Elite indicators :) - page 566

mandagozu81
182
mandagozu81  

Combo indicator

mladen:
mandagozu81 It should not take too much time to make such an indicator

Is it a good idea to construct the indicator using the 4tf macd code or am i being totally senseless?

Mladen Rakic
151206
Mladen Rakic  

mandagozu81

It is a good frame to use for that purpose

mandagozu81:
Is it a good idea to construct the indicator using the 4tf macd code or am i being totally senseless?
mandagozu81
182
mandagozu81  

Rsi Multisymbol + Smoothed

Mladen thank you for your guidance about the combo indicator.

Cci multisymbol smoothed indicator that u ve just posted seems interesting. Do you have Rsi multisymbol smoothed version already coded in your repository or yet to be coded?

Mladen Rakic
151206
Mladen Rakic  

Yet to be coded

mandagozu81:
Mladen thank you for your guidance about the combo indicator. Cci multisymbol smoothed indicator that u ve just posted seems interesting. Do you have Rsi multisymbol smoothed version already coded in your repository or yet to be coded?
mandagozu81
182
mandagozu81  

Rsi Multisymbol + Smoothed

mladen:
Yet to be coded

That's good Would it be a good idea for the indicator to have more than just one smoothing algorithms (smooth mode) inside the indicator one of them being rsioma? What do you think?

Mladen Rakic
151206
Mladen Rakic  

It is always goo to have more choices as long as you can control them (instead of they controling you). Maybe the best is to have a lot of choices, tests them for some period of time, and then decide which one is the best for your trading style and then stick with it. Otherwise there is a danger of constant choices expolration instead of trading

mandagozu81:
That's good Would it be a good idea for the indicator to have more than just one smoothing algorithms (smooth mode) inside the indicator one of them being rsioma? What do you think?
altoronto
318
altoronto  

So I took liberty to make smoothed multi symbols smoothed RSI and Momentum version, of course if its approved by master Mladen

mandagozu81
182
mandagozu81  

Dear Mladen i need your very simple idea about a coding issue please...

Dear Mladen,

You are our guru about mt4 coding and on whom many people like me count the most about mt4 programming.

2 days ago i have asked you in the elite forum about having 4 indicators in one subwindow to makeup a combo indicator which visually looks like the 4tf bars indicators (instead of having 4 different timeframes for 4 boxes having 4 different indicator values for 4 boxes all in one subwindow)

I decided to have a combo with 8 indicators. 8 boxes on top of each other blue or red.

When i made an inquiry about the project an an experienced commercial mt4 coder said to me.

"""MT4 allow only 8 buffers for indicators. Your combo needs 16 (8 blue and 8 red).

We have 2 possibilities :

1/ Make 2 indicators (4 indicators each). One of the 2 will check the other one to define the alert.

2/ Make only one but instead of using buffers, I will code with objects (blue/red squares). The look of the indicator will be the same but not very conventional way to code.""""

and another coder whom i don't know very well said,

"""""MT4 only allows 8 buffers for indicators, YES. You need 8 boxes, so your indicator uses only 8 buffers. No more, no less. Remember I mentioned we all are coders, but we have coders, and we have coders. Quality and Experience counts.

If you work with me, you'll definitely see how I'll deal with it which is totally different from the 2 possibilities the "experienced guy" mentioned. I'm the next simple guy across your computer. If I fail to WOW you, then I'm here to answer to you.

For what it's worth, your combo needs 8 buffers, I repeat, 8 buffers!""""""

--------------------

Which of the 2 coders is right in your opinion? Is it really possible to have my combo indicator with 8 boxes in one subwindow using 8 buffers? (i would prefer to not split my combo indi into 2 parts). Your valuable idea is very very important to me. Thank you for your ongoing support and ideas!

Mladen Rakic
151206
Mladen Rakic  

mandagozu81

To display 8 values in 2 colors each using only drawing buffers in metatrader 4 you would need 16 buffers (metatrader 4 does not allow that one drawing buffer has more than one color). And metatrader allows only 8 drawing buffers - so, without using objects (any kind and any way) it is not possible to have 16 colors for 8 drawing buffers.

It can be drawn using objects (see the "swami" series indicators where it practically uses as much colors your pc can show and in 95 step (buffers) - it could be more but I limited it to that for practical reasons - metatrader does not "like" too much object on chart)

mandagozu81:
Dear Mladen,

You are our guru about mt4 coding and on whom many people like me count the most about mt4 programming.

2 days ago i have asked you in the elite forum about having 4 indicators in one subwindow to makeup a combo indicator which visually looks like the 4tf bars indicators (instead of having 4 different timeframes for 4 boxes having 4 different indicator values for 4 boxes all in one subwindow)

I decided to have a combo with 8 indicators. 8 boxes on top of each other blue or red.

When i made an inquiry about the project an an experienced commercial mt4 coder said to me.

"""MT4 allow only 8 buffers for indicators. Your combo needs 16 (8 blue and 8 red).

We have 2 possibilities :

1/ Make 2 indicators (4 indicators each). One of the 2 will check the other one to define the alert.

2/ Make only one but instead of using buffers, I will code with objects (blue/red squares). The look of the indicator will be the same but not very conventional way to code.""""

and another coder whom i don't know very well said,

"""""MT4 only allows 8 buffers for indicators, YES. You need 8 boxes, so your indicator uses only 8 buffers. No more, no less. Remember I mentioned we all are coders, but we have coders, and we have coders. Quality and Experience counts.

If you work with me, you'll definitely see how I'll deal with it which is totally different from the 2 possibilities the "experienced guy" mentioned. I'm the next simple guy across your computer. If I fail to WOW you, then I'm here to answer to you.

For what it's worth, your combo needs 8 buffers, I repeat, 8 buffers!""""""

--------------------

Which of the 2 coders is right in your opinion? Is it really possible to have my combo indicator with 8 boxes in one subwindow using 8 buffers? (i would prefer to not split my combo indi into 2 parts). Your valuable idea is very very important to me. Thank you for your ongoing support and ideas!
traderdp
247
traderdp  

mladen, a followup to my last request to you

mladen,

Just a quick question as to whether there is any available info on the possibility of my last indicator (nonlag ATR of jma cross) coding request to you?

Thanks alot once again for all you do for all of us on these 2 forums.

traderdp

David