CatFx50 - page 219

 
harold4x:
i have been trading this setup for last 3 months and have made money do i take every signal no just the ones that fit ninas and my own critiria and look to get 34 pips with a 34 pip stop on gbp/usd or euro/usd i know its 1 to 1 risk /reward but if you have a good win loss record it works in fact do a little math being right only 60% of time makes you nice money only way to really backtest is to do it manually since no one else has stepma stoc also mibl why would you post the cable entry at 1300 when it closed 26 pips past 50 ema thats a no trade in my book

Yes harold, you are right. But it is a formal signal, even if it is risky. If you trade such a signal or not is another decision.

I didn't trade that because of the distance to ema50 and the great fall over 43 pips repectively.

passass:
I saw same signals but there is no signal: GBPUSD 13:00cet level 1 sell @1,7528 on my NorthFinance chart.

Signal is not valiated by hist_step_ma_stoch.

Could you attach your chart screen.

thnx

passass

Hi passass, Hi Docsniper,

at NorthFinance there was a slight signal - but a signal. See attached chart

b.r. mibl

Files:
hc_003.jpg  97 kb
 
Docsniper:
@passass

Attached you find the screenshot with todays picture in GBPUSD at Neuimex.

To me also it was a clear sell-signal level 1 at 13.00CET.

bye

Micha

Hi, Docsniper!

I have Neuimex and my GBPUSD chart related to StepMA_Stoch is different.

BTW, when we see a lot of bars hovering EMA50, we should not trade: market does not know where to go.

And if we do so, we should scalp till we see "strength". But it is better not to trade.

We do not need to trade everyday.

Something big is in the making. USDCHF is moving since 16-03 in a 100 pips range. We'll see.

Nina

Files:
gbpusd_3.jpg  152 kb
 

ok for people who make money with nina system i have a question

what win/loss ratio do you have?

the big problem for a system is the exit

if you dont know where to exit then you have a chanche to loss some pips

where is your exit?

i think this is a old question on this rhread

have the best and many pips

 

nina you are still a reporter or only a trader now?:)

 
mibl:

at NorthFinance there was a slight signal - but a signal. See attached chart

b.r. mibl

On MIG server, there was not a sell signal at 1300. There seemed to be big differences between servers.

Files:
eurusd_4.jpg  79 kb
 
coogee:
On MIG server, there was not a sell signal at 1300. There seemed to be big differences between servers.

Hi coogee - we are on cable - not on eurusd.

b.r. mibl

 
Docsniper:
@passass

Attached you find the screenshot with todays picture in GBPUSD at Neuimex.

To me also it was a clear sell-signal level 1 at 13.00CET.

bye

Micha

Hi Docsniper,

please take a look at Nina's Neuimex-chart which is different from yours and (mine at NorthFinance)

Something must be different - perhaps the configuration of the indicator.

b.r. mibl

 

Hi!

Lets go to Tools, Options. How many bars have you got there?

I have "Max bars in history" 128.000

Max bars in chart, 32.768.

Step should have 2000 bars

Nina

 

leutzuro i have been trading this since beginning of year and have a 79% win loss ratio with a little decretion to which signals i take average win 34 pips average loss 25 there were only a couple of losses

 
nina:
Hi!

Lets go to Tools, Options. How many bars have you got there?

I have "Max bars in history" 128.000

Max bars in chart, 32.768.

Step should have 2000 bars

Nina

i got the same settings, problem must be broker feed...

Reason: