how broker can found Expert List installed on user program?

New comment
 

hi

if user installed some experts and robots on mt5 in windows How broker can find  List of experts or if user have expert or not. it is mossible ?


Question 2 -- if user make market order manuallity but modify that by EA  broker can find   modify way is not manuallity ?

 

The broker can not found it.
This is reply from MQ - 

Форум по трейдингу, автоматическим торговым системам и тестированию торговых стратегий

Do brokers see the installed EAs

Renat Fatkhullin, 2017.02.19 13:22

The question constantly pops up, the answers were repeatedly given.

Never any broker sees and does not have access to the trader's computer, does not know and does not have access to his robots or any other programs.

But each order has a type of reason, which indicates how it was created - manually or by experts.

...

 
Sergey Golubev #:

The broker can not found it.
This is reply from MQ - 


thanks alot.

Now my question is this:

if i made market position and set TP and STOP for it by expert (modify open position set tp and stop loss)  how about this?  how they find how i modified manual position ?

 

i attached one screenshot. after manual market order i can set fast tp stop by Expert.

my broker say expert is not allowed in prop . so if i modify opened position and modify it by expert how they can or cant find this ?

Files:
1.jpg  28 kb
 
The broker is able to know (if the broker wants to know but I am sure - the broker does not want to know): manual trading or by EA. Because every order has a type which indicates about how it was created - manually or by EA. That's all. The broker can not know the name of your EA and can not access to it.
And I am sure - the brokers do not care about it at all.
 
Jafar Ashkany #: i attached one screenshot. after manual market order i can set fast tp stop by Expert. my broker say expert is not allowed in prop . so if i modify opened position and modify it by expert how they can or cant find this ?

As already stated in post #1 ... "But each order has a type of reason, which indicates how it was created - manually or by experts. "

So, a broker or prop-firm knows when transactions are carried out by an EA or manual operation.

If the prop-firm or broker does not allow EA operations, change your broker or find another prop-firm.
 
Sergey Golubev #:
The broker is able to know (if the broker wants to know but I am sure - the broker does not want to know): manual trading or by EA. Because every order has a type which indicates about how it was created - manually or by EA. That's all. The broker can not know the name of your EA and can not access to it.
And I am sure - the brokers do not care about it at all.
ok but my second quastion is that what about modify positin and set TP / stoploss .  can it posibble they found its by EA or manuallity ?
 
Jafar Ashkany #: ok but my second quastion is that what about modify positin and set TP / stoploss .  can it posibble they found its by EA or manuallity ?

ALL transactions have an identifier that "knows" if it was carried out by manual or automated method.

So, it does not matter if it is placing an order, or modifying a position, or closing it. Each transaction can identify if it was done by an EA or not.

 

How about a hybrid EA/auto-clicker? The idea would be to use an EA connected to a Windows application to programmatically click the MT5 trading buttons. Of course, the on-chart Quick Trading Buttons would be easier to incorporate than order modifications. (This would be well beyond my abilities, if it's even possible.)

New comment