Pueden dejar comentarios los usuarios que hayan comprado o alquilado el producto
12
Byunghak Kim  

Hello, 

I'm backtesting the EA. 

Can you please check the following two things?


1. Trade Direction:

Even when I set the trade direction to 'only short,' long trades occur, and vice versa.

Refer to the attached images.



2. No New Entry if Trades exists:

When set to "true",  I believe [next trade after X bars] is necessary.

Otherwise, too many trades may occur at similar price levels.

Biswarup Banerjee  
kinao #:

Hello, 

I'm backtesting the EA. 

Can you please check the following two things?


1. Trade Direction:

Even when I set the trade direction to 'only short,' long trades occur, and vice versa.

Refer to the attached images.



2. No New Entry if Trades exists:

When set to "true",  I believe [next trade after X bars] is necessary.

Otherwise, too many trades may occur at similar price levels.

Added these two fixes in new version. New input name is  Next open trade after x second [0: disable]

Byunghak Kim  
Thank you for the continued version updates.
I have been using this EA since version 1.0 and running it on a real account with my own settings.

Overall, I am very satisfied, but I would like to make a suggestion and report a bug.


1. GENERAL SETTINGS : No New Entry If Trade Exists(true)

     In the scenario where there's an active buy position, I want to ignore only buy signals and still want to take sell signal entries.                                                                                                                                                             Conversely, if there's an active sell position, I want to ignore further sell signals and want to take buy signal orders.

     In the current setting, when there's an active position, all subsequent signals,regardless of whether they are buy or sell, are ignored.


2.GRID SETTINGS : Execution Mode(pending orders)

     Even after all grid orders are closed, the pending order is not automatically deleted.                                                                                                                                                                                                                           It continuously repeats being deleted and reopened.Even if manually deleted, it reopens again, so I have to restart MetaTrader to completely remove it.

Biswarup Banerjee  
kinao #:
Thank you for the continued version updates.
I have been using this EA since version 1.0 and running it on a real account with my own settings.

Overall, I am very satisfied, but I would like to make a suggestion and report a bug.


1. GENERAL SETTINGS : No New Entry If Trade Exists(true)

     In the scenario where there's an active buy position, I want to ignore only buy signals and still want to take sell signal entries.                                                                                                                                                             Conversely, if there's an active sell position, I want to ignore further sell signals and want to take buy signal orders.

     In the current setting, when there's an active position, all subsequent signals,regardless of whether they are buy or sell, are ignored.


2.GRID SETTINGS : Execution Mode(pending orders)

     Even after all grid orders are closed, the pending order is not automatically deleted.                                                                                                                                                                                                                           It continuously repeats being deleted and reopened.Even if manually deleted, it reopens again, so I have to restart MetaTrader to completely remove it.

Thanks a lot for bug report I will fix this
Biswarup Banerjee  
Biswarup Banerjee #:
Thanks a lot for bug report I will fix this

for scenario 1:
No need of new input. it will complicate things. I have a better solution. You put the Ea in 2 charts . One chart select trade direction "Only Buy" and in other select "Only Sell" runt them with different magic number.

for scenario 2:
it was a valid bug and the fix has been provided in the latest version. Please check. 

Byunghak Kim  

As advised, I have been operating buy and sell separately, as per your suggestion in Scenario 1. Thank you for your kind response.

And I am reporting another potential bug.

Today(6/3), as soon as the market opened, a buy entry occurred on NZDCAD even though the RSI trade conditions (upper level:70, lower level:30) were not met. Additionally, since there was an active sell trade already, another buy trade should not have occurred.

It seems like the issue might have occurred due to widened spreads right after the market opened. If it's a bug, please fix it. Thank you.

Biswarup Banerjee  
kinao #:

As advised, I have been operating buy and sell separately, as per your suggestion in Scenario 1. Thank you for your kind response.

And I am reporting another potential bug.

Today(6/3), as soon as the market opened, a buy entry occurred on NZDCAD even though the RSI trade conditions (upper level:70, lower level:30) were not met. Additionally, since there was an active sell trade already, another buy trade should not have occurred.

