Discussing the article: "Trend strength and direction indicator on 3D bars" - page 3

 
Vitaly Muzichenko #:

But it helps you a lot, and all the other trading gurus.

Here we enter, and here we exit and earn 100500pp from each trade, and so on during the whole past period.

You know what the problem of all coders is? They have forgotten how to look for patterns.

They all follow the same pattern - now we will put an idea into the code and the machine will find the Grail! And so 100500 times in a circle. ))

But to take and check it by hand, to calculate it on a calculator.... No, it's not the honourable thing to pick a hole.... ))

That's why you don't understand that the market follows the usual laws of physics - the angle of incidence equals the angle of reflection. The graphical system was described 100 years ago. It works the way it works. But to understand it, you need to spend a decent amount of time working with history to find all mathematical connections. And especially by rearranging your thinking.

Even the first impulse carries information about future reversal levels. The error on the pound is usually no more than 2-5 pips.

 
Bogard_11 #:

You know what the problem with all coders is? They've forgotten how to look for patterns.

They all follow the same pattern - now we'll put some idea into the code and the machine will find the Grail! And so 100500 times in a circle. ))

But to take and check it by hand, to calculate it on a calculator.... No, it's not the honourable thing to pick a hole.... ))

That's why you don't understand that the market follows the usual laws of physics - the angle of incidence equals the angle of reflection. The graphical system was described 100 years ago. It works the way it works. But to understand it, you need to spend a decent amount of time working with history to find all mathematical connections. And especially by rearranging your thinking.

Even the first impulse carries information about future reversal levels. The error on the pound is usually no more than 2-5 pips.

Several hundred different systems from different users go through coding, you test them and see all the disadvantages and advantages.

It's not manually picking and missing some patterns. A machine will never miss anything, that's its advantage.

And what worked 100 years ago stopped working as technology improved.

Can you imagine how pips would have worked before, when trades were made by telephone or by telegram to the broker?

 
Vitaly Muzichenko #:

And what worked 100 years ago stopped working as technology improved.

Can you elaborate on why it stopped working? Some broker or market maker cancelled the laws of physics and mathematics?!

Man, how did I miss such a scoop. Can I know when this event happened and who was the author of the cancellation?

 
Vitaly Muzichenko #:

Several hundred different systems from different users go through the coding, you test them and see all the flaws and advantages.

It's not hand picking, missing some patterns. A machine will never miss anything, that's its advantage.

To code something correctly, you must first find ALL patterns by hand. The machine may not be wrong, but it will only look for what you put into it, i.e. what you have found on your own without the machine! I am sometimes amazed at the fanatical belief in the abilities of AI!!!! )))

You coded to search the text for the letters A, B and C. Because you either found them by accident, or someone prompted you. BUT! There are other letters in the alphabet, and you don't know about them.... What will the machine give you?

It's the same in the market, there are general rules, there are mat. models, but every day they have different proportions (although all fit into one general model). Even at the price there will be a backlash, +-3 points from the calculated value, but it will work out exactly according to the time. Or it will work out exactly at the price, but with a slippage of a couple of bars.

 
Bogard_11 #:

In order to code something correctly, you must first find all patterns with your hands. The machine may not be wrong, but it will only look for what you put into it, i.e. what you have found on your own without the machine! I am sometimes amazed at the fanatical belief in the abilities of AI!!!! )))

You coded to search the text for the letters A, B and C. Because you either found them by accident, or someone prompted you. BUT! There are other letters in the alphabet, and you don't know about them.... What will the machine give you?

It's the same in the market, there are general rules, there are mat. models, but every day they have different proportions (although all fit into one general model). Even at the price there will be a backlash, +-3 points from the calculated value, but it will work out exactly according to the time. Or it will work out exactly at the price, but with a slippage of a couple of bars.

The numerical series does not change. The commas in it change.