Yalnızca ürünü satın alan veya kiralayan kullanıcılar yorum yazabilir
Elias Rafael Rodelo Montes  
Hi friend, thank you so much for your contribution with this EA.

I have a question: Does the Smart Risk Manager EA manage the positions of other EAs? I understand that it should, since it allows you to set the "magic number" or leave it at "0" for all positions.

However, I have a doubt. If I use the hidden SL/TP function, will the EA that owns the position (the EA that opened the trade) also close that position if its own internal conditions are met, or could there be a conflict? In my case, I use a scalping EA that trades very frequently and usually closes trades automatically, but doesn't set a stop loss. My concern is protection against unforeseen events that leave a position open and exposed to significant losses.

My goal is to add protection with the Smart Risk Manager EA, but allow the original EA to continue closing positions according to its rules, without interference. Is this possible? Does the hidden TP/SL closing applied by your EA interfere with the closings programmed by the original EA?

Thank you in advance for your response and guidance!
Abdulhadi Darwish  
Elias Rafael Rodelo Montes #:
Hi friend, thank you so much for your contribution with this EA.

I have a question: Does the Smart Risk Manager EA manage the positions of other EAs? I understand that it should, since it allows you to set the "magic number" or leave it at "0" for all positions.

However, I have a doubt. If I use the hidden SL/TP function, will the EA that owns the position (the EA that opened the trade) also close that position if its own internal conditions are met, or could there be a conflict? In my case, I use a scalping EA that trades very frequently and usually closes trades automatically, but doesn't set a stop loss. My concern is protection against unforeseen events that leave a position open and exposed to significant losses.

My goal is to add protection with the Smart Risk Manager EA, but allow the original EA to continue closing positions according to its rules, without interference. Is this possible? Does the hidden TP/SL closing applied by your EA interfere with the closings programmed by the original EA?

Thank you in advance for your response and guidance!

​Hi, I appreciate your detailed question! It touches on a very important topic when combining Expert Advisors.

​I can confirm that your goal is absolutely achievable and is precisely how many traders use a dedicated risk management tool like this.

​1. 🛡️ Managing Positions from Other EAs (Magic Number)

​Yes, the Smart Risk Manager EA manages positions from other EAs.

  • ​If you set the Magic Number to 0, it will manage all trades on the chart, regardless of the EA that opened them.
  • ​If you set the Magic Number to the specific number used by your scalping EA, it will manage only those positions.

​2. 🚫 The Solution to Avoid Conflict (TP Interference)

​You are right to be concerned about the Take Profit (TP) conflict, especially since your scalping EA handles its own high-frequency exits.

​To ensure my EA acts purely as a safety mechanism (Trailing Stop) and does not interfere with your scalping EA's closures, we have a simple solution:

  • ​Set Take Profit in pips to 0.0: This will instruct the Smart Risk Manager EA to ignore the TP function entirely. It will not attempt to place a hard TP, nor will it attempt to execute any hidden TP closure.

Try this way, if it doesn't work for any reason please let me know, I can update my EA and make the TP property optional.