From theory to practice - page 1327

 
Evgeniy Chumakov:

And I am the ones who are responsible for their words.

Do you live by the rules?

In forex, when one wins, the other loses.

today you win, tomorrow someone else wins...

there's no one to respect, there's just a "thank you" and that's it.

No one knows who will be lucky tomorrow.

And there is an unspoken rule: if you put out a strategy, you lose.

so there's no point in pushing someone else's blisters, it's useless.

;)

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Do you live by the rules?

In forex, when one wins, the other loses.

one day you win, the next day another...

there's no one to respect, there's just a "thank you" and that's it.

Who will be lucky tomorrow - no one knows.

and the rule is that if you put out a strategy, you've lost...

;)

+1)

I have my doubts too though... Does it redraw by any chance?

like a zig-zag, for example? It looks cool but it's useless...

or else I can do the same thing...

 
Martin_Apis_Bot Cheguevara:

+1)

I have my doubts about the story though...it doesn't redraw by any chance?

like a zig-zag, for instance? It looks cool, but it is useless...

no it's not

it's one of the criteria you should pay special attention to.

I've had enough of spread mills, I don't want any more.... ;)))
 
Martin_Apis_Bot Cheguevara:

+1)

I have my doubts... Does it redraw by any chance?

like a zig-zag, for instance? which also seems to show cool but is useless because it re-draws...

I can draw it too...

...just by building an indicator using this zig zag...

zig zag doesn't have an ending and also wouldn't redraw

but otherwise, yeah, he's cool.

 
Alexander_K:

Well done, Maxim!

Window = 150 CLOSE M15? Did I get it right? I.e. = 2250 minutes? Is 1.14103 the average BP entropy value?

Of course I can't give you any assignments, but if you get a chance, please make a table of average entropy values for sliding windows in multiples of 1 hour:

60 minutes (an hour), 120,180, 240, ..., 1440 minutes (a day).

We need to find the window with the minimum average value of entropy BP.

Is it OK that it is in such healthy waves as the window increases? e.g. at 720 already


It takes a long time to calculate for the history of 50 min, for example for EURUSD at the moment. I will show the whole table later

Window size EURUSD
60 1.2862
120 1.8847
180 1.8134
240 2.0114
300 1.7494
360 1.4996
420 1.3849
480 1.2603
540 1.2316
600 1.268
660 1.3803
720 1.3403
 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

Is it OK that it makes such healthy waves when the window is enlarged? e.g. at 720 already


Wow!!! That's amazing!

Is that 12 hours? I have to think about what I'm seeing... If you can, Maxim, a full set of such pictures from 1 to 24 hours, either here or in person.

 
Alexander_K:

What a surprise!!! That's amazing!

Is that 12 hours? I've got to think about what I'm seeing... If I may, Maxim - a full set of such pictures from 1 to 24 hours either here or in a private message.

I'll finish for a few couples later, any preferences?

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

Is it OK if it's in such big waves when the window gets bigger? e.g. at 720.


It's a long time for the 50k history, for example EURUSD has been calculated for the moment. I will show you the whole table later

Window size EURUSD
60 1.2862
120 1.8847
180 1.8134
240 2.0114
300 1.7494
360 1.4996
420 1.3849
480 1.2603
540 1.2316
600 1.268
660 1.3803
720 1.3403

I.e. entropy minimum is observed, on average, on the period = 540 minutes = 9 hours = trading session?

Yes, yes, that is what I would expect to see.

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

I'll finish for a few pairs later and post it, any preferences?

No, just an independent review.

If entropy points to the same window on several pairs, that's it, problem solved.

 
Alexander_K:

I.e. entropy minimum observed, on average, for a period = 540 minutes = 9 hours = trading session?

Yes, yes, that is what I expected to see.

Yes, but I'm not quite there yet, I'll check it out on other currency pairs

Reason: