probability greater than 0.5, i.e. some degree of certainty, not absolute certainty, which, in general, is not achieved anywhere. Indies would be a better place to discuss.

[khorosh]

Petros Shatakhtsyan:

In real time to determine not only the beginning of a trend but also the end, it is absolutely impossible.

Don't believe it if someone knows how to do it.

Well it depends on how you define the trend. That is if you consider, and this is the most common definition: that a trend is up (down) when each new peak (trough) is higher (lower) than the previous peak (trough) According to this change in direction this is the beginning of a new trend and the end of the previous one.