Поясните, в чем заключается некорректность примеров? Покажите или докажите... А так пустая болтовня.
The idle chatter is just you in this thread, better use the forum search. I have made a very specific point to you - you do not take into account the totality of the facts, all the situations. As it was in previous discussions. And to dive into debates about locks or explanations here - sorry, year after year there have been the same debates, both sides have just been full of holes, without any attempt at a full and objective investigation (that's a pretty strong word, but it means something quite simple). In the threads about lokas both the pillars of the forum participated, and casual visitors, and platform developers (and also a stubborn fellow categorically unwilling to perceive anything). And the hedgehog has no example-analogy at all, it's obvious.
kharko>>: На счет Граальчика вы зря иронизируете. И депо нужен не такой уж безразмерный. Если правильно задать параметры для вычисления возможного риска.. Еще раз перечитайте мое сообщение о пользе локов.
"Sho, again?" quote (Once upon a time there was a dog) ....
Sorry - you have a bit of a confused concept. Lock and Hedge are basically different approaches to trading. Not to repeat myself I will just give a link to spider - to the relevant thread - my old posts are there.
"Shaw, again?" - quote (cartoon "Once upon a time there was a dog") ....
Sorry - you have a bit of a confused concept. Lock and Hedge are basically different approaches to trading. Not to repeat myself I will just give a link to spider - to the relevant thread - my old posts are there.
Now that was interesting, but... denial is a far cry from creation. Your advice on how to be a trader when price moves 10-100p downwind of an open position You kind of combed out the hedging there as well.
Good advice on the Euribucks example i get a 5-10% lot of the eq. and at this point the position is in the range of -10-100 p ips
The usual standard situation when one is not ready to cut losses is when one is 51% sure that there is still some profit to be made on the position! I.e. the position has hit a pullback...
Вот это было интересным, но... отрицание - далеко-ооо от созидания Ваш совет как быть трейдеру при движении цены на 10-100п не по ветру открытой позы Вы там и хеджирование как бы причесали
Хорошо Ваш совет на примере пары Еврабакс лот 5-10% от еквити и в данный момент позиция лота в диапазоне - 10-100п
Обычная стандартная ситуация когда резать убытки рука не поднимается так увереность на 51% что на позе можно есче даже заработать! Т.е попала поза в откат...
Once again, there is no denial of locks per se in that thread. There's one statement there - lock does not give an advantage for trading. Even the Americans at the time tried to explain in a very popular way that opening a lock is equivalent to not having an open position. Then they gave up, but not for long, because the NFA made a mess of it. As for the trader's advice about waiting for the stop to execute or not: before opening a position, the trader should know the direction of the opening, the size of the position to be opened and the distance to the stop. If the system evaluates a possible profit, then also the distance to the limit. If any of these points are in doubt, it is more reasonable to "sit on the fence" - otherwise this is not a trader, but a gambler. And in this case any advice will not be effective: the drawdown is a matter of time and does not depend on the system.
Once again, there is no denial of locks per se in that thread. There's one statement there - lock does not give an advantage for trading. Even the Americans at the time tried to explain in a very popular way that opening a lock is equivalent to the absence of an open position. Then they gave up, but not for long, because the NFA made a mess of it. As for the trader's advice about waiting for the stop execution or non-execution: before opening a position, the trader should know the direction of the opening, the size of the position to be opened and the distance to the stop. If the system evaluates a possible profit, then also the distance to the limit. If any of these points are in doubt, it is more reasonable to "sit on the fence" - otherwise this is not a trader, but a gambler. And in this case any advice will not be effective: the drawdown is a matter of time and does not depend on the system.
... до открытия позиции трейдер должен знать направление открытия, размер открываемой позиции и расстояние до стопа. Если система оценивает возможный профит, то и расстояние до лимитника. Если какие-то из этих пунктов под сомнением, то разумней "сидеть на заборе" - иначе это не трейдер, а игрок.
I would like to join Vladislav in this statement. In my opinion, a trader is a person who evaluates the mathematical expectation, and a player is a person who evaluates the probability of that mathematical expectation occurring.
I didn't mean you personally - it's a general approach, and it's written in all the textbooks. And what prevents you from becoming a trader? If you have a system, the difference is discipline. (The question is rhetorical).
Еще раз - в той ветке нет отрицания локов как таковых. Там одно утверждение - лок преимущества для торговли не дает. Даже амеры в то время очень популярно пытались объяснить, что открытие лока эквивалентно отсутствию открытой позиции. Потом, правда, сдались, но не на долго - НФА всю малину поломало. По поводу совета трейдеру - ждать исполнения или не исполнения стопа : до открытия позиции трейдер должен знать направление открытия, размер открываемой позиции и расстояние до стопа. Если система оценивает возможный профит, то и расстояние до лимитника. Если какие-то из этих пунктов под сомнением, то разумней "сидеть на заборе" - иначе это не трейдер, а игрок. А в этом случае любые советы не будут эффективны: слив вопрос времени и от системы не зависит.
Удачи.
In my post I talked about the algorithm for opening a lock. The basis: taking a profit and waiting for a 50% pullback on the move. Pure technique to execute trading decisions - no system. I showed how to calculate the possible risks.
A similar technique is possible in hedging. The calculation becomes more complicated. It requires comparison of the position volumes of the pairs that are used for hedging.
Allow the use of cookies to log in to the MQL5.com website.
Please enable the necessary setting in your browser, otherwise you will not be able to log in.
You are signed in. Two-factor authentication has been disabled. Set it up again and scan a new QR code, or continue with two-factor authentication disabled.
OK Spartak rolled 8:1 so next time we will go out of the lock-up by splitting 8 orders
Поясните, в чем заключается некорректность примеров? Покажите или докажите... А так пустая болтовня.
And to dive into debates about locks or explanations here - sorry, year after year there have been the same debates, both sides have just been full of holes, without any attempt at a full and objective investigation (that's a pretty strong word, but it means something quite simple). In the threads about lokas both the pillars of the forum participated, and casual visitors, and platform developers (and also a stubborn fellow categorically unwilling to perceive anything).
And the hedgehog has no example-analogy at all, it's obvious.
На счет Граальчика вы зря иронизируете. И депо нужен не такой уж безразмерный. Если правильно задать параметры для вычисления возможного риска..
Еще раз перечитайте мое сообщение о пользе локов.
"Sho, again?" quote (Once upon a time there was a dog) ....
Sorry - you have a bit of a confused concept. Lock and Hedge are basically different approaches to trading. Not to repeat myself I will just give a link to spider - to the relevant thread - my old posts are there.
http://forex.kbpauk.ru/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=mm&Number=115844&Searchpage=4&Main=1018&Words=VG&topic=&Search=true#Post115844
Here I give the opinion of American brokers.
http://forex.kbpauk.ru/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=mm&Number=126295&Searchpage=4&Main=1018&Words=VG&topic=&Search=true#Post126295
In this chapter I will give my old posts.
In general, read and consider. Honestly - just sick of being urged to use a calculator.
Good luck.
Yeah, about the amers - that was before the NFA ban on loki.
"Shaw, again?" - quote (cartoon "Once upon a time there was a dog") ....
Sorry - you have a bit of a confused concept. Lock and Hedge are basically different approaches to trading. Not to repeat myself I will just give a link to spider - to the relevant thread - my old posts are there.
https://www.mql4.com/go?http%3A%2F%2Fforex.kbpauk.ru%2Fshowflat.php%3FCat%3D0%26amp%3BBoard%3Dmm%26amp%3BNumber%3D115844%26amp%3BSearchpage%3D4%26amp%3BMain%3D1018%26amp%3BWords%3DVG%26amp%3Btopic%3D%26amp%3BSearch%3Dtrue%23Post115844
Now that was interesting, but... denial is a far cry from creation.
Your advice on how to be a trader when price moves 10-100p downwind of an open position
You kind of combed out the hedging there as well.
Good advice on the Euribucks example
i get a 5-10% lot of the eq. and at this point the position is in the range of -10-100 p ips
The usual standard situation when one is not ready to cut losses is when one is 51% sure
that there is still some profit to be made on the position! I.e. the position has hit a pullback...
Вот это было интересным, но... отрицание - далеко-ооо от созидания
Ваш совет как быть трейдеру при движении цены на 10-100п не по ветру открытой позы
Вы там и хеджирование как бы причесали
Хорошо Ваш совет на примере пары Еврабакс
лот 5-10% от еквити и в данный момент позиция лота в диапазоне - 10-100п
Обычная стандартная ситуация когда резать убытки рука не поднимается так увереность на 51%
что на позе можно есче даже заработать! Т.е попала поза в откат...
Once again, there is no denial of locks per se in that thread. There's one statement there - lock does not give an advantage for trading. Even the Americans at the time tried to explain in a very popular way that opening a lock is equivalent to not having an open position. Then they gave up, but not for long, because the NFA made a mess of it.
As for the trader's advice about waiting for the stop to execute or not: before opening a position, the trader should know the direction of the opening, the size of the position to be opened and the distance to the stop. If the system evaluates a possible profit, then also the distance to the limit. If any of these points are in doubt, it is more reasonable to "sit on the fence" - otherwise this is not a trader, but a gambler. And in this case any advice will not be effective: the drawdown is a matter of time and does not depend on the system.
Good luck.
Once again, there is no denial of locks per se in that thread. There's one statement there - lock does not give an advantage for trading. Even the Americans at the time tried to explain in a very popular way that opening a lock is equivalent to the absence of an open position. Then they gave up, but not for long, because the NFA made a mess of it.
As for the trader's advice about waiting for the stop execution or non-execution: before opening a position, the trader should know the direction of the opening, the size of the position to be opened and the distance to the stop. If the system evaluates a possible profit, then also the distance to the limit. If any of these points are in doubt, it is more reasonable to "sit on the fence" - otherwise this is not a trader, but a gambler. And in this case any advice will not be effective: the drawdown is a matter of time and does not depend on the system.
>> Good luck.
Thanks, I get it - I'm a player.
Didn't get the point of that "Once more about the lokas". I don't think anyone has anything new to say....
... до открытия позиции трейдер должен знать направление открытия, размер открываемой позиции и расстояние до стопа. Если система оценивает возможный профит, то и расстояние до лимитника. Если какие-то из этих пунктов под сомнением, то разумней "сидеть на заборе" - иначе это не трейдер, а игрок.
I would like to join Vladislav in this statement. In my opinion, a trader is a person who evaluates the mathematical expectation, and a player is a person who evaluates the probability of that mathematical expectation occurring.
Спасибо я понял - я игрок
I didn't mean you personally - it's a general approach, and it's written in all the textbooks.And what prevents you from becoming a trader? If you have a system, the difference is discipline. (The question is rhetorical).
(The question is rhetorical.) Good luck.
Еще раз - в той ветке нет отрицания локов как таковых. Там одно утверждение - лок преимущества для торговли не дает. Даже амеры в то время очень популярно пытались объяснить, что открытие лока эквивалентно отсутствию открытой позиции. Потом, правда, сдались, но не на долго - НФА всю малину поломало.
По поводу совета трейдеру - ждать исполнения или не исполнения стопа : до открытия позиции трейдер должен знать направление открытия, размер открываемой позиции и расстояние до стопа. Если система оценивает возможный профит, то и расстояние до лимитника. Если какие-то из этих пунктов под сомнением, то разумней "сидеть на заборе" - иначе это не трейдер, а игрок. А в этом случае любые советы не будут эффективны: слив вопрос времени и от системы не зависит.
Удачи.
In my post I talked about the algorithm for opening a lock. The basis: taking a profit and waiting for a 50% pullback on the move.
Pure technique to execute trading decisions - no system. I showed how to calculate the possible risks.
A similar technique is possible in hedging. The calculation becomes more complicated. It requires comparison of the position volumes of the pairs that are used for hedging.