10points 3.mq4 - page 347

 
davidke20:
This thread is dedicated to research in Martingale.

Wish you good luck dude, you're gonna need it.

 

Differences

forexjim:
Hi John,

Indeed the two presets differ (as shown below). Does it mean your choices (responsible for #3461 statement) of 10p3v002, MaxTrade 5, Multiplier 3, and Money_mgnt are profitable faster while my choices (responsible for #3445 statements) of 10p3v003, MaxTrade 10, Multiplier 2, and no Maney_mgnt are profitable slower but safer?

Thank you for your advice.

forexjim

Jim,

It probably means that I have taken more risks using M15 TF & X 3 multiplier and got away with it. The next trade may destroy the account and your account may keep on and ultimately making more profit. There is no right or wrong method, in the end all martingale EAs hit the wall and the demo account can not escape that. Live accounts with a policy of withdrawing profit may survive longer that is if you can get profit before the big hit.

John

 

I have test on TF 1 hour , and i can see it grow up are too slowly .

If 10K balance one years just can make profit 50% , it is fall on MM....

too many open trading and using marting ...

this just my comment.

if can this EA can make more profit , i think it should be perfect!

 

Risk/Profit

yeoeleven:
Jim,

It probably means that I have taken more risks using M15 TF & X 3 multiplier and got away with it. The next trade may destroy the account and your account may keep on and ultimately making more profit. There is no right or wrong method, in the end all martingale EAs hit the wall and the demo account can not escape that. Live accounts with a policy of withdrawing profit may survive longer that is if you can get profit before the big hit.

John

Hi John,

If the presets indeed differ as you suggest, I must say you have more guts than I and therefore deserve more rewards.

I will keep my accounts as they are so that this thread can see how the forward tests go.

Merci beaucoup.

forexjim

 
 

You asked here https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/174975/page228 and I replied here alreadyhttps://www.forex-tsd.com/183007-post3412.html

I am sorry (it is the same indicator).

 
 

10p3v003

Hi David,

Would you please help me understand this?

I ran the exact same EA with same preset on IBFX MT4 and Velocity4 MT4 with identical account type, initial balance, leverage ratio, and time frame. I even exported the data feed from the two platforms and compared them to make sure their open, high, low, close, and volume are exactly identical. Yet the results were very different: IBFX MT4 generated lower DrawDown and was winning and Velocity4 MT4 gave much higher DrawDown and was losing miserably. Why this difference?

Thank you for advising.

forexjim

 

Hii, want to bacttest 10p3 ver 3 on FXopen, minimal is 0.1 lot

but when i test it

it said in journal

2008.02.19 14:37:06 2007.12.28 16:00 10p3v0.03 USDJPY,H4: OrderSend error 131

Here is my setting

Magic=772188

TakeProfit=45.00000000

Lots=0.10000000

InitialStop=1000.00000000

TrailingStop=0.00000000

MaxTrades=10

Multiplier=1.70000000

Pips=30

OrderstoProtect=5

Money_management=0

AccountType=0

risk=0.50000000

ReverseSignal=0

Fast_EMA=12

Slow_EMA=26

Signal_SMA=9

Shift=1

TradingRange=0

UseTimeFilter=0

StopTrade=13

StartTrade=18

Do I missed something??

 
duyduy:
Hii, want to bacttest 10p3 ver 3 on FXopen, minimal is 0.1 lot

but when i test it

it said in journal

2008.02.19 14:37:06 2007.12.28 16:00 10p3v0.03 USDJPY,H4: OrderSend error 131

Here is my setting

Magic=772188

TakeProfit=45.00000000

Lots=0.10000000

InitialStop=1000.00000000

TrailingStop=0.00000000

MaxTrades=10

Multiplier=1.70000000

Pips=30

OrderstoProtect=5

Money_management=0

AccountType=0

risk=0.50000000

ReverseSignal=0

Fast_EMA=12

Slow_EMA=26

Signal_SMA=9

Shift=1

TradingRange=0

UseTimeFilter=0

StopTrade=13

StartTrade=18

Do I missed something??

Hahah I know the problem, I change multiplier to 2.

And the backtest begin..

The test hit MC, but I think should ok if the multiplier is 1.7

But I wonder why it won't work, Is this a bug?

Files:
10p3.gif  9 kb
10p3.htm  158 kb
Reason: