Indicators: Differential indicator by Sultonov

[Automated-Trading]

Differential indicator by Sultonov:

Displays average values ​​of the bulls and bears power.

Author: Ihor Herasko

[fxsaber]

(TerminalInfoString(TERMINAL_LANGUAGE) == "Rusiian")

[Ihor Herasko]

fxsaber:

Thanks. Fixed it in both versions.

[Vladimir Suslov]

What is the reason for such mass psychosis? (I mean the branch https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/214529/unread#unread)

BullsPower(i) = SUM(Close(i) - Close(i + 1), N) / BUN
BearsPower(i) = SUM(Close(i + 1) - Close(i), N) / BEN

The whole indicator is two SMAs. Only positive increments can be applied to one, and only negative increments to the other.

Kindergarten)

[Ihor Herasko]

Vladimir Suslov:

What is the reason for such mass psychosis? (I mean the branch https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/214529/unread#unread)

The whole indicator is two SMAs. Only positive increments can be applied to one, and only negative increments to the other.

Kindergarten)

Look in the code. These are not SMAs at all. It is a bit more complicated, but no one said that we are dealing with something archically complex or ultra-complicated.

[Vladimir Suslov]

Ihor Herasko:

Look in the code. It's not mashkins at all. It is a bit more complicated, but nobody said that we are dealing with something archically complex or ultra-complicated.

It has nothing to do with code.

Or do the formulas given in the "Calculation Methodology" not correspond to the indicator's algorithm?

[Ihor Herasko]

Vladimir Suslov:

What does the code have to do with it.

Or the formulas given in the "Calculation Methodology" do not correspond to the indicator algorithm?

They do. But these are not just averages. The formula for calculating the average is different:

SMA = SUM(Price(i)) / N

However, you are right that there is nothing extraordinary in the described method. It is approximately the same indicator as any other one from the standard terminal delivery. No more and no less.

[Vladimir Suslov]

Ihor Herasko:

They are. But they are not just averages. The formula for calculating the average is different:

However, you are right that there is nothing extraordinary in the described method. It is approximately the same indicator as any other one from the standard terminal delivery. No more and no less.

You are trying to inflate a bubble)
Just as your code is inflated.

I only said "The king is naked".

Good luck.

[Yuriy Asaulenko]

What I wrote about earlier in the thread about the Sultonov indicator.

http://finfact.org/forex/glossarii/indicatory-trenda-ma-i-ema

Simple MA (линейно-акцентированный, МА) используется большинством игроков потому, что его просто вычислить а в терминале Metatraider он стоит
 по умолчанию. Однако его недостаток в том, что он дважды реагирует на одно изменение цены. 
Первый раз МА реагирует, когда цена попадает в период усреднения, а второй раз – когда цена покидает этот период. 
В результате МА часто противоречит реальному состоянию рынка. МА может падать, когда цена растет или идти вверх во время падения цены.

This is characteristic of all indicators based on direct averaging. And here is a typical example. At small price changes, we see a sharp decrease in the indicator readings (right part of the chart).

It can be seen that it almost coincides in form and even amplitude with the previous upward movement, only with the opposite sign.

At the same time, the victory of bulls over bears is claimed, and forecasts are made on this basis. And this is just an exit of the old data from the indicator averaging zone.

The chart is given earlier by Sultonov himself.

[Dmitriy Skub]

There's nothing to discuss. Even the Kalman filter fails on the net price, and here Sultonov's averager)).

[Maxim Romanov]

Vladimir Suslov:

What is the reason for such mass psychosis? (I mean the branch https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/214529/unread#unread)

The whole indicator is two SMAs. Only positive increments can be applied to one, and only negative increments to the other.

Kindergarten)

Hype is such a senseless and merciless. Those who do something worthwhile do not have time and desire to inflate everything.