Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen
Marco Montemari  

What do you think of this indicator?

 Let me know please

Sergei Lebedev  

Seems to be very promising Renko-indicator, however there are a lot of free Renko indicators, and it is impossible to draw any valid conclusion regarding real value of this particular indicator, including paid version with possibility of changing means values (e.g. it is obvious that with any randomly chosen set of means values the performance will be as bad as with default set of values). So I would suggest to create a project and to create a team of interested traders to continue working on parameters optimization in form of project.

Marco Montemari  
Gladiator WXT #:

Seems to be very promising Renko-indicator, however there are a lot of free Renko indicators, and it is impossible to draw any valid conclusion regarding real value of this particular indicator, including paid version with possibility of changing means values (e.g. it is obvious that with any randomly chosen set of means values the performance will be as bad as with default set of values). So I would suggest to create a project and to create a team of interested traders to continue working on parameters optimization in form of project.

First of all thanks for your comment, I appreciate it.
The indicator evolved since the first version based on suggestions/needs of users. Actually I am not developing it anymore, I just realeased a feature that I did in the past but I never published before about the possibility of change the trend after a threshold based on a set number of bricks. The averages can be good for a multi entry/exit but obviosuly it depends of the asset and volatility and we all know it can change a lot during some periods.
Thanks again.

[Gelöscht]  
Terrible indicator initial set-up. It is delayed by default. So how can I test it to see if it is working properly? What if it is delayed to hide non-working properly indicator? We cant evaluate delayed indicators. Lame. 
Cristian Mateo Duque Ocampo  


Hello, I have a question regarding your indicator, in the image you can see that the price has dropped considerably, but no new red renko candles were drawn, how much the price has to drop to draw a red candle? does this mean that the indicator does not draw a single red candle when the price drops, but it would draw 3 or more red candles?


Hola tengo una pregunta respecto a tu indicador, en la imagen se puede apreciar que el precio bajo considerablemente, pero no se dibujaron nuevas velas renko de color rojo, que tanto tiene que bajar el precio para que dibuje una vela roja? significa esto que el indicador no dibuja una sola vela roja cuando el precio baja, sino que de golpe dibujaría 3 o mas velas rojas?.

Marco Montemari  
Cristian Mateo Duque Ocampo #:


Hello, I have a question regarding your indicator, in the image you can see that the price has dropped considerably, but no new red renko candles were drawn, how much the price has to drop to draw a red candle? does this mean that the indicator does not draw a single red candle when the price drops, but it would draw 3 or more red candles?


Hola tengo una pregunta respecto a tu indicador, en la imagen se puede apreciar que el precio bajo considerablemente, pero no se dibujaron nuevas velas renko de color rojo, que tanto tiene que bajar el precio para que dibuje una vela roja? significa esto que el indicador no dibuja una sola vela roja cuando el precio baja, sino que de golpe dibujaría 3 o mas velas rojas?.

Hello,

in this indicator you can set the "delay" when there is a change of the trend. If you check the settings you can see the property X bricks delay.
Let me know if you have some other questions. Thanks 

singalong66  

I tried every way to make this renko reflect the chart above but it doesn't seem to follow the right direction, almost like the opposite direction.  what can i do to make it work.  


thanks.

Dateien:
GBPUSDM1.png  77 kb
Marco Montemari  
singalong66 #:

I tried every way to make this renko reflect the chart above but it doesn't seem to follow the right direction, almost like the opposite direction.  what can i do to make it work.  


thanks.

Hello, renko does not work as you expect. The chart you attached is a value changing on the time. In renko time does not exist.

Renko charts ignore time and show price movement only.

  • A new brick is drawn only when price moves by a fixed amount (e.g. 10 points).

  • If price doesn’t move enough → no new brick, even if hours pass.

  • Bricks go up or down only; small noise is filtered out.

 Result: clear trends, less noise, great for trend following and support/resistance.

You can use the date shown in the renko  chart on top right corner. Moving the mouse it will show which is the related date. Have a look to the attached image please.

Dateien:
Untitled.png  56 kb
tradeking2008  

There is something very wrong with this Renko indicator.   Renko bars are not time based, but they should still follow the general trend of the original price bars.  This Renko indicator is not following price trends at all.   It moves opposite the underlying price most of the time.  

I'm hoping you could look at the calculations for this indicator and fix it because you've done a great job creating this indicator, but unfortunately it does not work at all.

Marco Montemari  
tradeking2008 #:

There is something very wrong with this Renko indicator.   Renko bars are not time based, but they should still follow the general trend of the original price bars.  This Renko indicator is not following price trends at all.   It moves opposite the underlying price most of the time.  

I'm hoping you could look at the calculations for this indicator and fix it because you've done a great job creating this indicator, but unfortunately it does not work at all.

Second screenshot is from TradingView. Have a nice day
Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen