Removed Post

[Jefferson Judge Metha]

I asked a question regarding a particular trading system, and the comment was removed. 
I don't understand why. or maybe I need to rephrase the question I had asked, or is it against forum rules to discuss particular systems if thats the case why if we have a forum topic named trading systems. 

[Sergey Golubev]

Discussion related to the systems/services and any commercial (or external) trading systems are prohibited on the forum sorry.

---------------- 

About your post.
You were going to start the discussion on our forum related to commercial systems and external commercial forum (yes, they have a forum as well) which costs about 4,000 USD ("The BTMM course is $3997.00 USD"). So, your post can be considered as the spam and illegal promotion on this mql5 forum.

If you open such the post once again - I will ban you.

for information.

[Jefferson Judge Metha]

Sergey Golubev:

Discussion related to the systems/services and any commercial (or external) trading systems are prohibited on the forum sorry.

okay I get you. 

//---

so is there a way to know which systems are not open for discussion, provided we get a system on the freelance section from customers and create a post here in the forum, regarding that system.

[Sergey Golubev]

Jefferson Metha:

okay I get you. 

//---

so is there a way to know which systems are not open for discussion, provided we get a system on the freelance section from customers and create a post here in the forum, regarding that system.

Systems received from Freelance?
No sorry.

If you want to discuss some trading system so take some system created on this forum (for free, with free indicators from CodeBase, with free EA uploaded on the threads as the source codes), or create your system.
You can discuss my system if you want :) https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/12077
or create your system (take indicators from CodeBase, trade it manually/publicly  for several weeks and after that - upload EA to the forum as the source code; and after that only - we can discuss it).

[Sergey Golubev]

Forum on trading, automated trading systems and testing trading strategies

Can't Find Any Profitable EA on MQL5 in past 5 years.

Sergey Golubev, 2019.04.14 08:04

I have beed in forex since last century so I better know :) what's scam and how to create profitable EAs from the profitable manual trading system (and I am not a coder):

• because some people were/are creating the manual trading systems, traded this system manually on demo for few months/weeks and on real live accounts for few months/weeks with several brokers, and after that - they defined the rules for this system, and finally - they asked for coder (they paid to the coder, or coder created EA for free) to code EA for them according to their profitable manual trading system (profitable for them) - which they traded on demo and/or live for few months with proven results;
• and the other people are just waiting when all the job will be finished to ask: "Can you give me your profitable EA? Because I do not want to spend my money and my time to create the system and to ask the coder after that."

I am talking about public systems.

[Sergey Golubev]

Forum on trading, automated trading systems and testing trading strategies

Can't Find Any Profitable EA on MQL5 in past 5 years.

Sergey Golubev, 2019.04.14 08:26

There are Raw Ideas. It is the ideas about the following: attach indicators to the chart and see that it may be profitable.

There are Elaborated/Proven Ideas. It is when someone was trading this indicators' setup during the several days/or weeks/or months on demo account (and, in some cases - on real live account). I am not talking abouty backtesting. Raw idea became to be a Elaborated Idea by trading (at least - on demo).
Why to trade? To define the trading rules, and to know: when the system will let you win, and when you will lose by using this system (and why).

• Some people prefer to do it in public threads (raw idea - next is indicators uploaded to the thread - next: trading with one broker - trading with the other broker - next: elaborate the rules of the system - ask for coders), receive EA based on manual trading system (some coders may code for free using the public threads: some coders will never code for free ... up to them), optimize the settings, find the settings for some timeframes and more. And some people prefer to post/iupload everything on their public threads.
• The other people are doing in privately (with no one can see it). In this case - he believes in his own results and in his words such as "it is profitable EA, please use it", but we do not believe in his results and do not trust him in general.
• And the other people do not do anything. They just ask: "did you finish your great job here? did you spend your money to find the settings, did you spend your time to trade this manuall system on demo or live, right? So, for now - you should give this profitable EA to me and explain all your system to me (for free of course!".

[Jefferson Judge Metha]

Thank you. 

I was once banned last year 16 July to 16 August. Not a nice experience. 

Thats why I created this thread, to understand better. 

Saw in another forum post one individual that was repeating the same thread and it was being removed till he was banned. 

Thank u once again take care.