Discussion of article "General information on Trading Signals for MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5" - page 8

 
i_logic:

Awesome signal: https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/3186

In 2 seconds your deposit went from 2000 to 1.3 million USD?

In 3 years, actually. What other questions do you have?

I tend to think that this is a clever advert of FECH company, and behind the real account there is no real client, and there are employees of the company, who stuff deposit amounts in the server part of MT5. They didn't spam openly (like these guys), but they decided to attract in such a veiled way.

That's what I don't know. Maybe.
 
TheXpert:

In three years, actually. What other questions do you have?

I don't know. Maybe.

Yeah, I've seen the story.

But Free-subscription to such a grail and others like it is alarming: it turns out that the purpose of publishing a signal is not to make money, but something else.

By the way, the signal Zeleniy was talking about (with a similar increase of 26,287,747.77%) has already been banned

 

Wow, this is getting interesting at all:


Для всіх користувачів, не користуйтесь брокером FECH-Demo, оскільки він обманює користувачів по продуманій схемі, кому цікаво можу розказати схему! (Це аналогія КіберБот-у сигнали виставлені для того щоб показати людям, що це суцільний обман, ніхто Вам не дасть заробити на реальному рахунку. Ті реальні рахунки, що подібно працюють створив сам брокер)

Author: AndreyS

From here: https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/2906

We need to ask the author what kind of scheme the FECH-broker is using. I'm telling you, it's not clean.


UPD1: I wrote to AndreyS in private, waiting for a reply

UPD2: Feedback to a similar signal https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/1072/reviews By the way, it is also launched on FECH-server!

 

Also not clear signal https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/1858

Profit Minusinsk =) and gain 2 391.19%

Торговые сигналы: Collonel
Торговые сигналы: Collonel
  • 2012.12.05
  • Collonel
  • www.mql5.com
Торговый Сигнал Collonel для MetaTrader 4: копирование сделок, мониторинг счета, автоматическое исполнение сигналов и социальный трейдинг
 

can you make the terminal in the "Signals" section display by rating as on the site, otherwise it is incomprehensible.

I opened the top signal, and there -99.31%.

And the building structure itself should be formed in such a way, and then filtering.

 

ATTENTION TO THE SIGNAL SUPPORT SERVICE

INCORRECT DATA REPORTING (see attached picture)

Balance = 358.41, while on the chart it is 700!!!! If you look at the graph, it is easy to see that some section is displayed twice (flattened).

 

And more to the same picture.

Let's see:

1. Initial balance = $50

2. Current Balance = $358.41 (rounded up to $350 for the sake of reasoning).

3. Gain = 1016.7% (Question: Where did this gain come from?).

$350 - $50 = $300 This is the gain. In that $300, how much is the original $50? - Six!!! Therefore, the gain = 600% total!

 
Yeah, it's fixed. I couldn't believe it.
 
ForexMoneyMaker:

And more to the same picture.

Let's see:

1. Initial balance = $50

2. Current Balance = $358.41 (rounded up to $350 for the sake of reasoning).

3. Gain = 1016.7% (Question: Where did this gain come from?).

$350 - $50 = $300 This is the gain. In that $300, how much is the original $50? - Six!!! Hence the gain = 600% in total!

could not the author having 10$ to trade, then replenished the account for another 40$? In which case in the future the increase will grow as follows: 50$+received profit.

 
Renat:

1. automatic symbol mapping works within suffixes. That is EURUSD <=> EURUSDxxx, priority is given to a full name match, and if there is more than 1 mapping option, it is disabled due to uncertainty of what to choose. There are no other mapping methods and are not planned for security reasons.

2. yes, one month is mandatory.

3. yes. protected. it is technically impossible to resell signals, there is a good protection system. attempts to cheat will result in eternal ban for the whole account.

4. yes, point 3.

Read discussions of the signals service on this site - all these issues have been discussed. You can search for the topics.

Renat thank you very much for the answer!

There is one more important option.

Please give comments on it too, namely on identification of uppercase vs italic letters, for example: will the system give an equal sign between USOil and USOIL?

Thanks in advance!