Keep it simple - page 6

To add comments, please log in or register
a1ra
48
a1ra  
MeGaXwOrM:
need answer..

hi, need explanation please..

Question..

1. what is the different between TopTrend and PriceChannel indicator?

2. what is the different between Heiken_Ashi_kuskus2 and Heiken_Ashi_smoothed?

this all indicators look related each other..so what the diffrent? which one better?

hope can get answer from anybody..thanks for advance

1. Well, don't know to much about top trend. But by looking at the picture, both of them done the same thing. It showing where the trend start and where its end. Also identical with "bband stop" n "volty channel stop". Usually include ATR n money risk calculation. The last price channel i know was created by igorad somewhere arround here "PriceChannel_Signal_v1.2"

2. Heiken Ashi, was made with a purpose "trading with less noise". You can check it on parameter setting, if consist 2 ma period n ma setting, basically will gave the same result. There is alot of variant, "Hull ma", "T3 heiken ashi", "heiken ashi ma bar", "heiken ashi overlay". You may also consider checking HAMA pad thread started by fxcruiser.

Just my 2cent, hope its help

a1ra
48
a1ra  

Not allowed to edit post yet

Forgot one more ...

about which one better, in my opinion they are all gave identical result. So pick the most pleasant in your eyes, the one that look nice on your chart

Another 2cent from noob

BT2
6
BT2  

Well spotted - thanks so much

mladen:
Be carefull when using the "heiken ashi smoothed" indicators.

There is a coding error in them. This part :

maOpen = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,MODE_OPEN ,pos);

maClose = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,MODE_CLOSE,pos);

maLow = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,MODE_LOW ,pos);

maHigh = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,MODE_HIGH ,pos);

[/php]should be like this :

[php] maOpen = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,PRICE_OPEN ,pos);

maClose = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,PRICE_CLOSE,pos);

maLow = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,PRICE_LOW ,pos);

maHigh = iMA(NULL,0,MaPeriod,0,MaMetod,PRICE_HIGH ,pos);

_______________________

Compared are the MODE_ parameters (that are used in that code instead of PRICE_ parameters) and the PRICE_ parameters for moving average (the only one that is the same is high):

MODE_OPEN 0 Open price.

MODE_LOW 1 Low price.MODE_HIGH 2 High price.MODE_CLOSE 3 Close price.

PRICE_CLOSE 0 Close price.PRICE_OPEN 1 Open price.

PRICE_HIGH 2 High price.PRICE_LOW 3 Low price.

_______________________

From the code, it is obvious that those are not the values that are intended to be calculated, and only the min and max are saving indicator from making a huge error. Attached are the corrected ones

Hi mladen

Good work on spotting that error.

Thanks so much for the way you help us newbs & the other not-so-newbs.

I'm meant to be learning to trade, but this programing bug keeps getting in the way.

cheers bt2

chris_swiss
177
chris_swiss  

Could s.o. upload two charts, please, one with the rigth indicator code and the other with the fault one?, ...,working out the optical difference.

Kindest regards

fairose
113
fairose  

to zeman

where r u? lol

kompakt_74
3
kompakt_74  

Need help to modify HAMA indicator

Hi

I need help to modify a Heiken ashi MA indicator.

I would like to had an alert with sound when the indicator color change (after the close of the bar)

And I would like to had and email alert.

I searched the forum but I didn't find this version of HAMA.

If someone have a little time, could you give me the right code because I'm a little lost with MT4 langage....

Thanks a lot.

Files:
Ernestas
29
Ernestas  
kompakt_74:
Hi

I need help to modify a Heiken ashi MA indicator.

I would like to had an alert with sound when the indicator color change (after the close of the bar)

And I would like to had and email alert.

I searched the forum but I didn't find this version of HAMA.

If someone have a little time, could you give me the right code because I'm a little lost with MT4 langage....

Thanks a lot.

Hi.. look in #19 post.. there some corrected "Heiken Ashi"indicators...

mydien01
5
mydien01  

i need a guide to trade....somebody help me....tq

xx3xxx
1754
xx3xxx  

a gap , between 2 indicator -- could it mean something

the error don't seem to be much of a bigger deal -- in the charts

but the gap between 2 henki -- could be a good guide -- to place our SAFETY entry or stop though

attach the dig -- the resulting chart

henry
82
henry  

I have been searching for a non repainting Heiken ashi arrows with alert but could not get any.can someone help me out?

To add comments, please log in or register