How to Read an MQL5 Tester Report: Profit Factor, Drawdown, Equity vs Balance
20 十一月 2026, 02:34
0
4
The MQL5 strategy tester prints about thirty numbers. Most people look at net profit, close the window and go live. That is how accounts die. Here is the order I read the report in, and what each number is actually telling you.
Start with the deal count, not the profit
The first line I look at is total trades. If a report shows 40 deals over ten months, the profit is noise. Statistically you cannot distinguish a good system from a lucky one at 40 samples, especially with a low win rate. My rough floor is 200 closed trades before I take any number in the report seriously.
Then check the trade duration. If the average position lives for fewer than three bars of the tested timeframe, the result depends on intrabar behaviour that the tester approximates. Switch to every-tick model and rerun before believing it.
Profit factor is a ratio, not a grade
Profit factor is gross profit divided by gross loss. Above 1.3 is usable, above 1.6 is good, above 3 is suspicious. A very high profit factor usually means few losses and a short sample, or a grid system that hides many small wins against one giant loss that has not happened yet.
Pair it with win rate and average win over average loss. A system with a 30 percent win rate needs an average win about 2.5 times the average loss just to break even. If the report shows 30 percent win rate and 1.2 average win ratio, the profit factor cannot be real; you are probably looking at an unfinished test.
Drawdown: check both absolute and relative
There are two drawdowns: maximal balance drawdown and maximal equity drawdown. Balance drawdown only counts closed trades, so a system that holds losing positions for weeks looks calm on balance and terrifying on equity. Always read the equity figure.
Then divide it by starting deposit. A 300 USD drawdown on a 5000 USD account is 6 percent, which is normal. The same 300 USD on a 500 USD account is 60 percent, which is an account-ending number in practice, because margin calls arrive faster than statistics.
Also look at the drawdown duration, not just depth. A 20 percent drawdown that lasted three months will break most people's discipline long before it recovers.
Equity versus balance curve
The tester can draw both. The gap between them is the open floating loss. If the equity line runs consistently below the balance line and only catches up at trade close, you are looking at a system that carries losers and takes profits quickly. That shape works until one loser does not come back.
If the balance line is smooth and the equity line zigzags wildly, position management is doing the work, not the entry logic. That matters when you try to change the lot size later: the smoothness disappears.
The four numbers that kill most reports
Expected payoff is net profit divided by deals. Under 0.5 in account currency per trade means the system lives on spread luck. If your broker's commission per lot per side is bigger than the expected payoff per trade, the whole report is fictional at live costs.
Recovery factor is net profit divided by maximal drawdown. Under 1 means you risked more than you earned; over 3 starts to look interesting.
Sharpe ratio in MT5 is computed on a fixed risk-free assumption and is easy to game with many small trades. Use it for comparing two versions of the same system, never for comparing across strategies.
Margin level minimum tells you whether the account was ever close to a margin call. A single dip to 105 percent means the system survived by luck, not by risk control.
The report is the wrong place to test risk
The tester assumes fills at the requested price. Stop orders slip, especially on gold and during news. If your strategy relies on stop entries, add a cost assumption to the numbers before comparing with any live result, otherwise you are measuring a market that does not exist.
Final checklist before you trust a report
At least 200 closed trades. Every-tick model for anything intraday. Equity drawdown under a third of what you are willing to lose in total. Expected payoff comfortably above round-turn cost. Recovery factor above 1.5. And a full year that includes at least one trending and one ranging regime.
Print those seven numbers on one page. If any of them is missing, the report is not finished; it is a first draft that happens to look profitable.


