• Get access

Requests & Ideas - page 229

Mladen Rakic
163387
Mladen Rakic  
Hermo:
Thank you mladen!

But..is there another option to do a good backtests?

Thank you in advance!

Hermo

Hermo

As far as metatrader EAs are concerned, there is no other acceptable (100% compatible) way of backtesting

Mladen Rakic
163387
Mladen Rakic  
protrade:
Hi Mr Tools or Mladen. I had an idea for an indicator a couple of weeks back and have not seen anything posted like it here so far so here goes: It is basically two regular MACDs on a chart with one inverted. I was playing around with placing two MACDs on a chart and found some interesting signal crosses when the settings on one is inverted. But it can't just be any settings to create this effect. It has to be no-lag settings on both. So I came up with 10-26-1 for one MACD and 26-10-1 for the other and you'll see how it looks on the attached image. The crossings do appear as if they are floating though, at least some do. Don't know why. If you can create an alert when the orange line (in image) crosses the yellow line, I think it would be a really good indicator.

protrade

It can not be made the way you set it up (and I recommend that you do not use it the way you set it up). Let me explain : when two indicators are placed ate the same subwindow metatrader is adjust the vertical position of the two (if they do not have the same minimum and maximum value - and MACD does not have a known minimum and/or maximum). So it completely depends on the minimum and maximum values of the indicator on the visible segment of the chart you are currently observing. And there is the catch : if the minimum or maximum value of the indicator changes then all (including the places where you have those crosses) will change

In short : you will have a heavily repainting indicator. As a test : place it on a 1 minute chart and observe how will the crosses change places as the time passes (and minimum and maximums change).

On the other hand, if we place two MACD indicators in the same subwindow and anchor them to 0, the crosses will always happen on a place where MACD crosses 0 line.

KT
100
KT  

Ohh ok thanks for explaining it Mladen.

mladen:
protrade

It can not be made the way you set it up (and I recommend that you do not use it the way you set it up). Let me explain : when two indicators are placed ate the same subwindow metatrader is adjust the vertical position of the two (if they do not have the same minimum and maximum value - and MACD does not have a known minimum and/or maximum). So it completely depends on the minimum and maximum values of the indicator on the visible segment of the chart you are currently observing. And there is the catch : if the minimum or maximum value of the indicator changes then all (including the places where you have those crosses) will change

In short : you will have a heavily repainting indicator. As a test : place it on a 1 minute chart and observe how will the crosses change places as the time passes (and minimum and maximums change).

On the other hand, if we place two MACD indicators in the same subwindow and anchor them to 0, the crosses will always happen on a place where MACD crosses 0 line.
Hermo
383
Hermo  

Thank you mladen,

so, I understand that you can find another way to backtest (without metatrader). Could you teach me on that or give me a reference/link to learn it?

For example, what is your method to try the codes (it's what I really want to know, because I thought it was with MT4)? If is this case, do you know other similar/better?

Two different questions...but talking about the same, more or less.

Thank you in advance!

Hermo

mladen:
Hermo As far as metatrader EAs are concerned, there is no other acceptable (100% compatible) way of backtesting
Mladen Rakic
163387
Mladen Rakic  
Hermo:
Thank you mladen,

so, I understand that you can find another way to backtest (without metatrader). Could you teach me on that or give me a reference/link to learn it?

For example, what is your method to try the codes (it's what I really want to know, because I thought it was with MT4)? If is this case, do you know other similar/better?

Two different questions...but talking about the same, more or less.

Thank you in advance!

Hermo

Hermo

There were some alternative to metatrader back-testing and I was trying one or two but I gave up due to too much incompatibilities

So, for that last 2-3 years the code I always try with metatrader and frankly do not know a better way to test it

William Snyder
9493
William Snyder  
nevar:
MrTools,

Here is the link https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/179807/page102

If it is calculating TMA Centered then it is recalculating, is it possible to replace TMA centered calculation with JMA or any other MA ?Thanks.

Nevar,

Will see what I can do but can't make any promises on it.

KT
100
KT  

Hi Mr Tools or Mladen, can you make this Stix indicator multi-time frame please? Also if you can make an EA version of it too, that would be great. Thanks.

William Snyder
9493
William Snyder  
protrade:
Hi Mr Tools or Mladen, can you make this Stix indicator multi-time frame please? Also if you can make an EA version of it too, that would be great. Thanks.

Protrade this is the mtf version and a stripped down EA version.

Files:
KT
100
KT  

Thanks so much Mr Tools. Awesome!

mrtools:
Protrade this is the mtf version and a stripped down EA version.
MikhaelPankov
60
MikhaelPankov  

Good evening, Mladen ! I would like to make a request about the option of upgrading

the indicator from mq4 into mq.5, of course, if it is possible for technical reasons.

I’ve heard that the members of advanced elite have the right to apply with such a request

once a month . This is the wondered one and if that is the wrong thread - please, correct me.

Have a nice weekend, Mikhael. inverse_fisher_transform_of_oma_rsi.mq4