Рецепты увеличения выручки от продажи Сигналов - страница 7

[[Удален]]

evillive:
Его недавно забанили, это, наверное, немного заставляет задуматься, даже без статистики. Да и чудовищное проскальзывание и неприлично большой депозит - тоже. Ну а те, кто всё же подключились, сами себе враги, значит )))

Нужно было сразу банить, посмотрев лишь на брокера.

[[Удален]]

Новые данные:

Всего сигналов: 906
Всего подписчиков: 4232
Суммарно они платят: $47062.05

Сумма всех средства подписчиков: $5660240

Средства подписчиков -  совокупные средства только реальных счетов в рамках используемых рисков. Итак, мы видим, что Сигналы рулят суммой $5.5М. Много это или мало - ХЗ. Надо сравнивать с конкурентами, но это здесь делать было бы некорректно. Думаю, что сумма завышена на самом деле, т.к. разработчики еще не умеют четко отделять мух от котлет (реал и демо). Так что какие-то демо-фантики там точно учтены. Но порядок, думаю, ясен.

Распределение средств подписчиков по брокерам расположения сигналов-источников такое (брокер - средства):

RoboTrade Ltd. 2536678.00
International Capital Markets Pty Ltd. 672100.00
Profit Large Trading Limited 218000.00
InstaForex Companies Group 188155.00
TusarFX 186000.00
Alpari Limited 180051.00
E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc. 160014.00
FXOpen Investments Inc. 131875.00
GKFX FX/CFDs 128000.00
ServiceCom Ltd. 96500.00
I Securities Global Ltd. 88000.00
Planet Group International Holdings Limited 84300.00
Admiral Markets AS 82165.00
Straighthold Investment Group, Inc. 70363.00
ForexTime Ltd. 68985.00
Fort Financial Services Ltd. 65573.00
ALPEN ASSET MANAGEMENT TRUST SARL 62016.00
GSM Group 53000.00

Результаты ниже $50K не вставлял.

 

В визуализации не силен. Наверное, надо просто общий CSV-файл составить и выложить. Кто Excel  понимает и хочет визуализировать - пишите как надо, сделаю.

 

Ну и, наконец, топ-рейтинг по средствам подписчиков (см. Funds):

0: Name: GOOD PROFIT (ALEX_FOREX)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/35539 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 746.86% (Balance: 25861.81, Equity: 25584.27, Pips: 83964, Trades: 118)
MaxDD: 48.82%, ROI: 717.66%
Rating: 99884645 (Started: 2014.04.03 15:14:40, Published: 2014.04.03 15:14:40)
Subscribers: 386 (Price: $29.00), SignalIncome: $11194.00, Funds: $1400000.00 (per one: $3626.94)

1: Name: Loading (kyolulu)
Broker Server: ICMarkets-Live3 (International Capital Markets Pty Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/56880 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 499.85% (Balance: 599.85, Equity: 599.85, Pips: 5224, Trades: 310)
MaxDD: 22.72%, ROI: 499.85%
Rating: 99956884 (Started: 2014.09.15 06:45:28, Published: 2014.09.15 06:45:28)
Subscribers: 362 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $394000.00 (per one: $1088.40)

2: Name: RS Zoner (Scorpio4)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/46852 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 56.08% (Balance: 39020.69, Equity: 35578.41, Pips: 38157, Trades: 196)
MaxDD: 23.78%, ROI: 41.97%
Rating: 99979468 (Started: 2014.07.02 18:19:19, Published: 2014.07.02 18:19:19)
Subscribers: 89 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $281000.00 (per one: $3157.30)

3: Name: SAPIENT (SAPIENT)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/22769 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 737.21% (Balance: 8597.41, Equity: 8597.41, Pips: 22536, Trades: 254)
MaxDD: 58.19%, ROI: 722.51%
Rating: 99933337 (Started: 2013.12.18 16:25:16, Published: 2014.01.17 17:09:48)
Subscribers: 61 (Price: $35.00), SignalIncome: $2135.00, Funds: $268000.00 (per one: $4393.44)

