ChatGPT can create awesome EA? - page 7

New comment
 
Artur Jacek Domagala #:

The biggest problem is that ChatGPT does not automatically teach. It executes. When someone gives it the entire task from the beginning, they replace their own thinking with one impulse: “Chat will do it.”

In 2023, I had this bad idea, tried building experts and indicators with GPT3.5 and it was brutal, what it did help me do was understand the language quickly, I understood core concepts within weeks because of the debugging skills learnt along the way. 
This might be also because of the experience I have with C, have been learning C since a long while.
So yes, it did help teach me debugging, infact old codes from this project still exist, from Sonnet 3.5, 3.0, lots of crazy code that shows you how far AI has progressed. 
 
The only major program mql5 lacks are good libraries.
Mean libraries like tensorflow, all AI ML libraries use C/C++ underneath, so it is possible to bring them to Mql5 -

Support for GPUs using OpenCL exist.

Complex visualization from Mql5 Objects and Canvases.

Pure access to market data - no language has the data mql5 has, data from different forex brokers, to get such data on Python or JS isn’t easy or free, data is a bit plus. 

And Mql5 can do anything, Text to Speech or even anything with DLL import and others.

A community project to implement this libraries in mql5 would make a lot of positive impact.
 
Artur Jacek Domagala #:
AI can replace some of the coding but It cannot replace understanding.
I know that this is a ChatGPT thread, but we're all using AI and ChatGPT interchangeably. Therefore, I can tell you that agentic MT5 AI has gotten to know my terminal and I so well that it's a bit freaky. IMHO, there is no comparison of standalone ChatGPT verus MT5-integrated AI─the latter of which has total access of every symbol, chart, custom chart, price, volume, indicator, EA, script, service, settings, blah blah blah (you get the point) in the terminal... plus the web. It has literally given me tailored plain language trading strategies.
 
Bosco Antonio Vega #:
Sir, you should really do your research before you discredit the mt5 platform and call it's developers "liars". Yes, most of the paid EA's sell you a dream. But there are plenty of knowledgeable and honest developers on the platform. 

MetaTrader 5 already comes with a lot of built in math and modeling tools that developers have been using for years. The MQL5 Standard Library and the included ALGLIB package offer support for multilayer perceptrons with training and inference, several training methods, classification and regression, clustering, linear and nonlinear optimization, statistical analysis, probability distributions, matrix and vector operations, time series analysis, fuzzy logic, signal processing, digital filters, random number generation, and Monte Carlo methods.

If a developer needs more than that, MQL5 can also work with external DLLs, ONNX models, Python, REST APIs, and custom C plus plus libraries.

Calling every EA that uses machine learning a lie ignores the fact that the platform already includes machine learning and numerical optimization libraries. Whether an EA makes money is a separate issue from whether it uses those methods correctly.


Yeah I done my research thanks .I develop EA's myself .I know what's what and  the majority of EA's on here are trash , mutton dressed as lamb . 
 
Victor Paul Hamilton #:
[T]he majority of EA's on here are trash...
If anyone wants to verify that ☝, just prompt your AI to tell you about the mql5.com Market.
 

A black box EA is an automated trading system with a hidden strategy.

You are trusting the creator rather than understanding the edge.

What about price action Ea's or Helper bots.? To say all EA are rubbish is outrageous.

A well-built EA can improve discipline, remove emotional decisions, and help a trader execute a tested plan consistently.

 
AI is a tool
To put it very simply, you just need to know which side the monkey is on?

Either you resort to simply copying and pasting generated code into the IDE without understanding anything, or not understanding enough
Either you spend your time telling him what's wrong or not before sticking to the idea because you know exactly what you want
 
Jason Smith #:

A black box EA is an automated trading system with a hidden strategy.

You are trusting the creator rather than understanding the edge.

What about price action Ea's or Helper bots.? To say all EA are rubbish is outrageous.

A well-built EA can improve discipline, remove emotional decisions, and help a trader execute a tested plan consistently.

Who said all are rubbish , the majority are rubbish on here not all is what was stated and to learn to make your own is a wiser choice and with the A.I these days there is no excuse .No disrespect but I thought you were leaving this platform because of unfairness?, well many people will just bypass here because of asking certain questions on A.I about this space and go on and make their own EA's .I will say it again Metaquotes needs an overhaul of how things are done on here cause it should be dead in the water already ,The only thing keeping it afloat in the future would be certain external forces that I  have always had suspicions about in the first place regarding  sales etc be metaquotes wise to it or not !. 
 

What on earth has that got to do with you?

"But I thought you were leaving this platform because of unfairness."

You worry about your life, and I'll worry about mine.

 
Liang Zhang:
I am very interested in whether ChatGPT can create a very intelligent EA. Has anyone used ChatGPT to write an EA?
Hello!

ChatGPT is primarily a language model.

It is not an independent researcher.

It also tends to adapt to your level of knowledge in mathematics, trading, and programming, so the quality of its answers often depends on the quality of your own questions.

On its own, it is unlikely to invent a genuinely intelligent trading system for you. It will usually generate many possible ideas and approaches rather than discover a fundamentally new one.

However, if you already have your own concepts, hypotheses, or research direction, ChatGPT (and other AI models) can be an excellent tool for developing, refining, testing, and implementing those ideas at a very high level.
12345678
New comment