Discussion of article "Creating Neural Network EAs Using MQL5 Wizard and Hlaiman EA Generator" - page 7

 
Since this test indicators, request to those who want to download and test them in the work, write your constructive feedback.
So we will be able to improve the quality of indicators, select optimal input data, parameters and frequency of training.
Current versions of indicators was generated based on neural networks trained on EURUSD M1 for 01/02/2014 and 03/01/2014, MetaQuotes-Demo server.
 
Personally I don't get it, it gives out signals too often, not like in the picture, it seems to draw an arrow on every tick (broker - bank).
Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Константы индикаторов / Стили рисования
Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Константы индикаторов / Стили рисования
  • www.mql5.com
Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Константы индикаторов / Стили рисования - Документация по MQL5
 
sergeev:
I'm asking you, do your toys not work?


or are you just selling hlime?

I'm honestly curious.

so much work, such a patronising PR and advertising(although it is forbidden, but let it, your business, maybe you will get a ban for breaking the rules).

And you want feedback... logically, it's simple - it means a seller of leakers. just a seller.

---

and you don't need to close your mouth. If you call yourself a seller, you should accept everything that comes with it.


Any indicator can show a pretty picture.

Like mine.


He's talking about indicators that are attached to the EA itself. Why he doesn't test them himself in real life, I can't understand.

I have not been able to get profitable results even when running the history on gold. 300 quid spent are still hanging over the trash bin.... I'll wait for an update. If I can't make a profit, he'll get the full measure of it. so I won't need a ban.

ps- and what is your indicator, may i ask?

 
server:
Personally, I don't understand, it gives out signals too often, not like in the picture, it seems to draw an arrow on every tick (broker - bank).

Please specify: server, instrument, timeframe. Can be in a private message or support@hlaiman.com


trora:

he is talking about indicators that are attached to the EA itself. why he doesn't test them himself on real trading, I can't understand.

I have not been able to get profitable results even on running history on gold yet. 300 quid spent are still hanging over the trash bin.... I'll wait for an update. If I can't make a profit, he'll get the full measure of it. so I won't need a ban.

ps- and what is your indicator, may I ask?

hlaiman:

For different brokers/instruments/timeframes - different recommended parameters for generating Expert Advisors (training parameters). We provide full technical support for the product after purchase, as long as we have not received any questions from you regarding the generation of Expert Advisors. We will be happy to answer any questions you may have, review and recommend parameters for generating Expert Advisors for the brokers/instruments/timframes you are interested in.

No questions from you, please contact technical support.

 
hlaiman:

Please specify: server, instrument, timeframe. Can be in a private message or support@hlaiman.com



EUR USD Minute chart vtb24
 

Yes and I can here= XAUUSDv 15m forexstart .

are you ready to put the right parameters again via remote desktop and run the tests?

 
server:
EUR USD Minute chart vtb24

Thank you, indeed on vtb24 quotes the indicators work more roughly due to the 4-digit representation, which on small timeframes shows distorted bars in patterns, compared to 5-digit bars, on which the neural networks were trained.
I am posting an updated version of indicators trained on 4-digit bars, EURUSD M1 for the past week, default sensitivity 25%.


EURUSD Chart, M1, 2014.01.13 15:34 UTC, Bank VTB 24 (Closed Joint Stock Company), MetaTrader 5, Demo

Screenshots of the MetaTrader trading platform

EURUSD, M5, 2014.01.13

VTB 24 Bank (Closed Joint-Stock Company), MetaTrader 5, Demo

temp_file_screenshot_21265.png

EURUSD, M5, 2014.01.13, Bank VTB 24 (Closed Joint-Stock Company), MetaTrader 5, Demo

 
hlaiman:

Thank you, indeed on vtb24 quotes the indicators work more roughly due to the 4-digit representation, which on small timeframes shows distorted bars in patterns, compared to 5-digit bars, on which the neural networks were trained.
I am posting an updated version of indicators trained on 4-digit bars, EURUSD M1 for the past week, default sensitivity 25%.


Thank you, I will test it today-tomorrow
 
hlaiman:

Judging by the above pictures, the Close candlestick parameter is used in the indicator calculations, which means that the arrows should be shifted by 1 bar to the right for reliability. And the picture will not be so pretty :), it will not be pretty at all.

Документация по MQL5: Основы языка / Функции / Функции обработки событий
Документация по MQL5: Основы языка / Функции / Функции обработки событий
  • www.mql5.com
Основы языка / Функции / Функции обработки событий - Документация по MQL5
 
Yurich:

Judging by the above pictures, the Close candlestick parameter is used in the indicator calculations, which means that the arrows should be shifted by 1 bar to the right for reliability. And the picture will not be so pretty :), it will not be pretty at all.

To be more precise, the current price is used in the indicator calculations, which becomes the Close price on the last bar tick, and if as a result of this calculation the BUY or SELL indicator threshold value is reached, the corresponding arrows are drawn.

That is, the arrows are located exactly on those bars on which they are calculated.

But if by shifting the arrows "by 1 bar to the right" you mean the order of using signals, i.e. only on completed bars, then it refers to a specific trading strategy.

In this case, in addition to signals on already formed bars, a trader can also use intra-bar signals, which are displayed on the indicator, and their value is displayed in the comment field.