4: Name: Tricky Twisted FX (bellduke)
Broker Server: RoboForex-Pro (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/55020 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 62.61% (Balance: 1264.35, Equity: 1241.59, Pips: 38288, Trades: 370)
MaxDD: 13.56%, ROI: 21.33%
Rating: 99974340 (Started: 2014.09.03 11:01:17, Published: 2014.09.03 11:01:17)
Subscribers: 195 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $247000.00 (per one: $1266.67)

5: Name: Profit777 (Profit123)
Broker Server: ProfitLT-Server (Profit Large Trading Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/62484 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 60.80% (Balance: 152.76, Equity: 152.76, Pips: 3466, Trades: 27)
MaxDD: 21.25%, ROI: 60.80%
Rating: 99990032 (Started: 2014.10.15 16:35:18, Published: 2014.10.15 16:35:18)
Subscribers: 17 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $340.00, Funds: $218000.00 (per one: $12823.53)

[[Удален]]

Топ-рейтинг сигналов с самыми толстыми (в среднем) подписчиками (см.  per one):

0: Name: A 01 Forex Earth Robot (pro_trader)
Broker Server: Alpari-Standard1 (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/10941 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 41.57% (Balance: 121.97, Equity: 121.97, Pips: 6245, Trades: 521)
MaxDD: 27.99%, ROI: 7.09%
Rating: 99982863 (Started: 2013.07.16 08:45:22, Published: 2013.08.15 09:41:43)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $25.00), SignalIncome: $25.00, Funds: $64000.00 (per one: $64000.00)

1: Name: Claclacar (tomazzo)
Broker Server: EGlobal-Cent4 (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/45251 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 45.97% (Balance: 31048.85, Equity: 27598.75, Pips: 25569, Trades: 261)
MaxDD: 40.61%, ROI: 29.39%
Rating: 99988076 (Started: 2014.06.19 15:13:23, Published: 2014.06.19 15:13:23)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $26000.00 (per one: $26000.00)

2: Name: Pro Scalp MA (2sova2)
Broker Server: FXOpen-ECN Live Server (FXOpen Investments Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/64687 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 40.51% (Balance: 685.16, Equity: 685.16, Pips: 7982, Trades: 420)
MaxDD: 18.62%, ROI: 59.60%
Rating: 99960667 (Started: 2014.10.27 19:43:09, Published: 2014.10.27 19:43:09)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $22.00), SignalIncome: $66.00, Funds: $67000.00 (per one: $22333.33)

3: Name: Liu carl4 (liuzf1311)
Broker Server: IronFX-Real13 (IronFX)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/56775 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 5.83% (Balance: 34956.48, Equity: 34956.48, Pips: 7475, Trades: 96)
MaxDD: 2.42%, ROI: 5.93%
Rating: 99997231 (Started: 2014.09.15 02:01:06, Published: 2014.09.15 02:01:06)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $33000.00 (per one: $16500.00)

4: Name: Melaka LFx (menjaditrader)
Broker Server: LiteForex-Pamm.com (Straighthold Investment Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/56588 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 73.58% (Balance: 43393.81, Equity: 42832.81, Pips: -943, Trades: 230)
MaxDD: 48.81%, ROI: 71.33%
Rating: 99986018 (Started: 2014.09.12 09:07:14, Published: 2014.09.12 09:07:14)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $43000.00 (per one: $14333.33)

5: Name: Ivan10W (jieckwanghui)
Broker Server: Hadwins-Global Trader (Hadwins Capital Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/36991 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 48.30% (Balance: 33507.40, Equity: 33507.40, Pips: 24412, Trades: 877)
MaxDD: 8.45%, ROI: 24.70%
Rating: 99975150 (Started: 2014.04.15 06:34:12, Published: 2014.04.15 06:34:12)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $29.00), SignalIncome: $58.00, Funds: $28000.00 (per one: $14000.00)

6: Name: Profit777 (Profit123)
Broker Server: ProfitLT-Server (Profit Large Trading Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/62484 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 60.80% (Balance: 152.76, Equity: 152.76, Pips: 3466, Trades: 27)
MaxDD: 21.25%, ROI: 60.80%
Rating: 99990032 (Started: 2014.10.15 16:35:18, Published: 2014.10.15 16:35:18)
Subscribers: 17 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $340.00, Funds: $218000.00 (per one: $12823.53)

