Is the advisor suitable for real life? - page 42

 
FOReignEXchange:


You must have misunderstood. Enter at the opening of the next minute candle. That's like entering at the opening of an hour candle. What do the ticks have to do with it?

I simply looked through the old code at the entry points which are worse or equal to the candle's close point. Consequently, if you do not enter at the opening of the next candle instead of inside it, the result will not be at least the same. I have recognized one type of such candlesticks and that's all. I made the code at the opening of the next candle. I made a test and it seems to be good.

Now I want to make the second kind of candlesticks and open at the opening of the next one.

I do not understand all the same. You enter at the opening and take profit on pseudo-movement!

If you test on the open prices, you can still call it a result. On ticks, though in the middle of a candle, though in the beginning, though 2/3 - it makes no difference where the entrance is. After the entrance, the tester passes to the next counter-point like on skis. In reality the price may stand in one place for 10 ticks, and at the 11th tick it may jump to close, and that's all - the candle is drawn. Of course, there are a million variations.

 
OnGoing:

You still don't get it. You enter on the opening and profit on the movement of pseudotrades!


What does that have to do with the profit? Profit and stop are fixed, not on an exit signal. The pseudoticks will not affect it. If only within a minute, the price will go back and forth 15-20 pips several times.

 

FOReignEXchange:


What does this have to do with profit? Profit and stop are fixed, not by signal exit. Pseudoticks will have no effect. If only within a minute, the price will go back and forth 15-20 pips several times.

Well, well, do you think the candlesticks are drawn by the girl-operator at the broker?

If the pattern of a one-minute candlestick may indicate a price movement of 15-20 pips. in a certain direction)) well, haven't you tried to write a fiction? you would succeed.

 
OnGoing:

FOReignEXchange:


What does profit have to do with it? Profit and stop are fixed, not by signal exit. Pseudoticks will have no effect. If only within a minute, the price will go back and forth 15-20 pips several times.

You think the candlesticks are drawn by a girl operator at a broker?

If the pattern of any one-minute candlestick could mean a 15-20 pips price movement in a certain direction)) - well, haven't you tried to write fiction? you would be good at it.


Do you think it is unreal to find a system with a 10% deviation towards profit on the chart? Well, then it turns out to be a casino, where you play against the numbers and lose 3% from each bet. Then no one makes profit on Forex. Or do only martingale traders, who stop in time and leave, make profit?
 
I'm just saying, it's a bit too easy. But it's a long way to go.
 
FOReignEXchange:

You think it's unrealistic to find a system with a 10% profit margin on a chart? Then it is a casino, where you play against the numbers and lose 5% on every bet. Then no one makes profit on Forex. Or do only martingale traders, who stop in time and leave, make profit?

Exactly, only they are today) And by the way the picture shows that you also pyramid. And that is probably why you do not dare to show the test for a year for example.
 
OnGoing:
Exactly, they are the only ones to date) And by the way, the picture shows that you are also pyramiding. And that is probably why you do not dare to show the test for a year, for example.

I cannot do the test yet. I will contact the support tomorrow and ask them where their quotes history is available. What do you mean by pyramid? The lot is constant, stops are fixed.
 
FOReignEXchange:

I can't do the test yet. I will contact the support tomorrow and ask where I can get their quotes history. What do you mean by pyramid? The lot is constant, stops are fixed.

It means adding to the position, both in profit and in loss. And this is double the risk, and a fixed lot is not the same here.

Anyway, run the test in a year, don't make me laugh with 50 trades.

 
OnGoing:

It means adding to the position, both in profit and in loss. And this is double the risk, and a fixed lot is not the same here.

In general, run the test in a year then, don't be ridiculous with 50 trades.


I don't want to make anyone laugh. You asked. And there are no supplements. All trades are by signal only. Signal - open - stops - close - end.
 
OnGoing:
Exactly, they are the only ones to date)


Well I have a different opinion. Have you seen, for example, how systems made profits on a bounce off channels from 2000 to 2008 on the euro? The Eurodollar used to have much lower volatility and anti-trend systems worked there. Now nothing that works any more. I cannot say what the reason is, but I think the reason is the development of communications, the forex boom and the global instability. And the Eurodollar pair has become central, because it represents two poles. Because of all this, the trading volume is increasing. It has become more difficult to work, but something, I think, is still working.

Reason: