tonny, I'm really.really.really not trying to fuss with you. If I understood your question then I wouldn't have asked for clarification. Unfortunately, your response did very little to explain what you mean. Therefore I'll try again.
Is the 1_million dollars guarantee to happen within the 5_years?
Is the 100_thousand dollars guarantee to happen within the 5_years?
dont poll let those who understand poll then ill explain in the end dont worry
tonny, I'm really.really.really not trying to fuss with you. If I understood your question then I wouldn't have asked for clarification. Unfortunately, your response did very little to explain what you mean. Therefore I'll try again.
Is the 1_million dollars guarantee to happen within the 5_years?
Is the 100_thousand dollars guarantee to happen within the 5_years?
If I understood well, that will happen, so I don't see why someone would take 100.000$ when he can get 1 million$.
Angevoyageur this is exactly what i wanted to expose. Most traders with their impatience end up with little and leave the bigger cake. As you can see just as i expected, majority chose 100k over a million all they want is to just see 10-20 trades a day if you give them something that trades once a week theyll down play it and remove it after just 3 days without trades nomatter what it promises annually. To those who chose 100k know that forex is about trusting a strategy and giving it time by being patient.
tonny: Angevoyageur this is exactly what i wanted to expose. Most traders with their impatience end up with little and leave the bigger cake. As you can see just as i expected, majority chose 100k over a million all they want is to just see 10-20 trades a day if you give them something that trades once a week theyll down play it and remove it after just 3 days without trades nomatter what it promises annually. To those who chose 100k know that forex is about trusting a strategy and giving it time by being patient.
I agree and confirm this behaviour. I have see similar reaction about drawdown, some "traders" are thinking a good trader is someone who trade without drawdown and with a linear profit progression. In my opinion, the first thing to learn to become a winning trader is to accept to lose some trades.
Humm, I wonder how many people understood the question. I wonder who would make such guarantee in trading. I wonder how they would justify such guarantee based on one-trade in five-years.
Humm, I wonder how many people understood the question. I wonder who would make such guarantee in trading. I wonder how they would justify such guarantee based on one-trade in five-years.
Possibly not many . . . No signal provider would provide a guarantee of any sort.
The problem of drawdown is that if the signal provider has made 50% profit since first going live (100 --> 150) and then has 20% DD (150 --> 120) he is still up 20%, a subscriber that just recently started following the signal is down 20% and feeling uncomfortable . . . this is not workable for a subscriber that has an agenda of income rather than capital growth.
Possibly not many . . . No signal provider would provide a guarantee of any sort.
The problem of drawdown is that if the signal provider has made 50% profit since first going live (100 --> 150) and then has 20% DD (150 --> 120) he is still up 20%, a subscriber that just recently started following the signal is down 20% and feeling uncomfortable . . . this is not workable for a subscriber that has an agenda of income rather than capital growth.
You are right, but this is inevitable if you want to follow a signal. This is possible to have very little drawdown, but this is not mandatory to have a good EA or manual trading system. Maybe that would be a criteria for a signal but then your choice is very thin.
I agree with both of you guys. I also think tonny's question to his credit was fair enough. Personally, I would find it very difficult to trade a signal which triggered once every 5-years on average. The top-3 paid signals (based upon subscribers) on the signals page have draw-downs. Seems to trade EurUsd only. And all of them adds to position as time goes by.
Those systems are a slap in the face towards traditional system of fixed_lot and let_profits_run. Imo, the things most contributing toward their success are 1) low-draw-down%, 2) low_spreads_EurUsd and 3) time_based_averaging. Also these systems are quite active. What'll happen to them in the future however... is anyone's guess.
Ok, I got off-track about what I really wanted to say, and that is, all systems have draw-down. Its not a matter of what but rather how-much.
I agree with both of you guys. I also think tonny's question to his credit was fair enough. Personally, I would find it very difficult to trade a signal which triggered once every 5-years on average. The top-3 paid signals (based upon subscribers) on the signals page have draw-downs. Seems to trade EurUsd only. And all of them adds to position as time goes by.