7: Name: Protector investment 1 (Protektor)
Broker Server: EGlobal-Cent3 (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/66174 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 88.35% (Balance: 13749.55, Equity: 13749.47, Pips: -419, Trades: 223)
MaxDD: 26.78%, ROI: 77.33%
Rating: 99997958 (Started: 2014.11.05 09:03:02, Published: 2014.11.05 09:03:02)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $12000.00 (per one: $12000.00)

8: Name: Sulton forex4yousuf PAMM (yosuf)
Broker Server: EGlobal-PAMM (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/53155 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 96.17% (Balance: 36639.22, Equity: 33252.23, Pips: 2512, Trades: 72)
MaxDD: 32.29%, ROI: 26.24%
Rating: 99984157 (Started: 2014.08.20 22:55:59, Published: 2014.08.20 22:55:59)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $21000.00 (per one: $10500.00)

9: Name: Tianchengforex (cwq2255)
Broker Server: RGMForex-Real 2 (RGM FX Pty Ltd)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/68225 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 3.24% (Balance: 10325.45, Equity: 9902.47, Pips: 1138, Trades: 20)
MaxDD: 7.25%, ROI: -0.71%
Rating: 99999432 (Started: 2014.11.17 07:04:29, Published: 2014.11.17 07:04:29)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $30.00), SignalIncome: $30.00, Funds: $9900.00 (per one: $9900.00)

10: Name: LING193001 (tanzhouye)
Broker Server: MFXBroker-Cent (MFX Broker Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/49843 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 627.17% (Balance: 7271.70, Equity: 7271.70, Pips: 4301, Trades: 1421)
MaxDD: 40.63%, ROI: 627.17%
Rating: 99806074 (Started: 2014.07.28 09:12:52, Published: 2014.08.06 14:24:50)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $150.00), SignalIncome: $150.00, Funds: $9700.00 (per one: $9700.00)

11: Name: Stalker 03 (vurst)
Broker Server: AM-Live (Admiral Markets AS)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/23394 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 261.61% (Balance: 160.95, Equity: 116.04, Pips: 721, Trades: 1234)
MaxDD: 34.07%, ROI: 82.42%
Rating: 99830683 (Started: 2013.12.26 08:38:39, Published: 2014.01.25 09:27:45)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $9500.00 (per one: $9500.00)

12: Name: YJ HAM FOREX (yjham)
Broker Server: AM-Live2 (Admiral Markets AS)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/32325 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 53.75% (Balance: 31693.45, Equity: 25007.62, Pips: 130135, Trades: 664)
MaxDD: 35.06%, ROI: 8.17%
Rating: 99999975 (Started: 2014.03.11 15:36:45, Published: 2014.03.11 15:36:45)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $26000.00 (per one: $8666.67)

13: Name: LFHFX Steady (sundaylfh)
Broker Server: Alpari-PRO (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/17516 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 136.94% (Balance: 11646.12, Equity: 11469.24, Pips: -8219, Trades: 468)
MaxDD: 38.26%, ROI: 9.24%
Rating: 99982435 (Started: 2013.10.29 16:21:30, Published: 2013.11.12 16:04:24)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $17000.00 (per one: $8500.00)

14: Name: The Nick Leeson Appreciation Signal (Vagwan)
Broker Server: ForexTime-ECN (ForexTime Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/62987 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 80.61% (Balance: 4744.73, Equity: 3959.08, Pips: 28578, Trades: 2103)
MaxDD: 23.46%, ROI: 3.60%
Rating: 99972957 (Started: 2014.10.17 19:11:12, Published: 2014.10.17 19:11:12)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $8100.00 (per one: $8100.00)

15: Name: Steady returns (microns)
Broker Server: GKFX-FX-CFD Live (GKFX FX/CFDs)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/64156 (Real Account, Leverage: 400)
Gain: 121.87% (Balance: 6202.22, Equity: 6095.54, Pips: 20716, Trades: 28)
MaxDD: 7.63%, ROI: 81.91%
Rating: 99999982 (Started: 2014.10.24 08:54:04, Published: 2014.10.24 08:54:04)
Subscribers: 16 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $320.00, Funds: $128000.00 (per one: $8000.00)