It seems like the issue might have occurred due to widened spreads right after the market opened. If it's a bug, please fix it. Thank you.

ok I will check this.  hopefully in next version it is going to be fixed

Fernando Ribeiro  

Hello!

Overall, I am very happy this EA. Congratulatios!

I am backtesting it and found a issue:

-- when I set up to FALSE to "Trade on New Bar" (see print below), EA launched many trades (for the same pair) at the same time at the same price and the same direction.

Could you please verify this issue?  Thanks.



Biswarup Banerjee  
Fernando Ribeiro #:

Hello!

Overall, I am very happy this EA. Congratulatios!

I am backtesting it and found a issue:

-- when I set up to FALSE to "Trade on New Bar" (see print below), EA launched many trades (for the same pair) at the same time at the same price and the same direction.

Could you please verify this issue?  Thanks.



Thanks for reporting  I will check and let you know
Biswarup Banerjee  
Biswarup Banerjee #:
Thanks for reporting  I will check and let you know
I have fixed that problem. Can you check now by updating it to latest version?
Fernando Ribeiro  
Many thanks.. I Will test it.. one question:  If trade on New bar is False and  No New entry If trade exists is also False, I understand that If I have a 15 min chart, for example,  EA Will launch a new trade when gets to the defined RSI level, correct?  If It gets to defined RSI at 10:34 am EA    Will launch New trade and do not wait until 10:45, is that correct? My main concern is with news that may shake prices rapidly. Thanks.
Biswarup Banerjee  
Fernando Ribeiro #:
Many thanks.. I Will test it.. one question:  If trade on New bar is False and  No New entry If trade exists is also False, I understand that If I have a 15 min chart, for example,  EA Will launch a new trade when gets to the defined RSI level, correct?  If It gets to defined RSI at 10:34 am EA    Will launch New trade and do not wait until 10:45, is that correct? My main concern is with news that may shake prices rapidly. Thanks.
For that reason I have put the trade on Newbar, because on a same candle it may cross up down multiple times
Fernando Ribeiro  

Link you sent is for EA-Bollinger files (and not for RSI) . Can you check again since I would like to have for 

RSI OverBought OverSold EA MT5? Thanks
Fernando Ribeiro  

Hello! I have been using  the version 14.0 and it works very well.

However, this week I installed the newest version 17.0 to test it, but it seems this version has an error: selected profit and loss per AMOUNT and it is not working: trades are being closed in a profit and loss much different from the numbers inserted in the EA. Follows attached file as an example.

Could you please verify this problem on version 17.0?

Archivos adjuntos:
Biswarup Banerjee  
Fernando Ribeiro #:

Hello! I have been using  the version 14.0 and it works very well.

However, this week I installed the newest version 17.0 to test it, but it seems this version has an error: selected profit and loss per AMOUNT and it is not working: trades are being closed in a profit and loss much different from the numbers inserted in the EA. Follows attached file as an example.

Could you please verify this problem on version 17.0?

Ok I will check and get back to you, in the mean time , can you check the exit condition selected. Earlier it was no exit condition by default.  I added an extra enty and exit condition that may be selected by default which closing the trades
Biswarup Banerjee  
Biswarup Banerjee #:
Ok I will check and get back to you, in the mean time , can you check the exit condition selected. Earlier it was no exit condition by default.  I added an extra enty and exit condition that may be selected by default which closing the trades

I checked the your set file , the reason for which it is closing amount is much different is the "condition check mode" input . Earliar it was everytick now the default has been changed to every period. If you change back to every tick the results are back to normal again. 
every period only calculated at the candle begining, it is better option for some traders for faster backtesting. Please check and let me know after setting it to every tick mode

Byunghak Kim  

Hello!

I've been using this EA since version 1.0 and have been running version 9.0 with my own custom settings.Thanks to this EA, I've earned more than 30 times the purchase price, and I've been very satisfied.

Today, I upgraded to version 17.0, but I noticed that, unlike in version 9.0, I can no longer set both Grid / Hedge to true at the same time. This feature is crucial to my strategy.

Could you modify version 17.0 to enable simultaneous use again? Alternatively, is there a way to obtain version 9.0 separately?

RSI

Pueden dejar comentarios los usuarios que hayan comprado o alquilado el producto
12