will the FOREX live on? - page 20

 
Ilya Malev:
I think he has already opened and closed (more precisely, he left it to develop an outsourced ECN-platform for other CDs). Although he may have opened something else, I have not been following...

I opened a new one in August 2017. Already completely my own. A low-cost broker :)

 
tradeonlydemo:

I opened a new one in August 2017. Already completely its own. A low-cost broker :)

A low-cost broker, is that a broker that's cheap? :)

P.S. The relationship between the categories of fast, cheap and quality in services is an invariable pattern, I think everyone knows it ))))
 

And the fact that banks do real currency exchange - no, haven't you heard? They are taking it out into space)) The trader, on the other hand, provides liquidity, that is, the ability to make those transactions in reality. That was originally so, but gradually everything has been transformed (the leverage has been added, which gave an opportunity to earn more on all that, both for the trader, due to increased profits, and for the organizer of trading - due to traders' sinking), and on the periphery it has even degenerated into kitchens.

It all depends on which world you survive in. If in the world of suckers, then of course - all around are crooks... and suckers. But in reality, everything in the world was originally created based on the principle of expediency.

 
Dmitry Fedoseev:

And the fact that banks do real currency exchange - no, haven't you heard? They are taking it out into space)) The trader, on the other hand, provides liquidity, that is, the ability to make those transactions in reality. That was originally so, but gradually everything has been transformed (the leverage has been added, which gave an opportunity to earn more on all that, both for the trader, due to increased profits, and for the organizer of trading - due to traders' sinking), and on the periphery it has even degenerated into kitchens.

It all depends on which world you survive in. If in the world of suckers, then of course - all around are crooks... and suckers. But in fact, in the world everything was originally created with the basis of the principle of expediency.

This is the world of ringleaders, ringleaders, well, those who, in fact, are all these good people. It takes some time to be in the immediate vicinity of the process to understand its scope, scale and degree of no alternative.

Man is a social creature for the most part. In trading, only few people "survive" - these are clearly individualists who do not care about the opinion of all the others. And the latter must have both the will to oppose the opinion of the crowd, and reason, in order to benefit from it, and not to become a thankless marginal. If you imagine the ratio in society of those and others, it is, I think, roughly reflected in the percentage of those who earn and the percentage of those on whom one earns, and, I suspect, by no means only in relation to trading.

 
All regulation is evil. The market should be free. If grandmothers and grandfathers are losing money on forex, it is not forex's problem, no one has to explain anything to anyone. These brokerage companies with a license from the Central Bank are just advertising, and all clients are offshore. They need to return kopecks from clients' accounts and they will go offshore again. Apparently someone benefits from leaving only bank forex in Russia, I will not be surprised if other brokerage companies are banned. Then the "small" forex will leave Russia. And then... Small businesses are not allowed to go either. We will get bank forex, big business. The elite rules the country, nothing changes.
 
Dmitry Fedoseev:

And the fact that banks do real currency exchange - no, haven't you heard? They are taking it out into space)) The trader, on the other hand, provides liquidity, that is, the ability to make those transactions in reality. Initially it was like that, but gradually everything has a bit transformed (the leverage was added, giving a chance to make more profit on all that, both for the trader, due to increased profits, and for the organizer of trading - due to traders' sinking), and on the periphery it has even degenerated into kitchens.

It all depends on which world you survive in. If in the world of suckers, then of course - all around are crooks... and suckers. But the reality is that everything in the world was originally created on the basis of the principle of expediency.

Do not compare the real spot market with a virtual DTs environment, where the quote itself is taken from a real market and the transactions are vitrual, i.e. without delivery of the currency itself

the only way fx traders affect the exchange rate = when they exchange rubles for dollars (for real) to take them offshore to a dc, if they take a lot offshore, it would probably have some effect on the national currency rate, in a negative way of course

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

Do not compare the real spot market with a virtual DTs environment, where the quote itself is taken from the real market and the transactions are vitrual in the betting type, i.e. without delivery of the currency itself

the only way fx traders affect the exchange rate = when they exchange rubles for dollars (for real) to take them offshore to a dc, if they take a lot offshore, it would probably have an impact on the national currency, in a negative way of course

In any place, no matter whether it is a stock exchange, a broker or a brokerage house, a trader makes a bet on change of quotes and due to this wins or loses. It does not matter where the bet is placed. That is all!

 
Vitaly Muzichenko:

Regardless of whether it is a stock exchange, a CME broker or a DC, a trader bets on a change in quotation and wins or loses by doing so. It does not matter where to place the bet. That is all!

I forgot to add casino, it does not matter.

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

the casino forgot to add, it doesn't matter, does it?

In a casino you can't predict the odds, but in the market you can... in any market, even a commodity market selling sugar.

 
Vitaly Muzichenko:

In a casino there is no way of predicting probability, but in the market there is, ... in any market, even a commodity market selling sugar.

What do you mean no? 50/50 minus zero.

Reason: