Prop firm challenges: how many of you failed because of the loss limits?

How many of you have lost a prop firm challenge because of the loss limits (daily or maximum), and not because of the strategy?

And what would have helped you the most to pass? A clearer rule from the firm, an alert before reaching the limit, a fixed daily routine, smaller position sizes, or something else?

I am curious to hear different experiences.
Hi Amedeo,

I'm one of them. My EA setup ran through both phases for about 1.5 years, then a forex pair opened with a big gap over the stops. The daily limit was 5 %, the day ended at round about 7 %.
A grid EA on the same account was already sitting in floating loss, so the gap didn't have to do it alone.

An alert wouldn't have saved me. The gap came at the open, there was no time to react. What would have helped is knowing before the market closes how much all open positions together can lose if price jumps, not only what each single stop says.

Smaller size is the honest answer, but it has a catch. With EAs I had to cut the risk so much that the challenge would have taken forever. Thats the real conflict for me, the profit target wants speed and the daily limit punishes it.

Best regards,
Chris
Hi Chris, thank you, this is very useful.

A gap through the stop is a different problem, because the stop price is not the price you actually get. Two questions to understand it better: would one number for all open positions be enough, for a gap of a fixed size (for example 1% or 2% on every market), or would you want it per market? And did your firm count the gap loss against the daily limit even though it came at the open?

Also, the grid EA already in floating loss on the same account sounds like the real multiplier here.

For me the number that decided it was the worst day of the book, not the worst trade. I replayed one month of my own index setups across four markets, about 35 trades a day, and the worst single day came to minus 17.6 R. Red days were red almost everywhere at once, on one of them all seven of my Nasdaq trades stopped out. At 1 percent per trade that day alone is minus 17.6 percent, so I went down to 0.25 percent per trade to keep it inside a 4.5 percent cap. In my backtests cutting size also beat tightening the stop. A looser loss stop earned more but breached two to three times as often, while halving the size lowered the breach risk without costing expectancy per trade. Like Chris I doubt an alert would have saved me. What helps is one guard that watches account equity including floating, closes at a margin below the firm's number and scales size down as the drawdown grows. It cannot do anything about a gap though, so the worst day has to fit before the guard ever fires.

Thanks Timon-pascal, this is the most useful number in the thread. Your 4.5 percent cap divided by 17.6 R gives about 0.256 percent, so 0.25 percent per trade is exactly the size where your worst replayed day just fits, which makes the rule easy to check on other data. I built a guard of this kind for myself: it watches equity including floating, closes everything at 90 percent of the firm’s limit and locks the account for the day. It does not scale size down, and like you say it cannot do anything about a gap. Two questions if you don’t mind: do you take the worst day from each market or from all four together, since the red days were red almost everywhere at once? And does your guard scale the size in steps or smoothly as the drawdown grows?
Chris, your case is the one the equity guards in this thread cannot fix, so here is what I do about the gap part.

Since nothing can react to a gap, the only defense is before the close. Two simple options:

1. Flatten before the market closes (Friday especially). No open position, no gap. Costs some trades, but for a challenge the daily limit matters more than one held trade.

2. If you must hold, do the check you described: for every open position, lots x contract size x a gap you accept (say 1%), add them up, and compare with the room left under the daily limit. If the sum is bigger than the room, cut size before the close, not after.

The grid EA makes this worse, like Amedeo said: the floating loss already eats the room, so the gap only needs a small move to finish the day.

On the profit target vs daily limit conflict: I stopped trying to solve it with one size. Normal size early in the day, then smaller once the room left under the limit gets thin.
Thanks Youness, the pre-close check is the part I was missing.

One detail that changes the numbers: at firms where the daily limit is measured from the balance at the start of the day, a losing position you hold into Monday already uses part of Monday's limit before the gap. So on Friday the room to compare is Monday's limit minus the floating loss you carry over, not what is left of today. Worth checking how your firm defines the start of the day.

Chris, which symbols do you usually hold over the weekend? Gold and indices can gap at the Sunday open, while crypto usually keeps trading through the weekend, so there the risk is not the gap but a big move while you are away. That is why the 1% is worth setting per symbol.
Amedeo Nustriani #:
Hi Chris, thank you, this is very useful.

A gap through the stop is a different problem, because the stop price is not the price you actually get. Two questions to understand it better: would one number for all open positions be enough, for a gap of a fixed size (for example 1% or 2% on every market), or would you want it per market? And did your firm count the gap loss against the daily limit even though it came at the open?

Also, the grid EA already in floating loss on the same account sounds like the real multiplier here.
Thanks Amedeo,

yes, it counted. The firm looks at equity, so the loss from the gap went straight into the daily limit and that day ended the challenge. That it came at the open didnt matter at all.

For the gap size I would set it per market. A 1 % jump on a major pair is rare, on gold or an index it happens much more often. But in the end i want one number in money, the sum of all open positions, because the limit doesn't care which symbol caused it.

About the weekend, I don't remember anymore if that gap was a Monday open. But I don't touch my EAs, so whatever they hold on Friday stays open over the weekend. Today I trade only my own money, no prop accounts. The daily limit is gone, the gap risk is still there.

Your point about the balance at the start of the day was new to me. So a floating loss from Friday already eats part of Monday's room before anything happens.

Chris :)

Chris, “one number in money for all open positions” is the right way to see it, since the limit doesn’t care which symbol caused the loss.

One more thing I would put into that number: spread widening at rollover.

On many prop firms the daily limit resets around midnight server time, which is also when rollover happens and spreads widen. Floating P/L is calculated at the current bid/ask, so even without any price gap, a wider spread pushes the floating loss up on every open position right at the start of the new day. If the account is already close to the limit, that short spike alone can be enough to breach it.

At the weekend open it is usually worse, with thin liquidity on metals and indices.

So I would add a spread buffer on top of the gap buffer, or simply avoid holding through rollover when the room left is small.

lost quite a few challenges due to the daily drawdown (DD) limit.

The gap risk point is the one most people miss. A daily limit is usually checked against closed P/L, but a gap can blow through the limit before any alert fires. Two things that help: (1) calculate the worst-case loss across all open positions using each instrument's typical gap size, not just the stop loss, and size down if that total exceeds the limit; (2) close or hedge before high-impact news or session opens, since that is when gaps cluster. The conflict between profit target speed and daily limit safety is real — the answer is usually a smaller risk per trade with a longer time horizon, not a larger one.