16: Name: Protector investment 2 (Protektor)
Broker Server: EGlobal-Cent3 (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/66495 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 420.45% (Balance: 9295.90, Equity: 9293.40, Pips: -941, Trades: 182)
MaxDD: 83.06%, ROI: 9.52%
Rating: 99999999 (Started: 2014.11.06 14:27:37, Published: 2014.11.06 14:27:37)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $16000.00 (per one: $8000.00)

17: Name: Previous candle (Stib)
Broker Server: GrandCapital-Server (Grand Capital LTD)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/16599 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 81.99% (Balance: 18199.57, Equity: 18194.61, Pips: -32190, Trades: 2192)
MaxDD: 71.90%, ROI: 63.90%
Rating: 99997895 (Started: 2013.10.21 12:12:54, Published: 2013.11.20 13:26:28)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $12000.00 (per one: $6000.00)

18: Name: AIOS Fond (Bystrak)
Broker Server: Alpari-ECN1 (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/20676 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 64.37% (Balance: 504.83, Equity: 504.83, Pips: 10021, Trades: 331)
MaxDD: 18.82%, ROI: 28.77%
Rating: 99966845 (Started: 2013.11.27 16:34:20, Published: 2013.11.27 16:34:20)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $12000.00 (per one: $6000.00)

19: Name: PROGRESSOR (Bicas14)
Broker Server: InstaForex-Cent.com (InstaForex Companies Group)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/57841 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 29.35% (Balance: 35348.62, Equity: 33245.91, Pips: 3591, Trades: 1080)
MaxDD: 30.83%, ROI: 14.20%
Rating: 99996336 (Started: 2014.09.19 13:31:36, Published: 2014.09.19 13:31:36)
Subscribers: 17 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $87000.00 (per one: $5117.65)

20: Name: Protector investment (Protektor)
Broker Server: EGlobal-Cent3 (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/63668 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 804.24% (Balance: 12389.40, Equity: 12325.70, Pips: -633, Trades: 549)
MaxDD: 53.30%, ROI: 56.46%
Rating: 100000000 (Started: 2014.10.22 10:01:24, Published: 2014.10.22 10:01:24)
Subscribers: 5 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $100.00, Funds: $24000.00 (per one: $4800.00)

21: Name: VETO (ooo.cmex)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/16363 (Real Account, Leverage: 400)
Gain: 558.83% (Balance: 107188.24, Equity: 108153.24, Pips: 49289, Trades: 583)
MaxDD: 92.60%, ROI: 498.89%
Rating: 99999983 (Started: 2013.10.18 04:47:16, Published: 2013.10.18 04:47:16)
Subscribers: 10 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $200.00, Funds: $48000.00 (per one: $4800.00)

22: Name: SwingTrades LT (operez)
Broker Server: VantageFX-UK-Real (Vantage FX UK Trading Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/31152 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 38.77% (Balance: 277.53, Equity: 277.53, Pips: 10393, Trades: 52)
MaxDD: 10.91%, ROI: 38.76%
Rating: 99998410 (Started: 2014.03.03 13:16:17, Published: 2014.03.03 13:16:17)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $25.00), SignalIncome: $25.00, Funds: $4700.00 (per one: $4700.00)

23: Name: Doubleyields27 (Double-yields)
Broker Server: USGFX-Live (Union Standard International Group Pty Ltd)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/47402 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 55.24% (Balance: 15524.13, Equity: 15570.91, Pips: 19563, Trades: 260)
MaxDD: 23.58%, ROI: 55.67%
Rating: 99988554 (Started: 2014.07.07 17:30:32, Published: 2014.07.07 17:30:32)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $14000.00 (per one: $4666.67)

24: Name: FX WI REAL M5 (zk745678)
Broker Server: FBS-Real (FBS Inc)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/58811 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 38.57% (Balance: 68759.99, Equity: 68712.29, Pips: 31930, Trades: 2504)
MaxDD: 14.38%, ROI: 20.58%
Rating: 99999999 (Started: 2014.09.25 11:51:30, Published: 2014.09.25 11:51:30)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $60.00, Funds: $14000.00 (per one: $4666.67)

25: Name: BlackWatch (acnrvp)
Broker Server: ICMarkets-Live01 (International Capital Markets Pty Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/60761 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 39.50% (Balance: 215.52, Equity: 215.52, Pips: 6786, Trades: 123)
MaxDD: 20.48%, ROI: 9.64%
Rating: 99996963 (Started: 2014.10.06 17:35:16, Published: 2014.10.06 17:35:16)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $49.00), SignalIncome: $98.00, Funds: $9100.00 (per one: $4550.00)

26: Name: SAPIENT (SAPIENT)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/22769 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 737.21% (Balance: 8597.41, Equity: 8597.41, Pips: 22536, Trades: 254)
MaxDD: 58.19%, ROI: 722.51%
Rating: 99933337 (Started: 2013.12.18 16:25:16, Published: 2014.01.17 17:09:48)
Subscribers: 61 (Price: $35.00), SignalIncome: $2135.00, Funds: $268000.00 (per one: $4393.44)

27: Name: Impulse Scalper Pro (Autotrader)
Broker Server: Alpari-Standard4 (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/1199 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 481.13% (Balance: 5809.22, Equity: 5809.22, Pips: 2753, Trades: 465)
MaxDD: 15.86%, ROI: 76.08%
Rating: 99781647 (Started: 2012.11.13 12:02:45, Published: 2012.11.13 12:02:45)
Subscribers: 4 (Price: $38.90), SignalIncome: $155.60, Funds: $17000.00 (per one: $4250.00)

28: Name: CoralFxFund (coral5)
Broker Server: ICMarkets-Live02 (International Capital Markets Pty Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/29207 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 12.92% (Balance: 11712.15, Equity: 11712.15, Pips: 19933, Trades: 1435)
MaxDD: 13.45%, ROI: 12.96%
Rating: 99995680 (Started: 2014.02.16 10:00:24, Published: 2014.02.16 10:00:24)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $12000.00 (per one: $4000.00)

29: Name: Traders Family Forex Swing (startumbler)
Broker Server: MaxrichGroup-Real (Maxrich Group Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/65683 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 57.61% (Balance: 12939.30, Equity: 12842.13, Pips: 35873, Trades: 14)
MaxDD: 2.76%, ROI: 28.42%
Rating: 99996737 (Started: 2014.11.03 02:59:38, Published: 2014.11.03 02:59:38)
Subscribers: 6 (Price: $21.00), SignalIncome: $126.00, Funds: $24000.00 (per one: $4000.00)

30: Name: Itc (sheyne)
Broker Server: BMFN-RealCFD (Boston Merchant Financial, Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/51325 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 59.72% (Balance: 9585.62, Equity: 9494.31, Pips: -24185, Trades: 237)
MaxDD: 18.82%, ROI: 58.60%
Rating: 99976216 (Started: 2014.08.07 17:52:57, Published: 2014.08.07 17:52:57)
Subscribers: 5 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $19000.00 (per one: $3800.00)

31: Name: QFract2 (huwei3000)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/49748 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 98.73% (Balance: 19872.81, Equity: 19872.81, Pips: 94472, Trades: 308)
MaxDD: 10.13%, ROI: 98.73%
Rating: 99966058 (Started: 2014.07.27 03:50:29, Published: 2014.08.06 14:24:48)
Subscribers: 4 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $80.00, Funds: $15000.00 (per one: $3750.00)

32: Name: GOOD PROFIT (ALEX_FOREX)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/35539 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 746.86% (Balance: 25861.81, Equity: 25584.27, Pips: 83964, Trades: 118)
MaxDD: 48.82%, ROI: 717.66%
Rating: 99884645 (Started: 2014.04.03 15:14:40, Published: 2014.04.03 15:14:40)
Subscribers: 386 (Price: $29.00), SignalIncome: $11194.00, Funds: $1400000.00 (per one: $3626.94)

