All John Ehlers Indicators... - page 53

stockspotter

Looks that John open a new site to sell his ideas.

http://www.stockspotter.com/

And video with pdf

StockSpotter.com - Contact Us

His new idea seems to be based on a new filter called roofing filter which for me is just band pass filter. See enclosure.

Did anybody make any strategy based on this filter and Walk Forward test ??

Corresponding thread on bigmetrading is here

https://www.bigmiketrading.com/traders-hideout/27585-webinar-john-ehlers-indicators-effective-trading-strategies-5.html#post361943

Hmmm. Seems John tries again to sell some trading signals after failure and closing his eminiz site which was based on Corona charts...

Krzysztof

Krzysztof

They have already been converted to metatrader (starting from this post https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/174980/page32)

As usual, what John Ehlers tells should be taken with a grain of salt but it seems that we were able to squeeze what is usable from it too (adaptive super smoother, for example, is not a bad way to filter data in my opinion, even though some other ways of adapting could be tested on it). As of his trading signals : he is probably a good engineer but so far he haven't proved that he is as good a trader too - all his attempts in that part of the world so far were failures, which shows that it is not enough to have just one part of a trading knowledge to be a good trader too.

HELLO MLADEN,

Please kindly assist with a HISTO VERSION OF ROOFING FILTER 2 which you made in POST 511.

THANKS FOR THE GREAT WORK

HELLO MLADEN,

Please my request in preceding post is for the HISTO VERSION of this indicator,THANKS for everything.

Winner246, this would be the Roofing filter 2 histo version.

HELLO MRTOOLS,

THANKS For your kind assistance.

I just attended John Ehler live webinar. (stock spotter sent me invitation)

For my questions I got following answers

1) What is a difference between bad pass and roofing filters. Answer was better attenuation on the bands so better.

2) For what time frame his new technique is applicable. Answer was he is using for daily charts but for all TF is OK.

Hmmm this needs to be proven. Daily charts has little bars so easy to fit whatever to them specially if you choose

sideways period.

3) Is this technique applicable for HF FOREX data - no answer

4) Is this technique will work if data will have strong trends - no answer

5) I asked him also if he made any Walk Forward Test for any instruments using this technique - also no answer

Well, he was recommending his new book and stock spotter service quite much instead...

In next few days I will make some Walk Forward tests using John's stochastic strategy in comparison to

ordinary stochastic strategy on the same data sets so we will is if it extracts some more trade-able info.

Krzysztof

here is an info about Nyquist-Shannon Moving Average (together with MT4 code) which suppose to be superior to Ehler's MA.

Did anybody tried it already ??

stevehopwoodforex.com • View topic - Nyquist-Shannon Moving Average

Krzysztof

Krzysztof

Are they talking about this MA : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/182120

If they are, I do not think that they are on a right track (quite frankly it is too complicated to use and the results are not what one would expect from a good average/filter).

Not the question if something is superior to Ehlers' ma (Ehlers is not good in the field of MAs - some his attempts like the one he named "zero lag ma" are frankly anything but serious) but a comparison to some much better filters immediately comes to mind and then that ma is not going to be so shiny

Fisher or Solar Wind No repaint Indicator

Any one please post MTF Fisher or Solar Wind No repaint with alert Indicator ....