Those systems are a slap in the face towards traditional system of fixed_lot and let_profits_run. Imo, the things most contributing toward their success are 1) low-draw-down%, 2) low_spreads_EurUsd and 3) time_based_averaging. Also these systems are quite active. What'll happen to them in the future however... is anyone's guess.
Ok, I got off-track about what I really wanted to say, and that is, all systems have draw-down. Its not a matter of what but rather how-much.
It would be very interesting to analyse signals publicly, but unfortunately it's difficult with the rules.
Allow the use of cookies to log in to the MQL5.com website.
Please enable the necessary setting in your browser, otherwise you will not be able to log in.
You are signed in. Two-factor authentication has been disabled. Set it up again and scan a new QR code, or continue with two-factor authentication disabled.
tonny, I'm really.really.really not trying to fuss with you. If I understood your question then I wouldn't have asked for clarification. Unfortunately, your response did very little to explain what you mean. Therefore I'll try again.
tonny, I'm really.really.really not trying to fuss with you. If I understood your question then I wouldn't have asked for clarification. Unfortunately, your response did very little to explain what you mean. Therefore I'll try again.
Angevoyageur this is exactly what i wanted to expose. Most traders with their impatience end up with little and leave the bigger cake. As you can see just as i expected, majority chose 100k over a million all they want is to just see 10-20 trades a day if you give them something that trades once a week theyll down play it and remove it after just 3 days without trades nomatter what it promises annually. To those who chose 100k know that forex is about trusting a strategy and giving it time by being patient.
Humm, I wonder how many people understood the question. I wonder who would make such guarantee in trading. I wonder how they would justify such guarantee based on one-trade in five-years.
Humm, I wonder how many people understood the question. I wonder who would make such guarantee in trading. I wonder how they would justify such guarantee based on one-trade in five-years.
Possibly not many . . . No signal provider would provide a guarantee of any sort.
The problem of drawdown is that if the signal provider has made 50% profit since first going live (100 --> 150) and then has 20% DD (150 --> 120) he is still up 20%, a subscriber that just recently started following the signal is down 20% and feeling uncomfortable . . . this is not workable for a subscriber that has an agenda of income rather than capital growth.
Possibly not many . . . No signal provider would provide a guarantee of any sort.
The problem of drawdown is that if the signal provider has made 50% profit since first going live (100 --> 150) and then has 20% DD (150 --> 120) he is still up 20%, a subscriber that just recently started following the signal is down 20% and feeling uncomfortable . . . this is not workable for a subscriber that has an agenda of income rather than capital growth.
I agree with both of you guys. I also think tonny's question to his credit was fair enough. Personally, I would find it very difficult to trade a signal which triggered once every 5-years on average. The top-3 paid signals (based upon subscribers) on the signals page have draw-downs. Seems to trade EurUsd only. And all of them adds to position as time goes by.
Those systems are a slap in the face towards traditional system of fixed_lot and let_profits_run. Imo, the things most contributing toward their success are 1) low-draw-down%, 2) low_spreads_EurUsd and 3) time_based_averaging. Also these systems are quite active. What'll happen to them in the future however... is anyone's guess.
Ok, I got off-track about what I really wanted to say, and that is, all systems have draw-down. Its not a matter of what but rather how-much.
I agree with both of you guys. I also think tonny's question to his credit was fair enough. Personally, I would find it very difficult to trade a signal which triggered once every 5-years on average. The top-3 paid signals (based upon subscribers) on the signals page have draw-downs. Seems to trade EurUsd only. And all of them adds to position as time goes by.
Those systems are a slap in the face towards traditional system of fixed_lot and let_profits_run. Imo, the things most contributing toward their success are 1) low-draw-down%, 2) low_spreads_EurUsd and 3) time_based_averaging. Also these systems are quite active. What'll happen to them in the future however... is anyone's guess.
Ok, I got off-track about what I really wanted to say, and that is, all systems have draw-down. Its not a matter of what but rather how-much.