Multi Timeframe Indicators - page 1077

bobbie
34
bobbie  

Dear Mladen and Mr.tools,

There was a paper clip for every thread in this forum..where is it now?i don't see it anymore

William Snyder
9493
William Snyder  
mahnooj:
many many thanks mladen, yes just checking now and as you said this is more efficient & the signals seems to be stable as well....:) would be grateful if you could ever make a MTF version please....

Mahnooj, added mtf.

ddstochastic_1_1_mtf.mq4

Yangwoo Park
225
Yangwoo Park  
mladen:
Re: Multi Timeframe Indicators The upgraded traders dynamic index with visual and all other alerts, multi time frame version : traders_dynamic_index_visual_alerts_mtf_3.mq4

Dear mladen

Is it possible for you to make it show lower timeframes? For example, I want to display 60M and 15M TDI on 4H chart. In addition, it would be great if it automatically shifts TF up to two lower TFs. My scenario is when I open 4H chart, it shows 4H, 60M and 15M TDIs, then I change it to Daily chart, it automatically shows Daily, 4H and 60M TDI..... Of course the scale should match the current TF accordingly. I find watching lower TF MTF is much more useful than watching higer TF MTF, which is repainting until the higher TF bar closes.

Thank you.

Mladen Rakic
153781
Mladen Rakic  
heispark:

Dear mladen

Is it possible for you to make it show lower timeframes? For example, I want to display 60M and 15M TDI on 4H chart. In addition, it would be great if it automatically shifts TF up to two lower TFs. My scenario is when I open 4H chart, it shows 4H, 60M and 15M TDIs, then I change it to Daily chart, it automatically shows Daily, 4H and 60M TDI..... Of course the scale should match the current TF accordingly. I find watching lower TF MTF is much more useful than watching higer TF MTF, which is repainting until the higher TF bar closes.

Thank you.

heispark

That is not possible to do (you have to throw out some lower time frame data, and there is no way to decide which data to use. For example : on a 4h time frame you would have to eliminate 15 out of 16 bars belonging to 15 minute chart. Which one would you use, and why that ne and not one of the remaining 15?). All in all, lower time frame display on a higher time frame chart can not be done without big loss of data

Yangwoo Park
225
Yangwoo Park  
mladen:

heispark

That is not possible to do (you have to throw out some lower time frame data, and there is no way to decide which data to use. For example : on a 4h time frame you would have to eliminate 15 out of 16 bars belonging to 15 minute chart. Which one would you use, and why that ne and not one of the remaining 15?). All in all, lower time frame display on a higher time frame chart can not be done without big loss of data

Thank you very much sir. It makes sense to me.

There's a version of MTF TDI which I found at ForexFactory. It supports lower TF already (not automatic though). Could you please have a look at this code to see if it also loses data as you explained? I thought it would be useful (and indeed made some good forward test result), but I may be wrong if it loses any data....

Thank you.

Mladen Rakic
153781
Mladen Rakic  
heispark:

Thank you very much sir. It makes sense to me.

There's a version of MTF TDI which I found at ForexFactory. It supports lower TF already (not automatic though). Could you please have a look at this code to see if it also loses data as you explained? I thought it would be useful (and indeed made some good forward test result), but I may be wrong if it loses any data....

Thank you.

heispark

Every lower time frame display on a higher time frame chart loses data. There is no way to avoid that (regardless of the code used - for example : there is simply no way to display sixteen 15 minute bars values in one 4 hour bar - that is not possible)

________________

That indicator will, in the case of 15 minute display on a 4 hour chart, display a 15 minute value of the start of the 4 hour period and then ignore next 15 values, and so on and on. People often forget that higher time frame has less data than lower time frame (lower data time resolution) and that you can not see lower time without a loss

Yangwoo Park
225
Yangwoo Park  
mladen:

heispark

Every lower time frame display on a higher time frame chart loses data. There is no way to avoid that (regardless of the code used - for example : there is simply no way to display sixteen 15 minute bars values in one 4 hour bar - that is not possible)

________________

That indicator will, in the case of 15 minute display on a 4 hour chart, display a 15 minute value of the start of the 4 hour period and then ignore next 15 values, and so on and on. People often forget that higher time frame has less data than lower time frame (lower data time resolution) and that you can not see lower time without a loss

Thank you sir. Now understand your point! My idea looked good at first but it turned out to be an illogical myth... You're the myth burster!

Thanks

mahnooj
76
mahnooj  
mrtools:

Mahnooj, added mtf.

ddstochastic_1_1_mtf.mq4

thanx a ton mrtools....

Tam
197
Tam  
heispark:

Thank you very much sir. It makes sense to me.

There's a version of MTF TDI which I found at ForexFactory. It supports lower TF already (not automatic though). Could you please have a look at this code to see if it also loses data as you explained? I thought it would be useful (and indeed made some good forward test result), but I may be wrong if it loses any data....

Thank you.

Those lines look arbitrary there

toddanderson
495
toddanderson  

Hi,

Could someone please make this indicator MTF, thank you inadvanced

Files: