On FOREX, it's easy to check when brokers play with quotes on the stock market - Trading Systems

[Deleted] 2014.11.10 08:32 #11

Mikalas:

first quotation AW 09:49:11

i've gotten used to the situation

i decided that in the morning the broker comes to work at 9:30, has some coffee and turns on the quote broadcast.... sometimes earlier sometimes later... something like that

Subscription to OnBookEvent sometimes Attach MySQL to MQ4 Does the Grail exist?

Mikhail Filimonov 2014.11.10 08:36 #12

IvanIvanov:
I've got used to this situation for myself

decided that in the morning the broker would come to work at 8:30, have a cup of coffee and start broadcasting quotes.... Sometimes earlier, sometimes later... that's it.

Yes, on FOREX it does not matter, while on the Stock Exchange you can check EVERYTHING with documents.

Therefore, such tricks will not work on FOREX.

Dmitriy Skub 2014.11.10 08:38 #13

IvanIvanov:
and i've gotten used to the situation for myself.

decided that in the morning the broker would come to work at 9:30, have a coffee and switch on the quote broadcast .... sometimes earlier, sometimes later... something like that.

Well, man gets used to everything. that's why the whole planet is flooded))

It's not just the timing, it's the actual distortion of the flow of data.

Mikhail Filimonov 2014.11.10 08:44 #14

Dima_S:

Well, man gets used to everything. That's why the whole planet is flooded)).

It's not just about time, it's about the actual distortion of the flow of data.

Here, who doesn't believe that FOREX is CUCH, make a point!

Maxim Romanov 2014.11.10 09:35 #15

I didn't expect such a set-up. The broker should have his licence taken away for that! Where do the quotes even come from, if not the stock exchange?

Aleksey Vyazmikin 2014.11.10 10:48 #16

kond777, Mikalas, how does the broker explain it?

Mikhail Filimonov 2014.11.10 11:25 #17

-Aleks-:
kond777, Mikalas, how does the broker explain it?

I just sent a complaint to the broker at 10-10.

They won't respond that quickly.

But I think the answer will be standard...

There is one indication that it's not the broker.

It's that the quotes are duplicated many times, apparently something is wrong in the code.

On FORTS there is no sense for a broker to "play" with quotes - it's very easy to check.

Coding help Question to the administration RBCI + TTF =

Renat Fatkhullin 2014.11.10 13:46 #18

Mikalas :

Nothing-to itself "jamb".

I don't work for wrappers...

P/S, now it’s clear why my limits are rejected (there is NO such price on the exchange)

Most likely, you hooked on a premarket (at the Opening it is from 09:45 to 10:00) and tried to trade in it.

We allow traders to see the premarket accumulation (from 9:45 am to 10:00 am) and receive them by tick experts. These are non-trading ticks and give the Expert Advisors a chance to prepare for a breakout. Of course, you should not try to trade at this time - you will naturally receive refusals.

The charts themselves are built exclusively on the last trading prices that have passed through the market and exclusively with the timestamp of the exchange. Thus, the charts are built exclusively accurately for all brokers.

Here is the proof: the minute bar opened at exactly 10:00, its tick volume is 88 ticks

Now let's go to the logs, select only the first minute of the market opening in order to make comparisons:

If we take clean ED-12.14 ticks from Quik, we get 88 ticks, which exactly matches the number of ticks on the M1 chart in MetaTrader 5. Open/High/Low/Close of the tick flow from the Quik log also matches the minute bar in MT5

Quik.Last

10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2467
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2468
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2469
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 00         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 02         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 02         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 02         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 03         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 04         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 05         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 06         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 08         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 08         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 08         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 11         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 11         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2481
10 : 00 : 11         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 18         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 19         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 19         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 19         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 33         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 34         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 34         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 36         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 44         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 44         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 48         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 50         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 51         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 51         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51         ED- 12 , 14          1 , 2476

But the collected ticks in MetaTrader 5 are frankly erroneous.

The code for collecting these ticks was not presented, and the ticks themselves were repeatedly duplicated. There are 111 of them instead of 88.

 10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 00          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 01          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 02          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 02          1 , 2471
10 : 00 : 02          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 02          1 , 2470
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 03          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 04          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 05          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 05          1 , 2472
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 06          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 07          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2473
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2480
10 : 00 : 08          1 , 2479
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 11          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 14          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 15          1 , 2482
10 : 00 : 18          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 19          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 26          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 27          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 27          1 , 2483
10 : 00 : 33          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 34          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 34          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 36          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 36          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 36          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 36          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 37          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 42          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 42          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 42          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 42          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 44          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 44          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 44          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 44          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2477
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 45          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 47          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 47          1 , 2478
10 : 00 : 48          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 48          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 48          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 50          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 50          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 50          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2475
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2474
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 51          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 54          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 57          1 , 2476
10 : 00 : 57          1 , 2476

Your computer's local time is incorrect, sync it

There is your error in collecting ticks in MT5. Most likely you went too far, inserting the entry in the wrong place, and then misinterpreted the result. I also hope that you took measurements on a real MT5 account , and not on a demo.

Provide the full code for recording quotes and we will test it in real work right now. Live accounts on Quik and MT5 are available.

seeking advice about the Is the advisor suitable How can I get

Renat Fatkhullin 2014.11.10 14:05 #19

Another addition: the candlesticks are completely the same in Quik and MT5, right down to the actual volumes.

This proves that you have not correctly collected ticks in MT5 in your program.

Mikhail Filimonov 2014.11.10 14:20 #20

void OnTick()
{
  if ( SymbolInfoTick( _Symbol, curr_tick ) )
  {
                Print( curr_tick.time, "; Bid = ", curr_tick.bid,
                      "; Ask = ", curr_tick.ask, "; Last = ", curr_tick.last,
                      "; Vol = ", curr_tick.volume );
  }
}

Укажите, где ошибка?

И причём время моего компьютера?

//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|                                                    Kotirovki.mq5 |
//|                                                   Copyright 2014 |
//|                                              http://www.mql5.com |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
#property copyright "Copyright 2014, Mikalas"
#property link      "http://www.mql5.com"
#property version   "1.00"
//
  MqlTick curr_tick;
//  
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//| Expert initialization function                                   |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
int OnInit()
{
  return( INIT_SUCCEEDED );
}
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//| Expert deinitialization function                                 |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
void OnDeinit( const int reason )
{

}
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//| Expert On Tick event function                                    |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+  
void OnTick()
{
  if ( SymbolInfoTick( _Symbol, curr_tick ) )
  {
                Print( curr_tick.time, "; Bid = ", curr_tick.bid,
                      "; Ask = ", curr_tick.ask, "; Last = ", curr_tick.last,
                      "; Vol = ", curr_tick.volume );
  }
}

Files:

Kotirovki.ex5 4 kb

Question on FORTS quotes - page 2