33: Name: HGY1160311503 (forex88)
Broker Server: PGI-Live (Planet Group International Holdings Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/45701 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 118.91% (Balance: 43805.58, Equity: 43711.59, Pips: 64209, Trades: 924)
MaxDD: 20.18%, ROI: 118.50%
Rating: 99939847 (Started: 2014.06.23 17:22:58, Published: 2014.06.23 17:22:58)
Subscribers: 19 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $380.00, Funds: $67000.00 (per one: $3526.32)

34: Name: OK FOREX AutoTrade (okforex)
Broker Server: AlpariUK-Micro-2 (Alpari (UK) Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/33777 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 9.58% (Balance: 637.84, Equity: 637.84, Pips: 6957, Trades: 216)
MaxDD: 36.45%, ROI: 0.67%
Rating: 99999979 (Started: 2014.03.21 16:23:09, Published: 2014.03.21 16:23:09)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $25.00), SignalIncome: $25.00, Funds: $3400.00 (per one: $3400.00)

35: Name: HGY522078628 (forex88)
Broker Server: PGI-Live (Planet Group International Holdings Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/45700 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 94.11% (Balance: 97057.45, Equity: 96652.15, Pips: 28221, Trades: 331)
MaxDD: 33.87%, ROI: 93.06%
Rating: 99960861 (Started: 2014.06.23 17:20:17, Published: 2014.06.23 17:20:17)
Subscribers: 3 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $60.00, Funds: $10000.00 (per one: $3333.33)

36: Name: ASC1984 (wizardan)
Broker Server: FXCM-USDReal09 (Forex Capital Markets Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/58109 (Real Account, Leverage: 400)
Gain: 28.66% (Balance: 4453.52, Equity: 4391.87, Pips: 9747, Trades: 87)
MaxDD: 20.19%, ROI: 8.97%
Rating: 99993916 (Started: 2014.09.21 23:35:59, Published: 2014.09.21 23:35:59)
Subscribers: 13 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $42000.00 (per one: $3230.77)

37: Name: RS Zoner (Scorpio4)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/46852 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 56.08% (Balance: 39020.69, Equity: 35578.41, Pips: 38157, Trades: 196)
MaxDD: 23.78%, ROI: 41.97%
Rating: 99979468 (Started: 2014.07.02 18:19:19, Published: 2014.07.02 18:19:19)
Subscribers: 89 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $281000.00 (per one: $3157.30)

38: Name: Tuninvest (mario.oi.92)
Broker Server: FXOpen-Real1 (FXOpen Investments Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/49074 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 250.85% (Balance: 1000.00, Equity: 1005.00, Pips: 14562, Trades: 129)
MaxDD: 57.95%, ROI: 75.40%
Rating: 99976390 (Started: 2014.07.21 10:52:58, Published: 2014.07.21 10:52:58)
Subscribers: 4 (Price: $25.00), SignalIncome: $100.00, Funds: $12000.00 (per one: $3000.00)

39: Name: A1117 (win888)
Broker Server: RoboForex-FixCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/31616 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 269.38% (Balance: 23683.62, Equity: 23683.62, Pips: 18191, Trades: 1310)
MaxDD: 63.75%, ROI: 254.88%
Rating: 99979130 (Started: 2014.03.06 08:05:56, Published: 2014.03.06 08:05:56)
Subscribers: 8 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $23000.00 (per one: $2875.00)

40: Name: Maknyoss (xrondick)
Broker Server: MTrading-Live (ServiceCom Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/65126 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 1939.48% (Balance: 10197.41, Equity: 10147.41, Pips: 1606, Trades: 31)
MaxDD: 9.08%, ROI: 1929.48%
Rating: 99999899 (Started: 2014.10.30 08:36:18, Published: 2014.10.30 08:36:18)
Subscribers: 34 (Price: $21.00), SignalIncome: $714.00, Funds: $95000.00 (per one: $2794.12)

41: Name: AtomAcc Inst 7418 (Dedpistolet)
Broker Server: InstaForex-Cent.com (InstaForex Companies Group)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/35535 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 364.06% (Balance: 2705.89, Equity: 2706.10, Pips: 792, Trades: 128)
MaxDD: 58.72%, ROI: 45.68%
Rating: 99945091 (Started: 2014.04.03 14:36:53, Published: 2014.04.03 14:36:53)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $2600.00 (per one: $2600.00)

42: Name: Bomb Broker (umeghayu)
Broker Server: EGlobal-Cent4 (E-Global Trade and Finance Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/56045 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 379.41% (Balance: 7220.76, Equity: 7583.56, Pips: 12137, Trades: 279)
MaxDD: 58.96%, ROI: 405.57%
Rating: 99999932 (Started: 2014.09.09 18:52:32, Published: 2014.09.09 18:52:32)
Subscribers: 19 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $49000.00 (per one: $2578.95)

43: Name: Aaanna13 (aaanna13)
Broker Server: LiteForex-Lite2.com (Straighthold Investment Group, Inc.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/42715 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 37.05% (Balance: 9586.51, Equity: 9586.51, Pips: -1975, Trades: 209)
MaxDD: 29.52%, ROI: 36.95%
Rating: 99988308 (Started: 2014.06.03 08:01:07, Published: 2014.06.03 11:11:05)
Subscribers: 4 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $9600.00 (per one: $2400.00)

44: Name: LU HU Manual Trading (huangguangquan)
Broker Server: ICMarkets-Live04 (International Capital Markets Pty Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/66385 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 4.66% (Balance: 200.39, Equity: 200.39, Pips: 2043, Trades: 43)
MaxDD: 1.88%, ROI: 4.62%
Rating: 99998526 (Started: 2014.11.06 04:59:14, Published: 2014.11.06 04:59:14)
Subscribers: 19 (Price: $30.00), SignalIncome: $570.00, Funds: $45000.00 (per one: $2368.42)

45: Name: ExtraSafe_AutoTrendTrading (AutoTrading2014)
Broker Server: IronFX-Real14 (IronFX)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/57931 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 21.65% (Balance: 9737.01, Equity: 9202.70, Pips: 22414, Trades: 390)
MaxDD: 21.67%, ROI: 14.84%
Rating: 99996236 (Started: 2014.09.20 03:36:19, Published: 2014.09.20 03:36:19)
Subscribers: 2 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $40.00, Funds: $4700.00 (per one: $2350.00)

46: Name: FAST (shabot)
Broker Server: RoboForex-ProCent (RoboTrade Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/65229 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 642.16% (Balance: 16179.01, Equity: 16179.01, Pips: 9787, Trades: 86)
MaxDD: 43.55%, ROI: 642.16%
Rating: 100000000 (Started: 2014.10.30 16:44:14, Published: 2014.10.30 16:44:14)
Subscribers: 23 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $460.00, Funds: $51000.00 (per one: $2217.39)

47: Name: Syngrabarza (2210272)
Broker Server: XM.COM-Real 2 (Trading Point Of Financial Instruments Ltd)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/66575 (Real Account, Leverage: 200)
Gain: 84.20% (Balance: 10772.00, Equity: 8343.64, Pips: 37048, Trades: 138)
MaxDD: 40.45%, ROI: 39.73%
Rating: 99999087 (Started: 2014.11.06 19:52:45, Published: 2014.11.06 19:52:45)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $2200.00 (per one: $2200.00)

48: Name: TRENDFOLLOWER8 (trendfollower8)
Broker Server: ICMarkets-Live3 (International Capital Markets Pty Ltd.)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/56719 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 72.37% (Balance: 2582.38, Equity: 2582.38, Pips: 14866, Trades: 118)
MaxDD: 17.82%, ROI: 19.24%
Rating: 99975809 (Started: 2014.09.13 07:51:02, Published: 2014.09.13 07:51:02)
Subscribers: 8 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $17000.00 (per one: $2125.00)

49: Name: SmartInvest (a.fatkin)
Broker Server: Alpari-ECN1 (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/64073 (Real Account, Leverage: 100)
Gain: 82.95% (Balance: 846.69, Equity: 844.63, Pips: 14826, Trades: 45)
MaxDD: 9.91%, ROI: 71.15%
Rating: 99954185 (Started: 2014.10.23 20:40:56, Published: 2014.10.23 20:40:56)
Subscribers: 1 (Price: $20.00), SignalIncome: $20.00, Funds: $2100.00 (per one: $2100.00)

50: Name: TradeStatBetav1 (MonArX)
Broker Server: Alpari-Standard2 (Alpari Limited)
URL: http://www.mql5.com/en/signals/37362 (Real Account, Leverage: 500)
Gain: 12.93% (Balance: 3387.87, Equity: 3187.72, Pips: 13270, Trades: 867)
MaxDD: 81.11%, ROI: 6.52%
Rating: 99999939 (Started: 2014.04.17 13:54:23, Published: 2014.04.17 13:54:23)
Subscribers: 8 (Price: $0.00), SignalIncome: $0.00, Funds: $16000.00 (per one: $2000.00) 

[[Удален]]

Сам сделал пока такие выводы:

• Средний подписчик имеет ~$3-4K, из которых он готов ежемесячно платить за услуги сервиса ~1%.
• Многим на показания просадки плевать (есть и > 90%). Главное - плавность кривой баланса.
• У многих популярных сигналов используются пересиживатели - нет отрицательных сделок.
• Почти все популярные сигналы на центовых счетах.
• Практически все популярные сигналы - представители территорий бСССР и Ю-В Азии: Индонезия, Малайзия и т.д. Видимо, трейдинг и подобные схемы процветают там, где средний уровень дохода населения невысок.

В общем, складывается впечатление, что сервис владельцы сигнала используют для краткосрочного развода.

Один из вариантов использования:

• сделать несколько пересиживателей и усреднителей.
• Под каждый забацать свою учетку и зарегить в сигналы на центовиках.
• Что-то сольется, но что-то будет показывать отличный результат.
• Ждать от последнего профит от платных подписок.
• Использовать также можно различные уловки в тех. несовершенстве центовиков для создания впечатления граальности. Например, арбитраж любого вида и т.д.
• Ну и маркетинг, явно, очень сильно влияет. Причем его тупость не важна. Главное - массовое распространение.
• Короче, все законы бизнеса действуют и здесь.

[[Удален]]

Ни то хорошие управляющие хотят работать за фиксированный процент, а не за фиксированную абонентскую плату.

Ни то хороших управляющих просто нет. Грустно. 

[[Удален]]

Сервис действительно используется частью поставщиков для развода. Но и нормальные управляющие есть.

В этом сервисе есть некоторая стратегическая ошибка. Они увидели успешную схему  - памм, и пытаются ее копировать один-в-один. Нет, с одной стороны правильно конечно, многие клонеры успешнее оригинала, но почему вы не видите уникальных особенностей и возможностей сервиса? Возможности для развития тут гигантские, но метаквоты мышей не ловят, совсем. Черт, такие возможности для развития бизнеса пропадают :)

[[Удален]]

Отсортировав по длительности трейда нашел почти HFT-ника... Пока я забанен, историю не посмотреть.

[[Удален]]

Но есть и невезунчики какие-то. Вот этот парень, например, подходит под многие выводы, но ни одного подписчика до сих пор. В чем тут может быть причина - не пойму.

[[Удален]]

Легко выдрать историю любого сигнала и сделать стандартные  History-Signal.Order*-методы - аналоги OrderOpenPrice, OrderCloseTime и т.д. После чего любой индикатор-визуализатор истории будет показывать историю торговли сигнала сходу. Мне в лом писать это, т.к. пока не вижу полезной отдачи для себя от такой возможности.

[Vitalie Postolache]

lob32371:
Отсортировав по длительности трейда нашел почти HFT-ника... Пока я забанен, историю не посмотреть.

Какой же это высокочастотник, за 5 месяцев - 19 сделок, причём оба сигнала повторяются...

И ещё он любитель без предупреждения пополнять депозит, а это для клиента нехорошо, на его-то счёте автоматически пополнение не повторится.

lob32371:
Но есть и невезунчики какие-то. Вот этот парень, например, подходит под многие выводы, но ни одного подписчика до сих пор. В чем тут может быть причина - не пойму.

У этого всё ещё впереди, всего 3 недели торгует, а уже 2 подписчика, будут ещё, если выживет. Плохо, что закрывает сделки поздно, не забирает всё что мог бы.