Moving Average - page 87

[rahul701]

Hi mladen , I found this indicator Pretty_t3_LK_V1.2.mq4 , which i found quite interesting bcoz of its smoothness. But the problem is i think it repaints though i tried to test it extensively but just couldnt find enough evidence of it repainting. So for reference I am attaching the image. If possible can you please make its non repainting version. Regards, rahul Edit: Thanks to eurusd i caught it repainted redhanded . So its confirmed it repaints

[Mladen Rakic]

Rahul

Use the one from this post https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/173058/page16 (to get it paint on slope change the SlopeLimit to some big value (1000 for example would be enough for any symbol I guess) Also set the T3Original to true to get the same values as the one you posted

rahul701:
Hi mladen , I found this indicator Pretty_t3_LK_V1.2.mq4 , which i found quite interesting bcoz of its smoothness. But the problem is i think it repaints though i tried to test it extensively but just couldnt find enough evidence of it repainting. So for reference I am attaching the image. If possible can you please make its non repainting version. Regards, rahul Edit: Thanks to eurusd i caught it repainted redhanded . So its confirmed it repaints

[rahul701]

mladen:
Rahul Use the one from this post https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/173058/page16 (to get it paint on slope change the SlopeLimit to some big value (1000 for example would be enough for any symbol I guess) Also set the T3Original to true to get the same values as the one you posted

Really Thks a lot mladen. A Perfect nrp version. One question mladen: In previous version(Pretty_t3_LK_V1.2) there in comments i saw following codes for prices : "Close: 0, Open: 1, High: 2, Low: 3 Median: 4, Typical: 5, Weighted: 6". Are these codes common for all Mt4 indicators involving pricetype or are hardcoded. Actually I used to think that for Price type there are 2 values(0 and 1) 0 means that values are calculated at bar close and 1 means values at bar open. So does these codes apply to hma_pricetype option in hmanrp version too. Regards, Rahul

[Mladen Rakic]

...

Rahul

Those are usual values when it comes to metatrader using prices. So, if any code asks you for a price (except stochastic which has a close/close and high/low "prices") you can use those values

rahul701:
Really Thks a lot mladen. A Perfect nrp version. One question mladen: In previous version(Pretty_t3_LK_V1.2) there in comments i saw following codes for prices : "Close: 0, Open: 1, High: 2, Low: 3 Median: 4, Typical: 5, Weighted: 6". Are these codes common for all Mt4 indicators involving pricetype or are hardcoded. Actually I used to think that for Price type there are 2 values(0 and 1) 0 means that values are calculated at bar close and 1 means values at bar open. So does these codes apply to hma_pricetype option in hmanrp version too. Regards, Rahul

[keth22]

TMA centered

hai mladen can u make arrow cross for Tma centered/snake with original MA mt4....a big thank u....sorry for my bad english

[Mladen Rakic]

...

keth22

Older members already know what I am going to answer and I guess that they are laughing now : centered TMA recalculates (repaint) Placing arrows as a kind of a "signal" on it (even in a combination with a non-recalculating indicator) is not a good idea and is very dangerous. Centered TMA, in my opinion, should never be used in a "signaling mode"

All the best

keth22:
hai mladen can u make arrow cross for Tma centered/snake with original MA mt4....a big thank u....sorry for my bad english

[keth22]

thank u

mladen:
keth22

Older members already know what I am going to answer and I guess that they are laughing now : centered TMA recalculates (repaint) Placing arrows as a kind of a "signal" on it (even in a combination with a non-recalculating indicator) is not a good idea and is very dangerous. Centered TMA, in my opinion, should never be used in a "signaling mode"

All the best

i know it's repaint i just try to make combination with other indi and so far good to me...thank's for the advise...best regard

[secretcode]

Guys

This is decompiled indicator !!

But the indicator (ex4) freely available on their site 'http://www.scientific-trading.com'

The indicator bit heavy on cpu and there are 3 option in it (MA_correction) to work differently using different math !

MA_correction = 0 : Regular MA

MA_correction = 1 : EHLER ( shown image )

MA_correction = 2 : DUERSCHNER

I am very much interested and would be appreciated if any master coder makes 2 different indicators using 1) EHLER and 2) DUERSCHNER calculation

ps- 'dll' need to be in 'libraries' folder

Thanks

secretcode

[techmac]

Just one observation (without any other intention - after all that is a decompiled code) : comparing something to Ehlers "zero lag" average (which is, all in all not an average at all but a trick of how to subtract price to average difference from some average to make it look good) is not such a good reference for something that should be a reliable average. And lines like this :

int li_24 = MA_DLL(li_16, lda_4, MA_Period, MA_Method, MA_priceType, MA_correction, 1000000, lda_20);

(working with fixed size arrays within the dll even though the li_16 does have the actual number of bars calculated) are even less assuring of some other things

[secretcode]

techmac:
Just one observation (without any other intention - after all that is a decompiled code) : comparing something to Ehlers "zero lag" average (which is, all in all not an average at all but a trick of how to subtract price to average difference from some average to make it look good) is not such a good reference for something that should be a reliable average. And lines like this : (working with fixed size arrays within the dll even though the li_16 does have the actual number of bars calculated) are even less assuring of some other things

Thanks for your effort