Profit Generator EA - page 62

 

Is that a trick question?

Nicholishen:
Which one of these fib ind is correct?

Sorry, accidentally posted double...

 

Loss Generator !

Dear All

http://www.thehobbystop.com/profitgenerator31/statement.htm

Since the beginning i am stating that this EA is not Profit Generator but Loss Generator !!

Above is one more proof ... How can this EA which gathered more 62 pages of comments and development .... still loosing money...

My frog by following the trend is doing much better !

He's just going against the trend and just pure speculation on possible overbought or reversal entries

-))))))))))))))))))))))))))

A Good way to screw an account if you have too much money !!!

Can anybody post any profitable equity generated by Profit Generator !!

I would rather suggest to concentrate on Sputnik !!! it works on real time and i did 350 pips today on 4 pairs

Congratulations to winners for its hard work !

Kr

bagovino:
OK... this EA is scaring me now! How could it not only catch this move, but lose money on it???? Stevie Wonder could have traded this one!!!!
 
zifx25000:
Dear All

Can anybody post any profitable equity generated by Profit Generator !!

I would rather suggest to concentrate on Sputnik !!! it works on real time and i did 350 pips today on 4 pairs

Congratulations to winners for its hard work !

Kr

What is Sputnik?, where can I see forward results, is it available to all?

Don't forget your looking at the canned setting's as a base for everyone else's forward tests.

EDIT: Nevermind found it, I shall review, now back to our program!

 

943467 2006.04.17 07:16 sell 1.00 eurusd 1.2182 1.2197 1.2092 2006.04.17 08:26 1.2176 0.00 0.00 0.00 60.00

948000 2006.04.17 08:59 sell 1.00 eurusd 1.2183 1.2198 1.2093 2006.04.17 09:21 1.2178 0.00 0.00 0.00 50.00

949313 2006.04.17 09:26 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.7578 1.7593 1.7488 2006.04.17 10:02 1.7593 0.00 0.00 0.00 -150.00

950372 2006.04.17 10:02 buy 1.00 usdchf 1.2899 1.2884 1.2989 2006.04.17 11:39 1.2884 0.00 0.00 0.00 -116.42

954414 2006.04.17 11:39 sell 1.00 eurusd 1.2197 1.2212 1.2107 2006.04.17 11:41 1.2212 0.00 0.00 0.00 -150.00

959613 2006.04.17 11:50 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.2219 1.2247 0.0000 2006.04.17 12:36 1.2247 0.00 0.00 0.00 280.00

974309 2006.04.17 13:01 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.2231 1.2216 1.2321 2006.04.17 13:03 1.2216 0.00 0.00 0.00 -150.00

975264 2006.04.17 13:03 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.2219 1.2233 1.2309 2006.04.17 13:29 1.2233 0.00 0.00 0.00 140.00

979753 2006.04.17 13:33 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.2231 1.2278 1.2321 2006.04.17 14:59 1.2282 0.00 0.00 0.00 510.00

1002049 2006.04.17 18:40 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.2266 1.2251 1.2356 2006.04.17 20:17 1.2251 0.00 0.00 0.00 -150.00

This is today, i am not using the same setting as at default.

Useclose true, tp 45, sl 15, tsactivation 10, trailpips 10, ema true Ema 10 and 30

33 pip profit, not that great but it will do

i took 130 pip profit trading manually, bought position at1.2110 eurusd on friday looking for a breakout, would be nice if ea took same kind of profit

 

HI Sir

thanks for your reply!

PG

can anybody post a profitablestatment + mq4 with appropriate settings ?

I tested almost all version of PG and this EA is still ''a looser''

Kr

marlintrdg:
What is Sputnik?, where can I see forward results, is it available to all?

Don't forget your looking at the canned setting's as a base for everyone else's forward tests.

EDIT: Nevermind found it, I shall review, now back to our program!
 

I'm out of ideas

Well, out of respect to the spirit of the forum and the creator of this thread, I am done posting my ideas about pivot trading here. My idea is out there. This Pro-gen entry method is an important discovery, no question. I sincerely hope this thread doesn't fizzle out and some more experimentation with filtering ideas is done with this. If I have any more ideas, I will post. Ideas like Sputnik are viable, the XXX indicators agree thing. Pivot trading is another time proven low risk, profitable trading methodology in forex. Somehow I find it very strange that there are so many good manual trading methods and that not much has been accomplished in the way of automation. I think that ultimately, a winning EA will need to be very complex and take into consideration S/R levels as well as trend direction and exhaustion, etc, etc, etc. There are a lot of things that need to be taken into account when trading. My apologies to anyone who may feel I have stepped on this thread, it hasn't been my intentions. Good Luck everybody, let's not give up!!

 

I'll be testing the new filter

I have the new version with the 50 LWMA filter running. I'll post my results in a few days. Thanks Nich.

 

UseAbsoleteMethod

Hi Nich

On my forward testing, on GBPUSD ,H1, SL=0 TP=80 BL=12, UseObsoleteMethod= True, ObsoleteMinute=30. As per my attached chart you can see a loss of 126 Pips. I wonder why Obsolete did not work here?

Thanks, you are doing a great job and help to all traders.

Files:
gbp_h-1.gif  14 kb
 

Nich,

Just so I can humor myself, how can I set it so it only takes trades in the agreement of the direction of the 5 and 12 EMA's on the 15min even though trading off the hour?

Thanks,

Billy

 
bagovino:
Nich,

Just so I can humor myself, how can I set it so it only takes trades in the agreement of the direction of the 5 and 12 EMA's on the 15min even though trading off the hour?

Thanks,

Billy

Change the ema's then set EMAtf to the TF you want to use. Easy way... start a new EA on new chart... change the idbase to 300000

Reason: