Discussing the article: "Trend strength and direction indicator on 3D bars"

 

Check out the new article: Trend strength and direction indicator on 3D bars.

We will consider a new approach to market trend analysis based on three-dimensional visualization and tensor analysis of the market microstructure.

One might think nothing new can be found in ordinary candles. Everything has already been discovered, counted and digitized. But as soon as we look at the market from a different angle, it reveals its completely unexpected side.

Imagine that you look at the chart not as a flat picture, but as a living, breathing organism. Each bar is not just a rectangle with shadows, but a volumetric structure pulsating in time with the market heartbeat. That is how the idea of 3D bars was born. At first, it was just a visualization experiment - I wanted to look at familiar data in a different way. But the deeper I delved into my research, the more striking patterns emerged.

I remember the moment I first saw the "yellow" cluster. On the 3D chart it literally glowed, foreshadowing a trend reversal. At first, I thought it was a coincidence. But the pattern repeated itself over and over again, pointing with astonishing accuracy to future price movements. Six months of continuous research, hundreds of sleepless nights, thousands of lines of code - all this gradually formed into a coherent mathematical model.

Now, looking at the test results, I understand that we really hit on something important. This is something that lies in the very structure of the market, deep in its nature. Conventional technical analysis is powerless here - these patterns can only be seen through the prism of tensor analysis - by rising above the plane of the chart into the third dimension.

In this article, I want to share my discovery. I want to show how ordinary market data, when examined from a new angle, can give us amazingly accurate signals about the strength and direction of a trend ahead of time, when there is still time to take a position and wait for a movement to occur. Fasten your seat belts, we are about to embark on a journey through the 3D market.


Author: Yevgeniy Koshtenko

 
The idea is interesting, but extracting/detecting reversal signals from such a combination of indicators is not easy. I managed to install only Trend_Force_Reverse.mq5, but I don't understand where to download 3D Bars Oscillator and Super Reversol (I don't see them in the zip), or these indicators are not needed?
 

God, how coders like to complicate things many times....


Here's Gunn in his purest form, and his famous 1x1 angle. All targets are visible in advance.

All right, keep sawing your square-wheeled lissapeed. :)

Yevgeniy Koshtenko #:
I found these levels (3 and 6) empirically. When trend strength breaks through level 6, it almost always means a strong move. Level 3 is something like a turbulence zone, where the trend can either strengthen or reverse.
Re-read Gunn carefully, he writes about 3 and 6 in plain text. )))))
 
Bogard_11 #:

Here's Gunn in his purest form, and his famous 1x1 angle. All targets are seen in advance.

Where are the targets? I assume they're only visible to a select few.
Can they be expressed in numbers? And a time frame for achieving them?

 
Grigori.S.B #:

And where are these targets? I suppose they are only visible to a select few.
Can they be expressed in numbers? And a timeframe for achieving them?

Does a 45-degree angle mean anything to you?

 
Bogard_11 #:

Does a 45-degree angle mean anything to you?

Yes, the best way to avoid answering a question is to ask a counter-question.

 
Grigori.S.B #:

Yes, the best way to avoid answering a question is to ask a counter question.

Have you read Gunn? If not, what are we talking about?!

 
Bogard_11 #:

Have you read Gunn? If not, what are we talking about?!

You started the conversation. About a target that can be seen. So be kind enough to voice it.
Just in case: the goal is expressed not in angles, but in price and term.

And who read what is another way of avoiding a straight answer.

 
Grigori.S.B #:

You started the conversation. About a target that can be seen. So be kind enough to voice it.
Just in case: the goal is expressed not in angles, but in price and term.

And who read what is another way of avoiding a direct answer.

You've seen the gopher, no?

And I haven't seen one, and there is one!

 
Dear colleagues, what is the dispute about? Only a lazy person has not studied Gann (I will not criticise or support the effectiveness of the method), Eugene Kostenko has presented an indicator or three indicators (I do not understand), applying which(s) it will be easier for a trader to determine the cycle: "completion of the current movement and enter against and on the opposite signal to turn around". How to determine these Signals is not clear, what is there to discuss?
 
Vitek2010v #:
Dear colleagues, what is the dispute about? Only a lazy person has not studied Gann (I will not criticise or support the effectiveness of the method), Eugene Kostenko has presented an indicator or three indicators (I do not understand), applying which(s) it will be easier for a trader to determine the cycle: "completion of the current movement and enter against and on the opposite signal to turn around". How to determine these Signals is not clear, what is there to discuss ?

I see entries on Wolf waves with 98% probability, with profits of 200-500 pips.

Show it on the Ghana?