Transaction volume - page 2
You are missing trading opportunities:
- Free trading apps
- Over 8,000 signals for copying
- Economic news for exploring financial markets
Registration
Log in
You agree to website policy and terms of use
If you do not have an account, please register
The main thing is the trading.
Do the volumes in the right methodologies produce results? - They do! I.e. volume is real volumes, not ticks.
In fact, what was all that fuss about volumes?
It was someone who invented something, but it did not work. It happens. But, no, you keep making noise.
that the author's idea is right, but the volumes are wrong.
so they are different, so their brokers are different, but what's important?
The main thing is the trading.
The main thing is that the main thing is that the volumes in the right methods give results? - They do! I.e. volume is real volumes, not ticks.
In fact, what was all that fuss about volumes?
It was someone who invented something, but it did not work. It happens. But, no, you keep making noise.
that the author's idea is right, but the volumes are wrong.
Let's take two DTs.
1st one was a D1 with 14,000 volumes.
2-dc gave the same day volume of 56000 on the same D1 pair
how do you explain this ?
---
from your point of view
different brokerages! it turns out one broker gets reliable information and the other - a phony? which he broadcasts to his customers
---
maybe methods with volumes GIVE RESULTS but how the method will give results in the case described above
----
VOLUME - IS NOT THE VOLUME OF THE WORLD at the current moment in the market
Exchange trading is now offered as a public offer (an advertising offer to enter into a contractual relationship).
The list of contractual relationships includes trading price signals:
Bid, Ask, Close, Open, High, Low and volumes - Volume.
What happens if the terms of the offer are violated by the trader?
There will be a court, fines, damages, etc. Read the civil code.
So, Volumes are the real volumes.
Otherwise, everyone has enemies, and they will sue for deceiving the consumer. (You, too, should sue for fraud and loss of profits)))).
Now what are these volumes.
Are the volumes world volumes?
Yes, volumes can be world volumes, brokers need to whistle for that.
But.
Is it compulsory to give users of free MT-4 world volumes?
No, not obligatory.
It is enough to give the volumes of a certain broker(FOREX) or a certain exchange (CFD), but world volumes are also possible.
Either way, the offer will not be violated.
Now, what for the broker needs volumes?
And the broker needs the volumes like air - he is the broker who provides the leverage.
It is vitally important for the broker that the volumes Ask/Bid coincide, otherwise he will go bankrupt.
In other words, the broker sets some maximal difference in the volumes of Ask/Bid from his stream of orders and in case of its exceeding he announces a trading pause to make it go away.
And we think that in case of a sharp fall, for example, when the broker stops the trading, he allegedly saves the World.
No, the broker saves himself, and he has every right to do so.
So, the broker asks/Bid volumes is much more important than the current quote. (because the broker invests his money in leverage)
We, the free ones, are informed about the total volume of Ask/Bid as a rule of one broker, (maybe due to kindness of the world), but it is also good.
Since a normal brokerage company has also a powerful broker, i.e. it is global.
The dynamics of volumes of the strong broker corresponds to the world ones. And it is enough.
Exchange trading is now offered as a public offer (an advertising offer to enter into a contractual relationship).
The list of contractual relationships includes trading price signals:
Bid, Ask, Close, Open, High, Low and volumes - Volume.
What happens if the terms of the offer are violated by the trader?
There will be a court, fines, damages, etc. Read the civil code.
So Volumes are real volumes after all.
Otherwise, everyone has enemies, and they will sue for deceiving the consumer. (You, too, should sue for fraud and loss of profits)))).
Now what are these volumes.
Are the volumes world volumes?
Yes, volumes can be world volumes, brokers need to whistle for that.
But.
Is it compulsory to give users of free MT-4 world volumes?
No, not obligatory.
It is enough to give the volumes of a certain broker(FOREX) or a certain exchange (CFD), but world volumes are also possible.
Either way, the offer will not be violated.
Now, what for the broker needs volumes?
And the broker needs the volumes like air - he is the broker who provides the leverage.
It is vitally important for the broker that the volumes Ask/Bid coincide, otherwise he will go bankrupt.
In other words, the broker sets some maximal difference in the volumes of Ask/Bid from his stream of orders and in case of its exceeding he announces a trading pause to make it go away.
And we think that in case of a sharp fall, for example, when the broker stops the trading, he allegedly saves the World.
No, the broker saves himself, and he has every right to do so.
So, the broker asks/Bid volumes is much more important than the current quote. (because the broker invests his money in leverage)
We, the free ones, are informed about the total volume of Ask/Bid as a rule of one broker, (maybe due to kindness of the world), but it is also good.
Since a normal brokerage company has also a powerful broker, i.e. it is global.
The dynamics of volumes of the strong broker corresponds to the world ones. And this is enough.
this is what it says about VOLUME - it's a collection of tics.
There is only this: iVolume - In the MQL4 Reference there is a clear description of this function.
Returns the value of tick volume of the bar specified by the shift parameter from the corresponding chart(symbol, timeframe). In case of error, the function returns 0. For more information about the error, call GetLastError().
For the current chart, information about the tick volumes of each bar is located in the predefined array Volume[].
Volumes provide very important information. Volumes are well studied. Volume is volumes.
If volumes are wrong in a brokerage company, it may happen, but why should we break TA?
Selection of a brokerage company is voluntary))).
Here we get to the bottom of why TA doesn't work in forex...
The AC was developed by our grandfathers for the Stock Market, where there are real volumes - the real money that investors pay. There is no such information on forex-casinos, but there are twitches - ticks. In addition, the grandfathers analysed daily candles, not minute candles. If you think about it, there are many more differences. We simply apply their ideas to forex, try to hammer nails with a microscope and are surprised that it does not work so well.
The list of contractual relationships includes trading price signals:
Bid, Ask, Close, Open, High, Low and Volume.
What happens if the terms of the offer are violated by the bidder?
There will be a court, fines, damages, etc. Read the civil code.
So Volumes are real volumes after all.
The list of contractual relationships includes trading price signals:
Bid, Ask, Close, Open, High, Low and Volume.
What happens if the terms of the offer are violated by the bidder?
There will be a court, fines, damages, etc. Read the civil code.
So Volumes are the real volumes after all.
Korey
You're wrong - THE DEVELOPERS TELL YOU!!!
"Returns the value of the tick volume."
----you hope you will not assert that the tic "VOLUME" is the real volume put on the market
the quantity of TICKS is not the VOLUME in the sense that you are interpreting it.
---1. to YuraZ
Bid volume is the volume of open interest = supply.
Ask volume is the volume of the open interval = demand
Tick volume is total Bid+Ask.
I.e. "Tick volume" is not the sum of ticks, but the sum per tick. And by a "tick" we mean any step, in our case a period. In English, a day is a tick.
to timbo
2. The TA works very well in Forex. (Note: those who created TA have never worked every day like now))).
3. The civil code is nonsense?
P.S.
By the way, the basic rule of the stock exchange is to trade lots, i.e. fixed, predetermined volumes.
So the tick volume can be the sum of lots, and just as well it can be the sum of money = number of lots x cost per lot.
Both do not spoil TA.
1. to YuraZ
Bid volume is the volume of open interest = supply.
Ask volume is the volume of open interval = demand
Tick volume is total Bid+Ask.
I.e. "Tick" is not the sum of ticks, but the sum per tick. And by a "tick" we mean any step, in our case a period. In English, a day is a tick.
to timbo
2. The TA works very well in Forex. (Note: those who created TA never worked every day like now))).
3. The civil code is nonsense?
P.S.
By the way, the basic rule of the stock exchange is to trade lots, i.e. fixed, predetermined volumes.
So the tick volume can be the sum of lots, and just as well it can be the sum of money = number of lots x cost per lot.
Both do not spoil TA.
per TICK VOLUME is simply increased by +1
write a simple crypt or Expert Advisor and see
it will not increase by 40 or 100 in one tick! because it is just the TICK volume and not the actual volume from the market
to YuraZ
Re-read the posts - it's the same and the same thing - there's an idea with volumes and it doesn't work!!!
Whose fault is that?
Get the right idea from the right author,
on Crawford lies
Farley's "Mastering Swing Trading", and try the TA method of "identifying hidden strong levels" from there.