Just a statistic - page 2

[Andrey Dik]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

I.e. in this case, the handicap (and exchanges in general) is a game with a non-zero amount.

The exchange is only a tool in another game.

All cash flows are within the pyramid. These cash flows are directed upwards. Even the interest rate holders below the top end up losing money - they spend it on food and other things, pay taxes, etc. Everyone who uses the money participates in this pyramid, whether they want to or not. The only difference is how quickly some of the pyramid participants get rid of their money, some very quickly and some more slowly, but all of them.

[Andrey F. Zelinsky]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

The data is taken from the signals service at the moment.

The stats are only for the signals visible in the window.

Sanyok, and what is this data, I do not understand

[Alexandr Bryzgalov]

Andrey F. Zelinsky:

Sanyok, what is this data, I do not understand.

left column - weeks

The right one is the number of accounts with a lifetime in the left column.

It's current.

[Vitaly Muzichenko]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

left column - of the week

right - number of accounts with lifetime specified in the left column

it is for the current moment

The statistics are skewed, as the previous speaker Maxim has already said. I had a signal here a year ago and it worked quite successfully, but it was deactivated due to the large number of trades, although it still works in my account to this day. I have not considered such signals, but there are a lot of them and they will improve my statistics in many ways.

[Georgiy Merts]

In my opinion, the statistics are quite correct.

As I understand it, the problem is that subscribers don't want signals with annual returns of tens of percent. They need hundreds of percent a month. And such signals do not live long.

[Alexandr Bryzgalov]

Vitaly Muzichenko:

The statistics are skewed, as the previous speaker Maxim has already said. I had a signal here a year ago and it worked quite successfully, but it was deactivated due to the large number of trades, although it still works in my account to this day. That's the signals you are not taking into account, while there are a lot of them and they greatly improve the statistics.

If I use statistics I just want to show the chances of newbies who have just come to the forum and what will happen to them in 2-3 months and in 2-3 years.

And, as they say, to calculate (visually see) the half-life of the crowd of traders)

Of course, the more accurate the statistics, the better, but the essence does not change: the graph curve over time tends to zero.

[Maxim Romanov]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

I just wanted to show the chances of newcomers who have just come to the forum and what will happen to them in 2-3 months and in 2-3 years.

Well, as they say, to calculate (visually see) the half-life of the crowd of traders).

Of course, the more accurate the statistics, the better, but the essence does not change: the graph curve over time tends to zero.

In general yes, if you take for example boxers or other athletes, then 100% quit the sport sooner or later. It is the same with companies, 100% will close sooner or later. Everything has a shelf life, the signal traders have just the same life, other traders have different life, but the result is the same. Besides, it is not interesting to keep the account with one broker all the time, as you develop, people switch to better brokers, if you start from mediocre ones. Actually there are many reasons. You either develop or you drop out. And most really do leave.

[[Deleted]]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

1) my conclusion is: something is wrong here, there can't be that many losers )

2) or this: if everyone loses, then who's winning )

1) Have you ever thought that someone may not need it after a while? It's not the mql5 signal service one lives for.

2) It's always the casino that wins.

[Alexandr Bryzgalov]

mmmoguschiy-new:
1) Have you ever thought that someone may not need it after a while?

2) Casino always wins.

The point is not the signals (I took the closest available, with the possibility of filtering), the point is the number of profitable (at least staying afloat) accounts, decreasing over time.

If you attach the status from another service (such as mufihbook), it would be interesting to compare.

Why would you need it?)

[[Deleted]]

Alexandr Bryzgalov:

though why would you want to do that?)

bull's-eye