Discussion of article "How to copy signals using an EA by your rules?" - page 2

[Deleted]  
I did, alas - you can go broke on the spread :) synchronisation every five minutes will kill even a mega profitable trade....
 
Александр:
I did, alas - you can go broke on the spread :) synchronisation every five minutes will kill even mega profitable trading....


Where do you get that synchronisation every five minutes - where is the evidence Or once again words in the wind? Also recommendations:

  1. With a stable connection to the trading server, synchronisation is a rare occurrence.
  2. It is time to abandon netting accounts in Forex.
  3. If you don't like it, don't use it :)

[Deleted]  
Vladimir Karputov:


Where did you get that synchronisation every five minutes - where is the proof Or once again words in the wind? Also recommendations:

  1. With a stable connection to the trading server, synchronisation is a rare occurrence.
  2. It is time to abandon netting accounts in Forex.
  3. If you don't like it, don't use it :)

Your inadequate reaction has discouraged any desire to have further discussion on the topic of this thread.

But I heard people are going to use this copier, and it will bring them real losses (I hope they have enough brains to check it on demo first), and then they will come to you with evidence, with logs, etc. and it will be your headache.

My recommendation to you: block the possibility of working with netting accounts in your Expert Advisor, unless you do not care about potential users and their money....

I'll leave you to it,

and to tell you the truth, no respect.

 
Александр:

Your inadequate reaction has discouraged any desire to have further discussion on the topic of this thread.

But I heard people are going to use this copier, and it will bring them real losses (I hope they have enough brains to check it on demo first), and then they will come to you, with evidence, with logs, etc. and it will be your headache.

My recommendation to you: block the possibility of working with netting accounts in your Expert Advisor, unless you do not care about potential users and their money....

I'll leave you to it,

and to tell you the truth, no respect.


And ours to you with a brush.

Just remember that everyone decides for themselves whether to use it or not. And for those who can not listen and hear: synchronisation, with a stable connection to the trading server - a rare phenomenon and therefore not so much will be losses on the spread. Moreover, it is assumed that the user who switches on the copier on his trading account will weigh all the risks three times.

It should also be taken into account that a user enabling the copier first of all sees the benefit of the increased copying ratio and against this background the rare losses on the spread are just a minor part.

Such a user will first of all be concerned about stable connection - he rents virtual hosting built into the terminal - thus reducing the number of synchronisation triggers due to connection disconnections with the trading server.

[Deleted]  

Okay, emotions aside.

At least one person has already lost money, at least a little. Yes, it was his own fault, such things should be checked thoroughly before, it will be a lesson to him. (this is not about me, if anything)

While you continue to persist in your delusions, I give you the facts, and you do with them as you see fit.

But it would be right if you blocked the work with netting accounts in the Expert Advisor, and then no one will lose time and even more money with this copier.

Here is the result of the provider:

and this is the result of the subscriber:

As I wrote above - plum on the spread, however.

How often in practice, and not in fantasies, there is a check and further synchronisation of volumes of positions of the provider and the subscriber can be seen in the logs.

Approximately once every 5 minutes. And the reason for this is not the quality of connection to the Internet....

In the trailer logs from both terminals, both provider and subscriber. (deleted the log of terminal installation and other things before the start of trading, not relevant to the essence).

And so that there was no doubt in their integrity below access to both accounts, you can check by time whether the trades were not edited.

Here is the account of the signal provider: 50100070, Invest to it: qxhs8cty.

Here is the account of the signal subscriber: 50100073, invest in it: 2zknuccf

I'm done.

Files:
 

Thanks for the log file. Probably there have been changes in synchronisation issues since the article was written.

Moreover, you should not use a netting account on Forex, if you want to add a copier to it.

As for the blocking of work on netting accounts - here everyone can change the code himself, all sources are available.

[Deleted]  
You can't edit the source in the Market.
 
Александр:
You can't edit the source code in the Market...

You have mixed up the section - you are now in the discussion of the article where the open source code is posted. You should be more attentive.
[Deleted]  
Does the Expert Advisor in the Market, with a link to the article we are discussing now, work according to some other algorithm?
 
Александр:
Does the Expert Advisor in the Market, with a link to the article we are discussing now, work according to some other algorithm?

There is a link to this article in the Market. You are using a free and open source product. What are your claims? I suggest you stop these attacks.