M5 prints a sell divergence while M30 prints a buy — what would you do?

New comment
 
Hi everyone, I've been trading RSI divergences for a while, and there's still one situation that confuses me. Curious how more experienced guys handle it.
  • On my screenshot (H1 gold), at the same moment I have:
  • M5  -> sell divergence, 13 bars old
  • M15 -> buy divergence
  • M30 -> fresh buy divergence, 2 bars old
  • H1 and above -> nothing

So half of the screen shouts "buy" and the other half shouts "sell". 

My usual reaction is to wait for the higher timeframe to join in, or just skip the trade - but honestly I keep feeling I throw away decent setups.

So for those of you who actually trade this stuff:
When timeframes conflict like this, do you trust the higher TF, go with the majority, or just stand aside? How much weight does a divergence even carry in your decisions - main trigger, or just a confirmation? And how
long do you keep a divergence "alive"? I expire mine after about 15 candles, not sure if that's too strict.
Real experience only please! Thank you so much!


Mixed RSI Divergence signal  
 

Forum on trading, automated trading systems and testing trading strategies

GOLD, Gold and XAUUSD

Vitaly Muzichenko, 2026.08.16 20:00

That’s how you should trade

As soon as the final confirmation appears as a red square, go short

Basically, when all the indicators align and the trend has ‘run its course’ – that’s when you enter; this way, it won’t be like reading tea leaves 😁


 
Ryan L Johnson #:

Thanks Ryan! So the idea is: don't fight the conflict, just wait for full alignment on the higher TFs and treat that as the only green light.
Do you still use divergences at all in that setup, or purely the day/week/month alignment?
 
Le Uyen Phuong Nguyen #:
Thanks Ryan! So the idea is: don't fight the conflict, just wait for full alignment on the higher TFs and treat that as the only green light.
Do you still use divergences at all in that setup, or purely the day/week/month alignment?

That is a pocket post referring you to Vitaly Muzichenko who is a consistent MTF gold trader. There's relevant information posted by him in many pages of that thread. Check it out.

(Personally, I trade my own gold scalping EA on a single custom chart structure).

New comment