Suggestions, comments, errors on the Signals service - page 31

[Aleksandr Lishchenko]

Will the payment be at the expense of part of the spread?

[Aleksandr Lishchenko]

How to remove the signal completely from the base ?

[Dmitriy Parfenovich]

I go to Signals and see 5 signals of one user in the TOP.

Maybe you should display no more than one signal per user in the TOP. If they are many, then display the best.

Otherwise you can make 10 signals, and then take the entire top.

[Aleksey Rodionov]

fyords:

I go to Signals and see 5 signals of one user in the TOP.

Maybe you should not display more than one signal per user in the TOP. If they are many, then display the best.

Otherwise you can make 10 signals, and then take the entire top.

And each signal may be connected to your signal and you will only have to manage one account. You can do it endlessly. Especially if one account trades in the opposite direction to the other.

[Yury Reshetov]

fyords:

I go to Signals and see 5 signals of one user in the TOP.

Maybe you should display no more than one signal per user in the TOP. If they are many, then display the best.

Otherwise you can make 10 signals, and then take the entire top.

If the signals rating were calculated based on the current equity, the distribution of signals in the tops would be quite different, not to mention close to the reality. In this case, many lovers of risky strategies such as martin or stop-loss strategies would have to rely on their luck and not on the wildly inflated balance to appear in the TOP.

[Dmitriy Parfenovich]

Reshetov:
If the rating in signals were calculated based on the current equity, the distribution in the tops would be absolutely different, not to mention close to the reality. In this case, many lovers of risky strategies such as Martin or Stop Loss without stops would have to be lucky to appear in the ranks.

For me, it does not really matter how signals are sorted in the TOP. It's important for me that 10 places of the top are distributed among 10 users, not less.

As for the rating itself, maybe we should do something exotic, like in the feed above - every time there are new articles, codes, products, ...

This is the type of signals: top by balance, top by equity, top by number of trades, top by profit factor, top best trade, ... . Everyone will have a chance to be in the top ranks of their categories.

Each time the page is refreshed, the arbitrary top will be shown.

[Vladimir Kustikov]

I don't understand how "Gain" is calculated? If this is some new kind of maths, then it's OK - just reassure me that this is the new kind of maths

Gain:-90.15%

Start deposit:30.00 USD

Profit:72.17 USD

Deposits:130.00 USD

Withdrawals:45.45 USD

Balance:186.72 USD

Funds:186.72 USD

In standard maths it would look like this

profit / (starting balance + deposits - withdrawals)

72.17 / (30 + 130 - 45.45) = 0.63 or +63%.

I hope I'm missing something, otherwise it looks like nonsense...

[Andrey Khatimlianskii]

Vladix:

I don't understand how "Gain" is calculated?

See the sequence of deposits and withdrawals. The profit percentage is not calculated on the sum of all deposits/withdrawals, but on the account balance at which the profit was made.

[Rashid Umarov]

Vladix:

I don't understand how 'Gain' is calculated? If this is some new kind of maths, then that's fine - just reassure me, tell me it' s a new kind of maths

I hope it's me who isn't understanding something, otherwise it's just nonsense...

There is no bullshit - there was a 90% drop in balance, that's honestly what it shows. It is easy to see on the Balance graph yourself

[Heroix]

I find the idea of evaluating a TS by its balance sheet absurd. Signals are no exception.

The only question that arises is to what end?