How is your success and which trading approach do you currently use for your live trading?

  • 0% (0)
  • 0% (0)
  • 45% (5)
  • 18% (2)
  • 9% (1)
  • 0% (0)
  • 0% (0)
  • 9% (1)
  • 0% (0)
  • 0% (0)
  • 0% (0)
  • 0% (0)
  • 18% (2)
Total voters: 11

Purpose 

  1. There were some surveys in the past about this topic, this survey is the continuation of those and the purpose is to see the trend of trading approach or trading concern/interest over time.

  2. This survey also helps to see the failure/success rate.

  3. This survey also helps to see the difference in trading approach between successful and failed traders.

Remark

The results only reflect those who voluntarily participated in the forum poll, and are not official statistics on all MT5 or MQL5 Community users.

Reference

2013. What are your successful way(s) of live forex trading? (Auto / Manual / Signal) (https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/13607)

2014. Manual Trading vs Automatic Trading - Suggestions? (https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/23379)

2015. What is better: the auto trade with EAs or manual trade? (https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/63495)

2024. Do you trade manually or do you use a FX Robot? (https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/473233)

What are your successful way(s) of live forex trading ? ( Auto / Manual / Signal )
What are your successful way(s) of live forex trading ? ( Auto / Manual / Signal )
  • 2013.08.23
  • www.mql5.com
The author discusses their success in various trading methods, emphasizing that manual trading is the best approach despite the advantages of auto and semi-auto trading. They highlight the impact of news on automated strategies and stress the importance of manual oversight.
Minh Tue Le #:
The results only reflect those who voluntarily participated in the forum poll, and are not official statistics on all MT5 or MQL5 Community users.
Stated a bit more directly, "filter dysmorphia" will likely appear in the Poll. Sociologically, people prefer to portray themselves in the best light possible online.
Hi Minh,

voted. For me its both. I traded manually for a few years, but next to a full-time job I couldn't repeat the same thing twice, so I moved to EAs in 2024. Today I run several EAs on a few accounts and brokers.

Success for me is less about the best month and more about whether the EA live still does what it did in the test. Thats where most of my time goes now.

Thanks for collecting this :)
Chris
Ryan L Johnson #:
Stated a bit more directly, "filter dysmorphia" will likely appear in the Poll. Sociologically, people prefer to portray themselves in the best light possible online.

Yes sure. If i am in loss, I don't want to vote. Another purpose of this survey is to have a summary statistics for this post, besides the interview of some exceptional cases.

2026.  Success Stories in Algorithmic Trading - we need more of them! (https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/518588)

Success Stories in Algorithmic Trading - we need more of them!
Success Stories in Algorithmic Trading - we need more of them!
  • 2026.10.17
  • www.mql5.com
Algo-trading is challenging, with many traders finding no guaranteed system, leading to disillusionment and the need for methodical approaches. Real futures markets offer better opportunities than OTC CFD/FX markets, and personal growth through the process is often more valuable than financial gains.

In my trading journey, it hasn’t been completely smooth.

I do use automated bots (EAs), but when it comes to manual trading, I sometimes take trades without properly reading what the market is telling me. Manual trading can be emotional, and that has cost me before.

I’ve noticed that my EAs are actually trading fine. The real problem was me — interfering with the system, closing trades too early, or not trusting the strategy.

What I’ve learned is this:

It’s better to let the EAs trade on their own account, and if I want to trade manually, I should fund a separate account for that. Mixing both can create problems.

Closing trades manually can sometimes be a big mistake, depending on how the strategy is designed to behave.

So right now, I’m focusing more on trusting the system and staying disciplined.

Thanks for the question.

Honest answer: I don't have a long live track record yet. I've just started forward testing my system on a demo account, and I'll move to a small real account once I've confirmed that live trades match the backtest.
The approach: multi-timeframe trend following on XAUUSD.
Trend filter: H1 and H4 market structure (swing highs/lows) must point the same way. No trades when they disagree.
Entry: an M15 structure break in the trend direction. Only the first 3 breaks of each trend; later breaks are skipped because they performed much worse.
Risk: stop loss 6 × ATR, take profit 2R, break-even at +1R, max 3 positions, no grid or martingale.
Exit: TP/SL, when the H1/H4 trend stops agreeing, or after 24 hours.
What I know so far (backtest, not live):
Real-tick MT5 backtest 2021–2026: profit factor about 1.9, win rate about 41%, average winner about 2.7× average loser.
At 1% risk per trade, positive in 5 of 6 years. 2024 was flat, and the max drawdown was about 16%.
My Python research and the MT5 tester produce the same trades about 96% of the time, and the edge holds up against random entries with the same stops.
What I don't know yet: how it handles real fills, slippage and spreads over months. That's what the forward test is for. I'm happy to share updates as results come in.
What about you? Are you running something live right now?
Wasun Angkanapanit #:
Honest answer: I don't have a long live track record yet. I've just started forward testing my system on a demo account, and I'll move to a small real account once I've confirmed that live trades match the backtest.
The approach: multi-timeframe trend following on XAUUSD.
Trend filter: H1 and H4 market structure (swing highs/lows) must point the same way. No trades when they disagree.
Entry: an M15 structure break in the trend direction. Only the first 3 breaks of each trend; later breaks are skipped because they performed much worse.
Risk: stop loss 6 × ATR, take profit 2R, break-even at +1R, max 3 positions, no grid or martingale.
Exit: TP/SL, when the H1/H4 trend stops agreeing, or after 24 hours.
What I know so far (backtest, not live):
Real-tick MT5 backtest 2021–2026: profit factor about 1.9, win rate about 41%, average winner about 2.7× average loser.
At 1% risk per trade, positive in 5 of 6 years. 2024 was flat, and the max drawdown was about 16%.
My Python research and the MT5 tester produce the same trades about 96% of the time, and the edge holds up against random entries with the same stops.
What I don't know yet: how it handles real fills, slippage and spreads over months. That's what the forward test is for. I'm happy to share updates as results come in.
What about you? Are you running something live right now?
Hi Wasun,

thats pretty much how I'd do it too. Test first, then go small on real.

One thing from my side. On demo the fills and spreads are often nicer than on a real account, so the demo can match the backtest and the real account still won't. I'd move to the small real account rather early, even with minimum lots, and compare it trade by trade with a backtest over the same weeks.

I'd also keep an eye on the "first 3 breaks" rule. It came out of the backtest, so the live weeks are the first real test for it.

Good luck with it :)
Chris